Melanocytic Naevus or Malignant Melanoma? A Large-scale Epidemiological Study of Diagnostic Accuracy: Clinical Reports

Lindelöf, B.; Hedblad, M.-A.; Sigurgeirsson, B.
July 1998
Acta Dermato-Venereologica;7/21/98, Vol. 78 Issue 4, p284
Academic Journal
While the early detection of malignant melanoma is important and has been emphasized widely in the past few years, it is difficult to accomplish. The purpose of this study is to assess how well dermatologists recognize malignant melanomas in patients with naevi. Information from 9,121 patients visiting two dermatological clinics in Stockholm and diagnosed melanocytic naevi was linked with the Swedish Cancer Registry to identify individuals with records of malignant melanoma. One-hundred-and-thirteen cases of malignant melanoma were detected in the study population. Sixty patients were diagnosed malignant melanoma prior to the naevus diagnosis and most of them were under continuous follow-up. A further 35 patients were diagnosed malignant melanoma and naevus at the same time. The remaining 18 were given the diagnoses malignant melanoma after the naevus diagosis and, of these, 6 cases were detected more than 6 years after examination and malignant melanoma was considered not present at the time of consultation. Three cases can be considered as missed (6%) and four others as partially missed or delayed. Thus, of 47 cases of probable recognizable malignant melanoma, there was insufficient management of 7 (15%). Six cases were detected during dermatological examination for other conditions and five through general examination of naevi. Although a few possibly detectable malignant melanomas were not discovered, the results of this study reflect a high clinical detection rate. In addition, a number of cases were discovered by chance during examinations for other dermatological conditions.


Related Articles

  • Counting moles may help determine the risk of malignant melanoma.  // Modern Medicine;Nov94, Vol. 62 Issue 11, p15 

    Reports on the findings of a study by intern Deborah D. Lawson and colleagues at the University of California in San Francisco which concludes that patients who have six or more large moles have a higher risk of melanoma. Ability of patients to monitor their risk for melanoma if they are taught...

  • The other self-exam you need. Stedman, Nancy // Redbook;May96, Vol. 187 Issue 1, p40 

    Provides tips for spotting a malignant tumor which could be indicative of melanoma. Asymmetric coloration; Border irregularity; Uneven pigmentation; Diameter greater than a pencil eraser.

  • Atypical mole syndrome needs follow-up. Guttman, Cheryl // Dermatology Times;May95, Vol. 16 Issue 5, p39 

    Discusses the recognition of atypical mole syndrome as a screening market for melanoma. Counselling of patients of sun avoidance; Careful monitoring needed to enhance early detection and treatment; Life-long cutaneous examination.

  • MOLE OR MELANOMA?  // Professional Beauty;Jul/Aug2011, p126 

    A personal narrative is presented that explores author's experience of undergoing melanoma screening tests for her moles.

  • Novel biomarkers distinguished melanoma from dysplastic nevi.  // Hem/Onc Today;12/10/2012, Vol. 13 Issue 23, p30 

    The article discusses research which examined molecular biomarkers that can be used in diagnosing melanoma from dysplastic nevi.

  • Special attention: Only problematic lesions in pediatric patients require close observation. Jesitus, John // Dermatology Times;Mar2012, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p95 

    The article offers views from Elvira Moscarella, dermatologist in the department of oncologic dermatology at San Gallicano Dermatological Institute in Rome, Italy, concerning the problematic lesions in pediatric patients. She suggests the need for dermatologists to prioritize only those types of...

  • Tertium Non Datur? Legitimacy of a Third Diagnostic Category in Melanocytic Lesions. Urso, Carmelo // Archives of Pathology & Laboratory Medicine;Oct2012, Vol. 136 Issue 10, p1181 

    The author discusses the problem and debate surrounding the use and legitimacy of a third diagnostic category between nevi and melanoma. The various methodologies and factors included for the classification of tumors and the morphologies related to the conditions are analyzed. The study thus...

  • WHAT'S YOUR DX? "Chicken skin" in a newborn. ZHU, SHAI-NAN // Contemporary Pediatrics;Sep2010, Vol. 27 Issue 9, p39 

    No abstract available.

  • Evidence of a Limited Intra-Individual Diversity of Nevi: Intuitive Perception of Dominant Clusters Is a Crucial Step in the Analysis of Nevi by Dermatologists. Wazaefi, Yanal; Gaudy-Marqueste, Caroline; Avril, Marie- Françoise; Malvehy, Joseph; Pellacani, Giovanni; Thomas, Luc; Triller, Raoul; Bruneu, Yvane; Monestier, Sandrine; Richard, Marie-Aleth; Fertil, Bernard; Grob, Jean-Jacques // Journal of Investigative Dermatology;Oct2013, Vol. 133 Issue 10, p2355 

    Although nevi are highly polymorphous, it has been suggested that each individual is characterized by only a few dominant patterns of nevi. Therefore, a nevus that does not fit in with these patterns, the 'ugly duckling' nevus, is suspicious. Our objective was to study the intra-individual...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics