Comparison of self-reported health & healthcare utilisation between asylum seekers and refugees: an observational study

Toar, Magzoub; O'Brien, Kirsty K.; Fahey, Tom
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p214
Academic Journal
Background: Adult refugees and asylum seekers living in Western countries experience a high prevalence of mental health problems, especially post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression and anxiety. This study compares and contrasts the prevalence of health problems, and potential risk factors as well as the utilisation of health services by asylum seekers and refugees in the Irish context. Methods: Cross sectional study using validated self reported health status questionnaires of adult asylum seekers (n = 60) and refugees (n = 28) from 30 countries, living in Ireland. Outcome measures included: general health status (SF-36), presence of PTSD symptoms and anxiety/ depression symptoms. Data on chronic conditions and pre or post migration stressors are also reported. The two groups are compared for utilisation of the health care system and the use of over the counter medications. Results: Asylum seekers were significantly more likely than refugees to report symptoms of PTSD (OR 6.3, 95% CI: 2.2-17.9) and depression/anxiety (OR 5.8, 95% CI: 2.2-15.4), while no significant difference was found in self-reported general health. When adjusted by multivariable regression, the presence of more than one chronic disease (OR 4.0, 95%CI: 1.3-12.7; OR 3.4, 95% CI: 1.2-10.1), high levels of pre migration stressors (OR 3.6, 95% CI: 1.1-11.9; OR 3.3, 95% CI: 1.0-10.4) or post migration stressors (OR 17.3, 95% CI: 4.9-60.8; OR 3.9, 95% CI: 1.2-12.3) were independent predictors of self reported PTSD or depression/anxiety symptoms respectively, however, residence status was no longer significantly associated with PTSD or depression/anxiety. Residence status may act as a marker for other explanatory variables; our results show it has a strong relationship with post migration stressors (χ²= 19.74, df = 1, P < 0.001). In terms of health care utilisation, asylum seekers use GP services more often than refugees, while no significant difference was found between these groups for use of dentists, medication, hospitalisation or mental health services. Conclusion: Asylum seekers have a higher level of self reported PTSD and depression/anxiety symptoms compared to refugees. However, residence status appears to act as a marker for post migration stressors. Compared to refugees, asylum seekers utilise GP services more often, but not mental health services.


Related Articles

  • In the shadow of fear. Brown, Phyllida // New Scientist;9/6/2003, Vol. 179 Issue 2411, p30 

    Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), is a condition that affects millions who have survived a life-threatening incident or witnessed violence. PTSD is a well-known condition, but less well known is the fact that PTSD is just one of a group of mental illnesses called anxiety disorders,...

  • Invited Commentary: How Healthy is the "Healthy Warrior"?  // American Journal of Epidemiology;Jun2008, Vol. 167 Issue 11, p1277 

    In this issue of the Journal, Larson et al. (Am J Epidemiol 2008;167:1269–1276) report incidence rates of 11.8% for any mental disorder and 1.6% for post-traumatic stress disorder among US Marines deployed during Operation Iraqi Freedom and Operation Enduring Freedom. Various...

  • Traumatic events, PTSD, and psychiatric comorbidity in forensic patients -- assessed by questionnaires and diagnostic interview. Garieballa, Samia Sirag; Schauer, Maggie; Neuner, Frank; Saleptsi, Evangelia; Kluttig, Tilman; Elbert, Thomas; Hoffmann, Klaus; Rockstroh, Brigitte S. // Clinical Practice & Epidemiology in Mental Health;2006, Vol. 2, p7 

    Background: Relationships between posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), comorbid illness and experiences of traumatic stressors have been reported for large and different groups. The present study investigated this relationship specifically for patients with psychiatric disorders admitted to a...

  • IS STRESS NOW A VALID PSYCHIATRIC DISEASE? Rosch, Paul J. // Health & Stress;Aug2008, Issue 8, p1 

    The article discusses the issue whether stress could be considered as a valid psychiatric disease. Critics argue if Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) should be accorded the same status as "temporary insanity" defense diagnosis. They believe that severe stress should not be regarded as an...

  • Stabilizing Patients With Dissociative Disorders. Welzant, Victor // Psychiatric Annals;Aug2005, Vol. 35 Issue 8, p678 

    Focuses on the stabilization of acute presentations of both dissociative disorders and complex post-traumatic stress disorder. Case presentations of dissociative disorder; Principles of stabilization; Stabilization phase treatment goals; Factors to consider in creating a plan for safety in the...

  • WFS1 gene as a putative biomarker for development of post-traumatic syndrome in an animal model. Kesner, Y.; Zohar, J.; Merenlender, A.; Gispan, I.; Shalit, F.; Yadid, G. // Molecular Psychiatry;Jan2009, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p86 

    Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is an anxiety disorder that may develop after the experiencing or witnessing of a life-threatening event. PTSD is defined by the coexistence of three clusters of symptoms: re-experiencing, avoidance and hyperarousal, which persist for at least 1 month in...

  • The Validity of Screening for Post-traumatic Stress Disorder and Other Mental Health Problems among Asylum Seekers from Different Countries. JAKOBSEN, MARIANNE; THORESEN, SIRI; JOHANSEN, LARS ERIK EIDE // Journal of Refugee Studies;Mar2011, Vol. 24 Issue 1, p171 

    Mental health problems are prevalent in asylum seekers and refugees. Screening instruments may be effective tools for identifying individuals with severe mental health problems, which will allow us to offer them further assessment and treatment. The aim of this study was to evaluate the utility...

  • For Anguished Vets, the Listening Cure. Caplan, Paula J. // Officer;Nov2004, Vol. 81 Issue 9, p18 

    Argues that simply sending frightened, angry soldiers, who have returned from war, to therapists conveys disturbing messages. Indication that people do not want to listen; Implication that their devastation is abnormal, that it is a mental illness; Importance of letting returnees know that we do...

  • Mental health of returnees: refugees in Germany prior to their state-sponsored repatriation. Von Lersner, Ulrike; Wiens, Ulrike; Elbert, Thomas; Neuner, Frank // BMC International Health & Human Rights;2008, Vol. 8, Special section p1 

    Background: Many refugees live for years in exile. The combination of stress in the host country, together with long-term effects resulting from traumatic stress usually experienced in the home country may affect mental health. Little is known, to what extent these and other factors promote or...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics