The relationship between effectiveness and costs measured by a risk-adjusted case-mix system: multicentre study of Catalonian population data bases

Sicras-Mainar, Antoni; Navarro-Artieda, Ruth; Blanca-Tamayo, Milagrosa; Velasco-Velasco, Soledad; Escribano-Herranz, Esperanza; Ramon Llopart-López, Josep; Violan-Fors, Concepción; Maria Vilaseca-Llobet, Josep; Sánchez-Fontcuberta, Encarna; Benavent-Areu, Jaume; Flor-Serra, Ferran; Aguado-Jodar, Alba; Rodríguez-López, Daniel; Prados-Torres, Alejandra; Estelrich-Bennasar, Jose
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p202
Academic Journal
Background: The main objective of this study is to measure the relationship between morbidity, direct health care costs and the degree of clinical effectiveness (resolution) of health centres and health professionals by the retrospective application of Adjusted Clinical Groups in a Spanish population setting. The secondary objectives are to determine the factors determining inadequate correlations and the opinion of health professionals on these instruments. Methods/Design: We will carry out a multi-centre, retrospective study using patient records from 15 primary health care centres and population data bases. The main measurements will be: general variables (age and sex, centre, service [family medicine, paediatrics], and medical unit), dependent variables (mean number of visits, episodes and direct costs), co-morbidity (Johns Hopkins University Adjusted Clinical Groups Case-Mix System) and effectiveness. The totality of centres/patients will be considered as the standard for comparison. The efficiency index for visits, tests (laboratory, radiology, others), referrals, pharmaceutical prescriptions and total will be calculated as the ratio: observed variables/variables expected by indirect standardization. The model of cost/patient/year will differentiate fixed/semi-fixed (visits) costs of the variables for each patient attended/year (N = 350,000 inhabitants). The mean relative weights of the cost of care will be obtained. The effectiveness will be measured using a set of 50 indicators of process, efficiency and/or health results, and an adjusted synthetic index will be constructed (method: percentile 50). The correlation between the efficiency (relative-weights) and synthetic (by centre and physician) indices will be established using the coefficient of determination. The opinion/degree of acceptance of physicians (N = 1,000) will be measured using a structured questionnaire including various dimensions. Statistical analysis: multiple regression analysis (procedure: enter), ANCOVA (method: Bonferroni's adjustment) and multilevel analysis will be carried out to correct models. The level of statistical significance will be p < 0.05.


Related Articles

  • Clinical Pathways in surgery—should we introduce them into clinical routine? A review article. Ronellenfitsch, Ulrich; Rössner, Eric; Jakob, Jens; Post, Stefan; Hohenberger, Peter; Schwarzbach, Matthias // Langenbeck's Archives of Surgery;Jul2008, Vol. 393 Issue 4, p449 

    In modern health care systems, care providers face ever new challenges with regard to quality and cost of care, as well as to satisfaction and training of staff. Due to the intensiveness of the subject, these challenges are particularly pronounced in surgery. Clinical Pathways, i.e. detailed...

  • The President's Page Free Medicine? PITOCK, MORRIS P. // Connecticut Medicine;Jan2014, Vol. 78 Issue 1, p53 

    The article presents a reprint of an article on American Medicine, which appeared in the January 1964 issue of the periodical "Connecticut Medicine." The article focuses on the drive for free medicine in the U.S. It states that medical personnel have no control over the nation's finances; and...

  • Opinion: Your Views - Revamp the MPIG. Harvie, Brian // GP: General Practitioner;12/5/2012, p24 

    The article presents the author's comments on the need to restructure the Minimum Practice Income Guarantee (MPIG) in Great Britain. He says that this funding is based on historical budgets and did not reflect the view that funding should follow the patient. According to him, medical personnel...


    The article discusses issues related to implementing tort reform in the U.S. It is noted that tort law deals with reparations for injuries caused by medical negligence or malpractice. It is stated that defensive medicine mechanism is predominant in "tort reform" and decreasing liability could...

  • Personal View. Humphries, S.V. // British Medical Journal;8/30/1975, Vol. 3 Issue 5982, p538 

    Presents several views on the cost of medical treatment in Africa. Factors contributing on the increase expenditure of health; Influence of technology on the high cost of health care; Assessment on the quality delivery of health services.

  • THE EXTENT OF MEDICAL PRACTICE IN FRANCE AROUND 1780. Goubert, Jean-Pierre // Journal of Social History;Summer77, Vol. 10 Issue 4, p410 

    Focuses on the medical practice in France of 1780. Number and density of practitioners admitted for medical practice; Description of the practice of surgery; Analysis of medical rates.

  • The Week. Warden, John // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);7/20/91, Vol. 303 Issue 6795, p154 

    Focuses on medical issues in Great Britain. Need for more funding for health care systems; Concerns regarding budget limitations for medical services; Importance of doctor participation in running medical services.

  • Cost of illness studies. Byford, Sarah // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);05/13/2000, Vol. 320 Issue 7245, p1335 

    Discusses issues associated with the cost of illness studies in Great Britain. Aim of a cost of illness study; Methods of costing illness; Determination of the total cost of illness; Arguments against the use of cost of illness studies in resources prioritization.

  • Low-Cost Tele-assessment System for Home-Based Evaluation of Reaching Ability Following Stroke. Rau, Chi-Lun; Chen, Ya-Ping; Lai, Jin-Shin; Chen, Shih-Ching; Kuo, Te-Son; Jaw, Fu-Shan; Luh, Jer-Junn // Telemedicine & e-Health;Dec2013, Vol. 19 Issue 12, p973 

    Objective: Tele-assessment techniques can provide healthcare professionals with easily accessible information regarding patients' clinical progress. Recently, kinematic analysis systems have been used to assess rehabilitative outcomes in stroke patients. Kinematic systems, however, are not...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics