Evidence and argument in policymaking: development of workplace smoking legislation

Apollonio, Dorie E.; Bero, Lisa A.
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p1
Academic Journal
Background: We sought to identify factors that affect the passage of public health legislation by examining the use of arguments, particularly arguments presenting research evidence, in legislative debates regarding workplace smoking restrictions. Methods: We conducted a case-study based content analysis of legislative materials used in the development of six state workplace smoking laws, including written and spoken testimony and the text of proposed and passed bills and amendments. We coded testimony given before legislators for arguments used, and identified the institutional affiliations of presenters and their position on the legislation. We compared patterns in the arguments made in testimony to the relative strength of each state's final legislation. Results: Greater discussion of scientific evidence within testimony given was associated with the passage of workplace smoking legislation that provided greater protection for public health, regardless of whether supporters outnumbered opponents or vice versa. Conclusion: Our findings suggest that an emphasis on scientific discourse, relative to other arguments made in legislative testimony, might help produce political outcomes that favor public health.


Related Articles

  • New Bill sparks confusion. Golding, Nick // Employee Benefits;May2006, p31 

    The article discusses the government's plan to outlaw smoking in the workplace and certain company vehicles in Great Britain. The legislation was believed to ban smoking in all company vehicles where there are two or more occupants and if vehicles are open to the public. Meanwhile, the country...

  • The ifs, butts and maybes. Jacobson, Browne // Travel Weekly (UK);1/19/2007, p46 

    The article presents a reprint of the article "The Ifs, Butts and Maybes," by Browne Jacobson, which appeared in an issue of "Personnel Today." The Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 of Great Britain requires employers to do what is reasonable and practicable to ensure the health, safety and...

  • Smoke-free workplaces. Ellis, Peter // RoSPA Occupational Safety & Health Journal;May2006, Vol. 36 Issue 5, p30 

    Discusses the smoking ban in workplaces and its implications for businesses in Great Britain. Number of deaths each year associated with smoking in Great Britain; Change in the public attitudes toward smoking; Explanation of how employers can use existing health and safety legislation to comply...

  • Using Socially Fair Treatment to Promote Acceptance of a Work Site Smoking Ban. Greenberg, Jerald // Journal of Applied Psychology;Apr94, Vol. 79 Issue 2, p288 

    Announcements of a work site smoking ban were made to 732 clerical workers. The presentations differed in the amount of information given about the need for the ban and the degree of interpersonal sensitivity shown over the personal impact of the ban. Immediately after the announcement,...

  • Ireland leads the way for Europe in banning smoking in the workplace.  // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);9/6/2003, Vol. 327 Issue 7414, p522 

    Discusses the steps taken by Ireland to be the first European country to ban smoking in the workplace. Inclusion of the hospitality industry in the elements of the ban; Scientific basis for the ban which was presented by the Office for Tobacco Control and the Health and Safety Authority in a...

  • The Last Gasp: Workplace Smokers Near Extinction. Lang, Nancy A. // Management Review;Feb92, Vol. 81 Issue 2, p33 

    Reports on the increased number of companies in the United States that have adopted the smoke-free environment policy. Impact of work place smoking on health insurance costs; Reasons behind companies' move to ban smoking in the work place.

  • Can I Prohibit My Employees From Smoking While Working? Duncan, Brooke // IE3;Sep2015, Vol. 4 Issue 5, p20 

    The article provides an answer to a question regarding smoking policy for employees.

  • Cuba joins global efforts to stub out smoking in public. Berry, Mike // Personnel Today;2/15/2005, p6 

    This article reports that last week, Cuba became the latest country to ban smoking in public places and workplaces. Cubans now have to stub out their cigarettes and cigars in offices, shops, cinemas, theatres, public transport, sports facilities and all air-conditioned buildings. And restaurants...

  • Testimony on Positive Impact of Smoke-Free Workplace Legislation Given in Two Days of Committee Hearings.  // Biomedical Market Newsletter;5/5/2011, p877 

    The article presents testimonials from several individuals including Dr. Phil Huang, musician Natalie Zoe, and entrepreneur John Korioth on the positive impact of the smoke-free workplace legislation in Texas. The smoke-free workplace bill is authored by Senator Rodney Ellis and Representative...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics