Interviews for the assessment of long-term incapacity for work: a study on adherence to protocols and principles

de Boer, Wout E. L.; Wind, Haije; van Dijk, Frank J. H.; Willems, Han H. B. M.
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p1
Academic Journal
Background: Assessments for long-term incapacity for work are performed by Social Insurance Physicians (SIPs) who rely on interviews with claimants as an important part of the process. These interviews are susceptible to bias. In the Netherlands three protocols have been developed to conduct these interviews. These protocols are expert- and practice-based. We studied to what extent these protocols are adhered to by practitioners. Methods: We compared the protocols with one another and with the ICF and the biopsychosocial approach. The protocols describe semi-structured interviews with comparable but not identical topics. All protocols prescribe that the client's opinion on his capacity for work, and his arguments, need to be determined and assessed. We developed a questionnaire to elicit the adherence SIPs have to the protocols, their underlying principles and topics. We conducted a survey among one hundred fifty-five experienced SIPs in the Netherlands. Results: Ninety-eight SIPs responded (64%). All respondents used some form of protocol, either one of the published protocols or their own mix. We found no significant relation between training and the use of a particular protocol. Ninety percent use a semi-structured interview. Ninety-five percent recognise having to verify what the claimant says and eighty-three percent feel the need to establish a good relation (p = 0.019). Twelve topics are basically always addressed by over eighty percent of the respondents. The claimant's opinion of being fit for his own work or other work, and his claim of incapacity and his health arguments for that claim, reach a hundred percent. Description of claimants' previous work reaches ninety-nine percent. Conclusion: Our study shows professional consensus among experienced Dutch SIPs about the principle of assessment on arguments, the principle of conducting a semi-structured interview and the most crucial interview topics. This consensus can be used to further develop a protocol for interviewing in the assessment of incapacity for work in social insurance. Such a protocol can improve the quality of the assessments in terms of transparency and reproducibility, as well as by enabling clients to better prepare themselves for the assessments.


Related Articles

  • Quality of life in adults following bone marrow transplantation during childhood. Helder, D. I.; Bakker, B.; De Heer, P.; Van der Veen, F.; Vossen, J. M. J. J.; Wit, J. M.; Kaptein, A. A. // Bone Marrow Transplantation;Feb2004, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p329 

    Summary:Quality of life (QOL) was assessed in 22 young adults, 14 years - on average- after having received bone marrow transplantation (BMT) during childhood at the Leiden University Medical Center. All were disease-free and >16 years when interviewed. The sickness impact profile and the...

  • Assessment of former ICU patients' quality of life: comparison of different quality-of-life measures. Frick, Sonia; Uehlinger, Dominik E.; Zenklusen, Regula M. Zürcher // Intensive Care Medicine;Oct2002, Vol. 28 Issue 10, p1405 

    Objective. To compare three different measures to assess quality of life (QOL) after an Intensive Care Unit (ICU) stay: a standardized telephone interview, a satisfaction scale, and the Sickness Impact Profile (SIP). Design. Prospective study, evaluating QOL 6 months after ICU discharge....

  • Health Status of Survivors of Cardiac Arrest and of Myocardial Infarction Controls. Bergner, Lawrence; Hallstrom, Alfred P.; Bergner, Marilyn; Eisenberg, Mickey S.; Cobb, Leonard A. // American Journal of Public Health;Nov85, Vol. 75 Issue 11, p1321 

    Abstract: We interviewed 308 survivors of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and matched controls who had suffered a myocardial infarction. The Sickness Impact Profile (SIP) scores of controls were somewhat lower (better) than those of cases, but responses of cases and controls to additional...

  • Pitfalls in Measuring the Health Status of Mexican Americans: Comparative Validity of the English and Spanish Sickness Impact Profile. Deyo, Richard A. // American Journal of Public Health;Jun84, Vol. 74 Issue 6, p569 

    We tested a Spanish translation of the Sickness Impact Profile (SIP) in a clinical study of low back pain, which included non-Hispanic patients (Group I), Mexican Americans who used the English SIP (Group II), and Mexican Americans who used the Spanish SIP (group III). The reliability and...

  • Health Status of Survivors of Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest Six Months Later. Bergner, Lawrence; Bergner, Marilyn; Hallstrom, Alfred P.; Eisenberg, Mickey; Cobb, Leonard A. // American Journal of Public Health;May84, Vol. 74 Issue 5, p508 

    The health status of long-term survivors of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest was studied six months after the event. Although Sickness Impact Profile scores for arrest survivors were higher (worse) than scores of enrollees in a prepaid closed panel health plan, in most cases problems of survivors...

  • Calidad de vida relacionada con la salud y trabajo en pacientes con tuberculosis en Guadalajara, (México). González Baltazar, Raquel; Lupercio Heredia, Andrés; Hidalgo Santacruz, Gustavo; Graciela León Cortés, Silvia; Guadalupe Salazar Estrada, José // Salud Uninorte;ene-abr2013, Vol. 29 Issue 1, p13 

    Objetive: Evaluate the perception of Health Related Quality of Life (HRQoL) in patients diagnosed with tuberculosis and its relation with their work. Materials and Methods: We used the SF-36 and the dimension of work of Sickness Impact Profile (SIP). Results: The dimensions of the SF-36...

  • Determinants of Patient Satisfaction After Severe Lower-Extremity Injuries. O'Toole, Robert V.; Castillo, Renan C.; Pollak, Andrew N.; MacKenzie, Ellen J.; Bosse, Michael J. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Jun2008, Vol. 90-A Issue 6, p1206 

    Background: In health care, increased emphasis has been placed on patient-centered care, but to our knowledge little work has been conducted to understand the influences on patient satisfaction after surgery for the treatment of severe lower-extremity injury. Our purpose was to analyze how the...

  • Factorial Invariance of the WHOQOL-BREF Among Disease Groups. Grace Yao; Chia-huei Wu // Quality of Life Research;Oct2005, Vol. 14 Issue 8, p1881 

    To compare health-related quality of life (QOL) across groups, researchers have to assure that items of a QOL measure represent the same constructs across groups. This study investigated factorial invariance of the WHOQOL-BREF between a healthy population and populations with diseases using the...

  • Sickness Impact Profile.  // Taber's Cyclopedic Medical Dictionary;2005, p1995 

    A definition of the term "Sickness Impact Profile" is presented. It refers to a standardized questionnaire designed to assess the effects of illness on function. There are 136 questions grouped into 12 categories that include sleep and rest, eating, work, home management, recreation, ambulatory...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics