Failure of hospital employees to comply with smoke-free policy is associated with nicotine dependence and motives for smoking: a descriptive cross-sectional study at a teaching hospital in the United Kingdom

Parks, Tom; Wilson, Clare V. R.; Turner, Kenrick; Chin, Joel W. E.
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p238
Academic Journal
Background: Smoke-free policy aims to protect the health of the population by reducing exposure to environmental tobacco smoke (ETS), and World Health Organisation (WHO) guidance notes that these policies are only successful if there is full and proper enforcement. We aimed to investigate the problem of resistance to smoking restrictions and specifically compliance with smoke-free policy. We hypothesised that an explanation for non-compliance would lie in a measurable difference between the smoking behaviours of compliant and non-compliant smokers, specifically that non-compliance would be associated with nicotine dependence and different reasons for smoking. Methods: We conducted a questionnaire-based, descriptive, cross-sectional study of hospital employees. Seven hundred and four members of staff at Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge, UK, completed the questionnaire, of whom 101 were smokers. Comparison between compliant and non-compliant smokers was made based on calculated scores for the Fagerström test and the Horn-Waingrow scale, and level of agreement with questions about attitudes. For ordinal data we used a linear-by-linear association test. For non-parametric independent variables we used the Mann-Whitney test and for associations between categorical variables we used the chi-squared test. Results: The demographic composition of respondents corresponded with the hospital's working population in gender, age, job profile and ethnicity. Sixty nine smokers reported they were compliant while 32 were non-compliant. Linear-by-linear association analysis of the compliant and non-compliant smokers' answers for the Fagerström test suggests association between compliance and nicotine dependence (p = 0.049). Mann-Whitney test analysis suggests there is a statistically significant difference between the reasons for smoking of the two groups: specifically that non-compliant smokers showed habitual smoking behaviour (p = 0.003). Overall, compliant and non-compliant smokers did not have significantly different attitudes towards the policy or their own health. Conclusion: We demonstrate that those who smoke in this setting in contravention to a smoke-free policy do so neither for pleasure (promotion of positive affect) nor to avoid feeling low (reduction of negative affect); instead it is a resistant habit, which has little or no influence on the smoker's mood, and is determined in part by chemical dependence.


Related Articles

  • ONLY 100% SMOKE-FREE ENVIRONMENTS ADEQUATELY PROTECT FROM DANGERS OF SECOND-HAND SMOKE.  // Central European Journal of Public Health;2007, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p128 

    The article reports that the World Health Organization (WHO) has signalled the need for countries to make all indoor public places and workplaces 100% smoke-free with its new policy recommendations on protection from exposure to second-hand tobacco smoke. It says that exposure to second-hand...

  • ONLY 100% SMOKE-FREE ENVIRONMENTS ADEQUATELY PROTECT FROM DANGERS OF SECOND-HAND SMOKE.  // Indian Journal of Medical Sciences;Jun2007, Vol. 61 Issue 6, p372 

    The article reports that the World Health Organization (WHO) has requested all countries to make indoor public places and workplaces 100% smoke-free with the release of its new policy recommendations on protection from exposure to second-hand tobacco smoke. According to the author, exposure to...

  • The Impact of Smoke-Free Workplaces on Declining Cigarette Consumption in Australia and the United States. Chapman, Simon; Borland, Ron; Scollo, Michelle; Brownson, Ross C.; Dominello, Amanda; Woodward, Stephen // American Journal of Public Health;Jul99, Vol. 89 Issue 7, p1018 

    Objectives. This study estimates the contribution of smoke-free work-places to the recent national declines in cigarette consumption in Australia and the United States. Methods. Nineteen studies of the impact of smoke-free workplaces on workday cigarette consumption were reviewed. The number and...

  • Environmental Tobacco Smoke Concentrations in No-Smoking and Smoking Sections of Restaurants. Lambert, William E.; Samet, Jonathan M.; Spengler, John D. // American Journal of Public Health;Sep93, Vol. 83 Issue 9, p1339 

    To characterize the effectiveness of a local ordinance that restricts smoking in restaurants to one third of the seating area, this study made simultaneous measurements of two markers of environmental tobacco smoke, respirable suspended particles and nicotine, in the smoking and no-smoking...

  • Multiunit housing residents’ experiences and attitudes toward smoke-free policies. King, Brian A.; Cummings, K. Michael; Mahoney, Martin C.; Juster, Harlan R.; Hyland, Andrew J. // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Jun2010, Vol. 12 Issue 6, p598 

    Introduction:: Secondhand smoke (SHS) causes significant disease and death. A person’s home represents a prominent source of SHS, and the potential for exposure is elevated among those who live in close proximity to smokers in multiunit housing (MUH). This study assessed the prevalence...

  • Hospital gets smoking ban.  // Employee Benefits;May2005, p8 

    Introduces a complete smoking ban by Ipswich Hospital in its premises in London, England. Response of the hospital on the government's recent White Paper on health; Inclusion of the hospital staff and visitors in the ban.

  • Editorial. Smoke and mirrors: clearing the air to expose the tactics of the tobacco industry. McKee, M // European Journal of Public Health;Sep2000, Vol. 10 Issue 3, p161 

    Editorial. Comments on the landmark agreement between the representatives of 26 European countries attending a World Health Organization working group on the need to eliminate exposure to tobacco smoke pollution. Recommendations of the Working Group; Research funded by the tobacco industry.

  • WHO Lifts Hong Kong Restriction.  // WWD: Women's Wear Daily;5/27/2003, Vol. 185 Issue 106, p13 

    Reports on the decision of the United Nations World Health Organization to lift travel restrictions imposed on Hong Kong, China.

  • ONLY 5.4% OF WORLD'S POPULATION COVERED BY COMPREHENSIVE SMOKE-FREE LAWS.  // Indian Journal of Medical Sciences;Dec2009, Vol. 63 Issue 12, p567 

    The article reports that only 5.4% of the world population were addressed by the comprehensive smoke-free laws in 2008 compared to the 3.1% in 2007 based on the World Health Organization (WHO) report. It mentions that 154 million more people are no longer exposed to the dangers of tobacco smoke...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics