Climate Change and the Endangered Species Act: The Difficulty of Proving Causation

Gerhart, Matthew
February 2009
Ecology Law Quarterly;2009, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p167
Academic Journal
It is likely that environmental groups will view the Endangered Species Act as a legal tool for forcing action on climate change. This Comment examines the standard for proving causation under section 7 and section 9 of the ESA, and analyzes potential barriers to proving that an entity has violated section 7 or section 9 by contributing to climatic changes that harm a listed species. Plaintiffs face two hurdles under section 7. Given the current models of climate change, defendants have ample evidence to argue that the present concentration of greenhouse gases is such that climate change will occur for many years. As a result, defendants can argue that past actions, not present actions, cause climate change. Furthermore, a defendant can argue that the emissions from a proposed action do not contribute significantly to climate change, and thus do not result in jeopardy. Proving causation under section 9 is also problematic. First, the sheer number of sources of greenhouse gas emissions poses a problem because of the traditional requirement that an entity be liable for harm only if its conduct is a substantial factor in bringing about the harm. Further, the persistence of greenhouse gas emissions in the atmosphere makes it even more difficult to establish that any given emitter's emissions are a substantial factor in causing climate change harm. Third, it is nearly impossible to trace the lifecycle of greenhouse gas emissions from a particular source, which renders it virtually impossible to trace particular emissions to particular climate change harms. Despite these obstacles, and in the aftermath of Massachusetts v. EPA, a plaintiff may still be able to make a reasonable argument that an action causes harm to a listed species. The question remains, however�how much greenhouse gas emissions are enough to satisfy a court's legal standard for causation under the ESA?


Related Articles

  • US EPA FINDING COULD LEAD TO GREENHOUSE GAS REGULATION.  // ENDS (Environmental Data Services);Apr2009, Issue 411, p52 

    The article reports on the proposed finding issued by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that emissions of greenhouse gases from vehicles are contributing to climate change and endanger public health and welfare. A ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court in 2007 stated that greenhouse gases...

  • Climate Change: EPA and DOE Should Do More to Encourage Progress Under Two Voluntary Programs: GAO-06-97.  // GAO Reports;5/25/2006, p1 

    To reduce greenhouse gas emissions linked to climate change, two voluntary programs encourage participants to set emissions reduction goals. The Climate Leaders Program, managed by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), focuses on firms. The Climate VISION (Voluntary Innovative Sector...

  • Greenhouse gas regulation rules upheld.  // Southwest Farm Press Exclusive Insight;7/ 9/2012, p1 

    The article discusses the Court of Appeal for the District of Columbia Circuit's ruling in favor of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) regulation on greenhouse gas emissions in the U.S.

  • U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions Fell 6.1 Percent In 2009--EPA.  // Energy Daily;4/19/2011, Issue 75, p5 

    The article discusses a report from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) which showed that the total greenhouse gas emissions in the U.S., including carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide, fell by 6.1% when compared to 2009 mostly because of the reduction of electricity generation...

  • Inventory of U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks: 1990-2010; Notice of Availability and Request for Comments. McCarthy, Gina // Federal Register (National Archives & Records Service, Office of;2/27/2012, Vol. 77 Issue 38, p11533 

    The article reports that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has issued a notice to declare that the draft inventory of the U.S. greenhouse gas emissions has been available for public review.

  • EPA Proposal Maintains Current Emissions Thresholds for GHG Permits.  // CoatingsTech;Apr2012, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p50 

    The article reports on the proposal made by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to preserve its existing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions thresholds for GHG permits as states develop their GHG permittings programs.

  • EPA Investigators Find Flaws in Endangerment Finding. SISSELL, KARA // Chemical Week;10/3/2011, Vol. 173 Issue 24, p19 

    The article reports on the clarifications issued by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) about a report by the Inspector General on September 28, 2011 which found the failure of the agency to meet requirements in determining whether greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) endanger public health.

  • Monadnock Paper joins EPA Climate Leaders.  // American Printer;Oct2008, Vol. 125 Issue 10, p10 

    The article reports on the decision of Monadnock Paper Mills to join the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's Climate Leaders program. The company has pledged to reduce its corporate-wide greenhouse gas emissions. The Climate Leaders program is an industry-government partnership that works...

  • EPA Rule to Require Greenhouse Gas Disclosure. Jaeger, Jaclyn // Compliance Week;May2009, Vol. 6 Issue 64, p65 

    The article focuses on the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) proposal which will force companies to monitor and report their greenhouse gas emissions in the U.S. The proposed rule is a critical step for EPA in providing factual ground for more comprehensive federal climate change...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics