On the Constitutionability of Global Public Policy Networks

July 2009
Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies;Summer2009, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p605
Academic Journal
Global Public Policy Networks (GPPNs) are increasingly influential in the global policy-making process. According to the Global Public Policy Institute, GPPNs are cross-sectoral coalitions of actors from governments, international organizations, civil society, and private industry. In structure, these networks differ from traditional hierarchical organizations, but their primary functions--negotiation, coordination, rulemaking, and implementation--pick up the classic tasks of formal international organizations and intergovernmental cooperation. The power and acceptance of these networks are based on the real or alleged expertise of their members, their former or current formal positions in national or international organizations or private industry, and their personal connections. Although these features nourish the assumption that GPPNs are efficient problemsolvers, there is no empirical proof of this belief. Potential sources of their legitimacy await grounding in a solid normative theory. Efficiency cannot be considered a ready substitute for the formal democratic legitimacy that these networks are lacking in either empirical or theoretical regard. The phenomenon of GPPNs, therefore, touches some core problems of the global constitutionalism project--the idea of subjecting transnational, non-state actors to the rule of a global constitutional agreement. As powerful actors in the transnational sphere, GPPNs must address three challenges relating to the future of constitutionalism. First, is it possible to put non-state political actors under a constitutional regime? Second, if it is possible, how does one do so? Third, in what ways can the project of constitutionalism be expanded beyond the frame of the nation-state, if at all? The answers to these questions must address the central problem of global constitutionalism: how the traditional bond between the nation-state and its constitution can be dissolved without abandoning the accomplishments that the project of the modern state constitution stands for--founding, legitimizing, and confining democratic governance.


Related Articles

  • The U.S. Strategy: Democracy and Internal Stability in the Arab World. Hayajneh, Adnan M. // Alternatives: Turkish Journal of International Relations;Summer/Fall2004, Vol. 3 Issue 2/3, p19 

    The article discusses the impact of the U.S. national strategy on the behavior of the Arab states. Are the U.S. demands having any response from the Arab states? Special attention has been given to the behavior of the Arab states as a response to the U.S. demands. How the U.S. would like to see...

  • Afro and Indigenous Life--Visions in/and Politics. (De)colonial Perspectives in Bolivia and Ecuador. Walsh, Catherine // Bolivian Studies Journal;2011, Vol. 18, p49 

    Ancestral cosmologies or "life--visions" are increasingly visible today, both within the realm of Afro and Indigenous community--based struggles, and within the frame of State constitutions, rights, and politics. This article looks at what happens when ancestral life--visions are positioned as...

  • CONSTITUTIONAL CORPORATISM: THE PUBLIC USE CLAUSE AS A MEANS OF CORPORATE WELFARE. Murphy, John Kieran // University of Baltimore Journal of Land & Development;Spring2013, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p91 

    The article presents a discussion on whether the cost of constitutional corporatism outweighs its benefits, and how it affects the functioning of a free and democratic society. It presents a definition of corporatism as a means of political organization to implement public policy with the...

  • Building Democratic Governability and Changing Government Style. de Mantilla, Lya Fernández; Ramírez, Esther Parra; Briceño, Andrea Juliana // Reflexión Politica;dic2010, Vol. 12 Issue 24, p78 

    This paper develops the meanings of Democratic Governability and Governance, building on the case study "Public Policy: Complex Mass Transit System in Bucaramanga". It works with the results of an earlier research which determined the degree of governance by citizen participation in policy...

  • ACTIVISTS TAKE THE LEAD ON INITIATIVES. Germond, Jack W.; Witcover, Jules // National Journal;3/15/97, Vol. 29 Issue 11, p533 

    The article presents information on the initiative process that allows the voters to put a check on the major policy issues through the ballot in California. It has helped the state to keep its position on the forefront of national trends while close watching its public interests. But there are...

  • Política de fundos na educação e desigualdades municipais no estado de São Paulo: uma análise a partir das arenas políticas de Lowi. Machado Limonti, Rogério; Dias Peres, Ursula; de Lima Caldas, Eduardo // RAP: Revista Brasileira de Administração Pública;mar/abr2014, Vol. 48 Issue 2, p389 

    The systematization of social policies in Brazil is being addressed incrementally in recent decades. The 1988 Constitution is a historic milestone in reaffirming the importance of states and municipalities to offer these policies, especially in education. During the 1990s, however, some...

  • Constitutional Means and Realization Forms of Public Policy in Scientific and Technical Field. Vorontsov, D. F. // Current Issues of Russian Law;2011, Vol. 2011 Issue 4, p63 

    The article devoted to the issues related to implementation of public policies in scientific and technical field and development strategy in the constitutional-legal aspect.

  • Demanding attention. Kruger, Adriaan // Finweek;7/27/2006, p102 

    The article reports on the possible consequence of continuous repetition of demands by the people in its government. Being accorded with authority, the government has the ultimate power to address the needs of its people. However, continuous repetition of the demands could possibly shade its...

  • WASHINGTON FRONT. Parsons, Wilfrid // America;2/13/1954, Vol. 90 Issue 20, p497 

    The article presents the author's perspective regarding the implications of the proposed constitutional amendment of treaty-making power of the U.S. federal government. He asserts that the writers of the amendment do not manifest their understanding on the policies since it only repeated what...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics