Mesenchymal Stem Cell Concentration and Bone Repair: Potential Pitfalls from Bench to Bedside

Cuomo, Anna V.; Virk, Mandeep; Petrigliano, Frank; Morgan, Elise F.; Lieberman, Jay R.
May 2009
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;May2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 5, p1073
Academic Journal
Background: Mesenchymal stem cells are multipotent and have the ability to differentiate into bone. We conducted a preclinical trial comparing the osteogenic potential of human bone marrow aspirate with that of mesenchymal stem cell-enriched bone marrow aspirate (both mixed with demineralized bone matrix) in a critical-sized rat femoral defect model. Methods: The buffy coat was extracted from human bone marrow aspirate to obtain mesenchymal stem cell-enriched bone marrow aspirate. Fifty-nine athymic rats, each with a 6-mm femoral defect, were divided into six treatment groups: defect only (Group I), demineralized bone matrix and saline solution (Group II), demineralized bone matrix and bone marrow aspirate (Group Ill), demineralized bone matrix and mesenchymal stem cell-enriched bone marrow aspirate (Group IV), demineralized bone matrix and recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) (Group V [positive control]), and absorbable collagen sponge and rhBMP-2 (Group VI [positive control]). All animals were killed at twelve weeks for radiographic, micro-computed tomography, histomorphometric, and histologic analysis. Results: There was wide variability in the mesenchymal stem cell concentrations obtained from the human donors. All ten defects healed in the positive control groups (Groups V and VI). Only one defect healed in each experimental group (Groups II, III, and IV) (i.e., three of forty-four defects healed). There was no significant difference among the radiographic scores of Groups II, III, and IV (p = 0.59), and the score for each of those groups was significantly higher than that for Group I (p ≤ 0.005) and significantly lower than those for Groups V and VI (p ≤ 0.001). The bone volume and mineral density did not differ among Groups III, IV, and V (p = 0.53). The percent total bone volume and percent normal bone volume in Group VI were significantly higherthan those values in Groups I, Ill, and IV(p < 0.0001) and those in Group II (p = 0.048). In Groups II through V, the cortical bone was more dense than the lace-like bone in Group VI. Conclusions: Neither bone marrow aspirate nor mesenchymal stem cell-enriched bone marrow aspirate mixed with demineralized bone matrix resulted in reliable healing of critical-sized bone defects. It is possible that a greater number of mesenchymal stem cells or an enhanced osteoinductive signal is required for adequate bone-healing. Mesenchymal stem cell and/or carrier variability may also contribute to differences in bone formation. Clinical Relevance: This study identified potential problems when adapting the use of mesenchymal stem cells for consistent bone repair in a clinical setting.


Related Articles

  • Depression-like deficits in rats improved by subchronic modafinil. Regenthal, Ralf; Koch, Holger; Köhler, Christian; Preiss, Rainer; Krügel, Ute // Psychopharmacology;Jul2009, Vol. 204 Issue 4, p627 

    Attentional and sensorimotor gating deficits in human depression are observed as residual symptoms irrespective of antidepressant treatment. Clinical studies point to a benefit of modafinil in depression. No data are available on modafinil effects in depression-like animal models. We...

  • Comparison of haloperidol, risperidone, sertindole, and modafinil to reverse an attentional set-shifting impairment following subchronic PCP administration in the rat—a back translational study. Goetghebeur, Pascal; Dias, Rebecca // Psychopharmacology;Jan2009, Vol. 202 Issue 1-3, p287 

    Selective cognitive impairments, including those of executive function as assessed using the Wisconsin Card Sort Test or intradimensional–extradimensional (ID–ED) tests, are a key feature of schizophrenia but remain inadequately treated by existing therapies. Recently, however,...

  • Effect of Corticosteroids on the Biomechanical Strength of Rat Rotator Cuff Tendon. Mikolyzk, David K.; Wei, Anthony S.; Tonino, Pietro; Marra, Guido; Williams, Denis A.; Himes, Ryan D.; Wezeman, Frederick H.; Callaci, John J. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;May2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 5, p1172 

    Background: The effect of corticosteroids on tendon properties is poorly understood, and current data are contradictory and diverse. The biomechanical effect of steroids on rotator cuff tendon has not been studied, to our knowledge. The current study was undertaken to characterize the...

  • Combination Stem Cell Therapy for the Treatment of Severe Limb Ischemia: Safety and Efficacy Analysis. Lasala, Gabriel P.; Silva, Jose A.; Gardner, Philip A.; Minguell, Jose J. // Angiology;Aug2010, Vol. 61 Issue 6, p551 

    The infusion of a source of endothelial progenitors (EPCs) to limb ischemia (LB) patients has been used to increase angiogenesis. Because the formation of new blood vessels involves, in addition to EPCs, other cells and angiogenic regulators, we postulate that a combination cell therapy...

  • Immunotherapy for the Prevention of Myointimal Hyperplasia After Experimental Balloon Injury of the Rat Carotid Artery. Hansrani, Monica; Stanford, John; McIntyre, Graham; Bottasso, Oscar; Stansby, Gerard // Angiology;Jul2010, Vol. 61 Issue 5, p37 

    We assessed the effect of novel immunotherapeutic heat-killed bacterial (Actinomycetales) preparations on the development of myointimal hyperplasia (MIH) in a rat carotid balloon trauma model and the effect on the immune response by measuring the expression of interferon γ (IFN-γ; (Th1)...

  • The effects of levamisole on experimental endometriosis: a randomized controlled trial in a rat model. Azimirad, Afshin; Alborzi, Saeed; Kumar, Perikala Vijayananda; Zarei, Afsoon; Azimirad, Mina // Archives of Gynecology & Obstetrics;Dec2013, Vol. 288 Issue 6, p1301 

    Purpose: To assess the effects of levamisole on experimental endometriosis in rats through the histopathology of the implants, the blood leukocyte and lymphocyte counts and the concentrations of interleukin-6, vascular endothelial growth factor-A and tumor necrosis factor-alpha in the peritoneal...

  • Gradual and Immediate Nicotine Reduction Result in Similar Low-Dose Nicotine Self-Administration. Smith, Tracy T.; Levin, Melissa E.; Schassburger, Rachel L.; Buffalari, Deanne M.; Sved, Alan F.; Donny, Eric C. // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Nov2013, Vol. 15 Issue 11, p1918 

    Introduction: Food and Drug Administration–mandated product standards that drastically reduce nicotine content in cigarettes aim to decrease smoking and thus improve health outcomes for millions of U.S. smokers. Researchers have suggested that nicotine reduction should be implemented...

  • Comparison of Prednisolone Acetate and Loteprednol Etabonate for the Treatment of Benzalkonium Chloride-Induced Dry Eye Syndrome in Rats. Beyazyıldız, Emrullah; Acar, Uğur; Beyazyıldız, Özlem; Pınarlı, Ferda Alparslan; Albayrak, Aynur; Uğurlu, Nagihan; Tiryaki, Meral; Delibaşi, Tuncay // Journal of Ocular Pharmacology & Therapeutics;May2014, Vol. 30 Issue 4, p306 

    Purpose: The aim of the current study is to compare the effects of two corticosteroids, prednisolone acetate 1% (PA) and loteprednol etabonate 0.5% (LE), for the treatment of benzalkonium chloride (BAC)-induced dry eye syndrome (DES) in rats. Methods: DES was established by topical...

  • Subconjunctival Injection of XG-102, a c-Jun N-Terminal Kinase Inhibitor Peptide, in the Treatment of Endotoxin-Induced Uveitis in Rats. El Zaoui, Ikram; Touchard, Elodie; Berdugo, Marianne; Abadie, Claire; Kowalczuk, Laura; Deloche, Catherine; Zhao, Min; Naud, Marie-Christine; Combette, Jean-Marc; Behar-Cohen, Francine // Journal of Ocular Pharmacology & Therapeutics;Jan/Feb2015, Vol. 31 Issue 1, p17 

    Purpose: XG-102, a TAT-coupled dextrogyre peptide inhibiting the c-Jun N-terminal kinase, was shown efficient in the treatment of experimental uveitis. Preclinical studies are now performed to determine optimal XG-102 dose and route of administration in endotoxin-induced uveitis (EIU) in rats...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics