TITLE

GROUP APPROACHES FOR IMPROVING STRATEGIC DECISION MAKING: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF DIALECTICAL INQUIRY, DEVIL'S ADVOCACY, AND CONSENSUS

AUTHOR(S)
Schweiger, David M.; Sandberg, William R.; Ragan, James W.
PUB. DATE
March 1986
SOURCE
Academy of Management Journal;Mar1986, Vol. 29 Issue 1, p51
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
This laboratory study compared the effectiveness of the dialectical inquiry, devil's advocacy, and consensus approaches to strategic decision making by groups. Results showed that both dialectical inquiry and devil's advocacy led to higher quality recommendations and assumptions than consensus. Dialectical inquiry was also more effective than devil's advocacy with respect to the quality of assumptions brought to the surface. However, subjects in the consensus groups expressed more satisfaction and desire to continue to work with their groups and greater acceptance of their groups' decisions than did subjects in either of the two other types of group studied.
ACCESSION #
4395094

 

Related Articles

  • ORGANIZATIONAL CRISES AND THE DISTURBANCE OF RELATIONAL SYSTEMS. KAHN, WILLIAM A.; BARTON, MICHELLE A.; FELLOWS, STEVEN // Academy of Management Review;Jul2013, Vol. 38 Issue 3, p377 

    Various bodies of literature attest to how crises significantly damage the way people relate with one another-damage that lasts long past the cessation of those crises. Such relational disturbances are problematic in terms of crisis management theory. If crises are understood to be operationally...

  • Group Decision and Negotiation in Strategy Making. Eden, Colin; Ackermann, Fran // Group Decision & Negotiation;Mar2001, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p119 

    For a large number of organisations effective delivery of strategy depends upon the psychological and emotional commitment of the Top Management Team (TMT) thus involving group negotiation and decision making. Computer based group support promoting open debate and developing commitment is...

  • The Science and Values of Administration--I. de Grazia, Alfred // Administrative Science Quarterly;Dec60, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p362 

    In the first of two parts the author, asserting that all action is purposive, calls group-performed habitual actions "administration." The task of administrative science is to generalize about all administrative situations. How the science selects and abstracts data and chooses and phrases...

  • A Model of Task Group Development in Complex Organizations and a Strategy of Implementation. Heinen, J. Stephen; Jacobson, Eugene // Academy of Management Review;Oct76, Vol. 1 Issue 4, p98 

    An intervention strategy for development of an industrial work group is proposed from a four stage model of group development. The group is distinguished from therapy and sensitivity groups in terms of its problem solving task purpose. The model reflects emphasis upon task structure rather than...

  • A Longitudinal Comparative Analysis of Dialectical Inquiry, Devil's Advocacy and Consensus Approaches to Strategic Decision Making. Schweiger, David M.; Sandberg, Wiliam R.; Rechner, Paula // Academy of Management Best Papers Proceedings;1988, p32 

    This longitudinal laboratory study using "fast track" middle managers involved in strategic planning found that both DI and DA were more effective than C and all were more effective with experience.

  • Good Boards are Strategic: What Does that Mean for Sport Governance? Ferkins, Lesley; Shilbury, David // Journal of Sport Management;7/14/2011, p1 

    In order to learn more about the governance of sport organizations, this study explored what meaning board members of national sport organizations (NSOs) attach to the concept of "strategic capability". In so doing, the enquiry also identified factors considered to constrain or enable board...

  • Cross-Cultural Management Research: The Ostrich and the Trend. Adler, Nancy J. // Academy of Management Review;Apr1983, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p226 

    The trends in cross-cultural management papers published in 24 journals during the last decade, 1971 to 1980, are examined. Less than 5 percent of organizational behavior articles published in top American management journals focused on cross-cultural issues. The majority of the cross-cultural...

  • CHANGING SPACES: THE DISRUPTIVE IMPACT OF A NEW EPISTEMOLOGICAL LOCATION FOR THE STUDY OF MANAGEMENT. Knights, David // Academy of Management Review;Jul1992, Vol. 17 Issue 3, p514 

    This article draws on the work of the French philosopher, Michel Foucault, in order to problematize conventional approaches to the study of management and organizations that have been thought of as informed by a positive epistemology. Such a methodology encourages researchers to produce positive...

  • Antagonistic and Nonantagonistic Dialectical Contradictions in Organizational Conflict. Erbert, Larry A. // International Journal of Business Communication;Apr2014, Vol. 51 Issue 2, p138 

    This study examined the perceived importance of five dialectical contradictions to conflict episodes for 40 organizational employees. Using a revised version of the Retrospective Interview Technique and questionnaire data, organizational employees were asked to recall important conflict...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics