Explaining the variation in the management of lifestyle risk factors in primary health care: A multilevel cross sectional study

Laws, Rachel A.; Jayasinghe, Upali W.; Harris, Mark F.; Williams, Anna M.; Davies, Gawaine Powell; Kemp, Lynn A.
January 2009
BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p1
Academic Journal
Background: Despite evidence for the effectiveness of interventions to modify lifestyle behaviours in the primary health care (PHC) setting, assessment and intervention for these behaviours remains low in routine practice. Little is known about the relative importance of various determinants of practice. This study aimed to examine the relative importance of provider characteristics and attitudes, patient characteristics and consultation factors in determining the rate of assessment and intervention for lifestyle risk factors in PHC. Methods: A prospective audit of assessment and intervention for lifestyle risk factors was undertaken by PHC nurses and allied health providers (n = 57) for all patients seen (n = 732) over a two week period. Providers completed a survey to assess key attitudes related to addressing lifestyle issues. Multi-level logistic regression analysis of patient audit records was undertaken. Associations between variables from both data sources were examined, together with the variance explained by patient and consultation (level 1) and provider (level 2) factors. Results: There was significant variance between providers in the assessment and intervention for lifestyle risk factors. The consultation type and reason for the visit were the most important in explaining the variation in assessment practices, however these factors along with patient and provider variables accounted for less than 20% of the variance. In contrast, multi-level models showed that provider factors were most important in explaining the variance in intervention practices, in particular, the location of the team in which providers worked (urban or rural) and provider perceptions of their effectiveness and accessibility of support services. After controlling for provider variables, patients' socio-economic status, the reason for the visit and providers' perceptions of the 'appropriateness' of addressing risk factors in the consultation were all significantly associated with providing optimal intervention. Together, measured patient consultation and provider variables accounted for most (80%) of the variation in intervention practices between providers. Conclusion: The findings highlight the importance of provider factors such as beliefs and attitudes, team location and work context in understanding variations in the provision of lifestyle intervention in PHC. Further studies of this type are required to identify variables that improve the proportion of variance explained in assessment practices.


Related Articles

  • Determinants of Perceived Morbidity and Use of Health Services by Children Less Than 15 Years Old in Rural Bangladesh. Alam, Nurul; van Ginneken, Jeroen K.; Timaeus, Ian // Maternal & Child Health Journal;Jan2009, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p119 

    This study examined the association of a number of social and economic and other factors with perceived morbidity and use of health services by children in rural Bangladesh, using the data of a health and socioeconomic survey conducted in Matlab, Bangladesh in 1996. One of the factors of...

  • The Eating Inventory, body adiposity and prevalence of diseases in a quota sample of Czech adults. Hainer, V; Kunesova, M; Bellisle, F; Parizkova, J; Braunerova, R; Wagenknecht, M; Lajka, J; Hill, M; Stunkard, A // International Journal of Obesity;May2006, Vol. 30 Issue 5, p830 

    Objective: To study the relationships between the Eating Inventory (EI) factors (restraint, disinhibition and hunger), body adiposity and prevalence of selected diseases in a quota sample of Czech adults.Subjects and Methods: The sample included 1429 men and 1624 women...

  • "Keeping Moving": factors associated with sedentary behaviour among older people recruited to an exercise promotion trial in general practice. Heseltine, Ruth; Skelton, Dawn A.; Kendrick, Denise; Morris, Richard W.; Griffin, Mark; Haworth, Deborah; Masud, Tahir; Iliffe, Steve // BMC Family Practice;2015, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Sedentary behaviour is detrimental to health, even in those who achieve recommended levels of physical activity. Efforts to increase physical activity in older people so that they reach beneficial levels have been disappointing. Reducing sedentary behaviour may improve health and be...

  • How Socio-economic Status Affects Health Intervention in Primary Health Care Setting. Vitale, Ksenija; Todorović, Goran; Šuljić, Petra; Džakula, Aleksandar // Materia Socio Medica;2008, Vol. 20 Issue 4, p216 

    Goal: The aim is to explore does socioeconomic status (SES) of examinees influence who out of four categories (general practitioner (GP), other health care workers, family or somebody else) most frequently gives advice about healthy life style. Our hypothesis is that, health intervention depends...

  • Socioeconomic status and risk of childhood leukaemia in Denmark. Raaschou-nielsen, Ole; Obel, Josephine; Dalton, Susanne; Tjønneland, Anne; Hansen, Johnni // Scandinavian Journal of Public Health;Sep2004, Vol. 32 Issue 4, p279 

    Aims : The aim of this study was to assess the influence of socioeconomic status on the risk of childhood leukaemia. Methods : A matched case-control design was used. The study population comprised all children (0-14 years old) born and reported to the Danish Cancer Registry between 1976 and...

  • Mortality among participants and non-participants in a prospective cohort study. Larsen, Signe; Dalton, Susanne; Schüz, Joachim; Christensen, Jane; Overvad, Kim; Tjønneland, Anne; Johansen, Christoffer; Olsen, Anja // European Journal of Epidemiology;Nov2012, Vol. 27 Issue 11, p837 

    Socioeconomic position and lifestyle often affect participation in scientific studies. The authors investigated differences in overall and cause-specific mortality between participants and non-participants in the prospective Danish cohort study 'Diet, Cancer and Health' and the association...

  • Knowledge and attitude towards basic life support among primary health care physicians in Taif, Saudi Arabia, in 2018: a regression analysis. Albaqami, Mohammed Mihmas; Abozaid, Hani // Electronic Physician;Jan-Mar2019, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p7415 

    Background: Relatively few studies have been carried out regarding assessment of knowledge and attitude of primary care physicians in Saudi Arabia towards Basic Life Support (BLS) and its training, as most of the studies were carried out among health care professionals in general, with the...

  • Healthy Physicians Equal Healthy Patients. Gupta, Rahul // Hospital Medicine Alert;Jul2013, Vol. 8 Issue 5, p37 

    The article discusses a study by E. Frank et al using data from Israel's largest health maintenance organization (HMO) to assess different indicators of quality health care for primary care physicians and adult patients. It examined 8 prevention-related healthy quality indicators including...

  • Does the integration education-service contributes to promote healthy way of life in primary health? Náthia Lourenço Lacerda, Leysse; Mendes Miranda, Mariane; de Aguiar Barcelos, Tábata; Torres, Lícia; Tavares Barreto Matias, Isabela; Célia de Castro, Regina; Moreira, Patrícia; Santos, Luana Caroline // Revista de Atencao Primaria a Saude;abr-jun2013, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p207 

    This study aimed to describe how the teaching-service integration can contribute to the promotion of healthy ways of life in Primary Health Care (PHC) in the field of Educational Working Program for Health in a Basic Health Unit (BHU). This is an experience report guided longitudi­nal study...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics