Appropriate wastewater treatment systems for developing countries: criteria and indictor assessment in Thailand

Singhirunnusorn, W.; Stenstrom, M. K.
May 2009
Water Science & Technology;2009, Vol. 59 Issue 9, p1873
This paper presents a comprehensive approach with factors to select appropriate wastewater treatment systems in developing countries in general and Thailand in particular. Instead of focusing merely on the technical dimensions, the study integrates the social, economic, and environmental concerns to develop a set of criteria and indicators (C&I) useful for evaluating appropriate system alternatives. The paper identifies seven elements crucial for technical selection: reliability, simplicity, efficiency, land requirement, affordability, social acceptability, and sustainability. Variables are organized into three hierarchical elements, namely: principles, criteria, and indicators. The study utilizes a mail survey to obtain information from Thai experts—academicians, practitioners, and government officials—to evaluate the C&I list. Responses were received from 33 experts on two multi-criteria analysis inquiries—ranking and rating—to obtain evaluative judgments. Results show that reliability, affordability, and efficiency are among the most important elements, followed by sustainability and social acceptability. Land requirement and simplicity are low in priority with relatively inferior weighting. A number of criteria are then developed to match the contextual environment of each particular condition. A total of 14 criteria are identified which comprised 64 indicators. Unimportant criteria and indicators are discarded after careful consideration, since some of the indicators are local or site specific.


Related Articles

  • Review on Moving Bed Biofilm Processes. Yang Qiqi; He Qiang; Ibrahim, Husham T. // Pakistan Journal of Nutrition;Sep2012, Vol. 11 Issue 9, p804 

    The aim of this study is to present the Moving Bed Biofilm (MBB) technology as an alternative and successful method to treating different kinds of effluents under different conditions. In the past few years this technology has become more common and widely used in the world because the need for...

  • Activated Sludge Model No. 1 calibration for piggery wastewater treatment using respirometry. Boursier, H.; Béline, F.; Paul, E. // Water Science & Technology;2004, Vol. 49 Issue 5/6, p389 

    To optimise the intermittent aeration process for piggery wastewater, the Activated Sludge Model No. 1 needs to be calibrated and adapted to this specific effluent. By combining aerobic and anoxic respirometric tests, biodegradation kinetics of organic fractions in piggery wastewater could be...

  • Alpine infrastructure in Central Europe: integral evaluation of wastewater treatment systems at mountain refuges. Weissenbacher, N.; Mayr, E.; Niederberger, T.; Aschauer, C.; Lebersorger, S.; Steinbacher, G.; Haberl, R. // Water Science & Technology;2008, Vol. 57 Issue 12, p2017 

    Planning, construction and operation of onsite wastewater treatment systems at mountain refuges is a challenge. Energy supply, costly transport, limited water resources, unfavourable climate and load variations are only some of the problems that have to be faced. Additionally, legal regulations...

  • Characterisation and optimisation of individual wastewater treatment systems. Moelants, Nina; Janssen, Griet; Smets, Ilse; Van Impe, Jan // Water Science & Technology;2008, Vol. 57 Issue 12, p2059 

    Onsite individual wastewater treatment systems can provide a financially attractive alternative to a sewer connection in locations far from the existing sewer network. These systems are, however, relatively new, and practical experiences, especially long-term field studies, are lacking....

  • Capacity to Influence Sources of Heavy Metals to Wastewater Treatment Sludge. Sérme, Louise; Lindqvist, Annica; Séderberg, Henriette // Environmental Management;Mar2003, Vol. 31 Issue 3, p0421 

    Wastewater treatment sludge contains valuable nutrients, yet represents a residue problem due to the amount of heavy metals, which is one of the factors preventing the use of sludge as fertilizer. In Sweden, the government has a declared aim of closing the ecocycles of nutrients to arable land,...

  • The performance of fermentation wastewater treatment in ultrafiltration membrane bioreactor by continuous and intermittent aeration processes. Lu, S. G.; Imai, T.; Ukita, M.; Sekine, M.; Fukagawa, M.; Nakanishi, H. // Water Science & Technology;2000, Vol. 42 Issue 3/4, p323 

    A lab-scale experiment on the performance of highly concentrated activated sludge in high strength fermentation wastewater treatment with rotary disk type UF membrane was carried out. The experiment lasted 252 days and was operated under continuous and various intermittent aeration conditions....

  • Never Underestimate the Power of an Environmental Management System. Lemons, Julie M.; Yarborough, Jason; Roberts, Dan // Journal: American Water Works Association;Jan2009, Vol. 101 Issue 1, p26 

    The article focuses on the move of the Palm Bay Utilities Department (PBUD) to create a culture that promotes environmental awareness and stewardship throughout its daily operations in Palm Bay, Florida. The PBUD has incorporated green initiatives by implementing its environmental management...

  • Reductive dehalogenation of iopromide by zero-valent iron. Stieber, M.; Putschew, A.; Jekel, M. // Water Science & Technology;2008, Vol. 57 Issue 12, p1969 

    Iodinated X-ray contrast media (ICM), as derivatives of 2, 4, 6-triiodo benzoic acid, are applied in high doses to humans and are excreted unchanged via urine within 24 h. Common as well as advanced wastewater treatment is not able to remove the iodinated compounds leading to an environmental...

  • Role playing games: a methodology to acquire knowledge for integrated wastewater infrastructures management in a river basin scale. Prat, P.; Aulinas, M.; Turon, C.; Comas, J.; Poch, M. // Water Science & Technology;2009, Vol. 59 Issue 9, p1809 

    Current management of sanitation infrastructures (sewer systems, wastewater treatment plant, receiving water, bypasses, deposits, etc) is not fulfilling the objectives of up to date legislation, to achieve a good ecological and chemical status of water bodies through integrated management. These...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics