Different Paths to Economic Reform in Russia and China: Causes and Consequences

Buck, Trevor; Filatotchev, Igor; Nolan, Peter; Wright, Mike
December 2000
Journal of World Business;Winter2000, Vol. 35 Issue 4, p379
Academic Journal
Economic reform in Russia has been described as 'shock therapy' because rapid industrial privatization, price liberalization and democratic reforms of the political system were introduced simultaneously. However, shock therapy led to insider control of most manufacturing firms, with important consequences for foreign investment. In contrast, China's 'gradualist' reforms, without privatization or significant democratization, facilitated foreign joint ventures as the dominant means of reforming State-owned enterprises incrementally. This paper proposes an explanation for these contrasting reform paths in Russia and China and then traces their consequences for inward foreign domestic investment (FDI), exporting and for corporate governance in the short and long term. The impact of national level policies on enterprises is demonstrated in a matched pair of cases in Russia and China. Conclusions are drawn for policy, for practice and for future research.


Related Articles

  • Desperate times Beijing is loosening its grip on the renminbi in a bid to prop up the economy.  // China Economic Review (13506390);Aug2012, p9 

    The article focuses on the economic condition in China in 2012. It highlights the move of senior Chinese officials to announce several reforms which target a special development zone in Shenzhen. It notes that such approaches have put the Qianhai Bay development zone at the forefront of plans to...

  • Enterprise reform and economic restructuring.  // OECD Economic Surveys: Baltic States;Mar2000, p119 

    Discusses the privatization process and its impact on economic restructuring in the Baltic States. Details of the initial stages of privatization; Benefits of the use of vouchers and small privatization; Role of foreign direct investment.

  • Enigma of All Enigmas: Capitalist Takeover? Assessment of the Post-Mao Economic Transformation. Sujian Guo // Journal of Chinese Political Science;Jun98, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p33 

    Assesses the post-Mao economic transformation in China. Growth of capitalist and entrepreneurial class accompanied by large-scale privatization and foreign investment in the urban areas of the country; Aspects of the economic change in post-Mao era.

  • Fin de Siècle China. Qin Hui // Chinese Economy;Sep/Oct2005, Vol. 38 Issue 5, p3 

    The article chronicles the economic and social transition in China after the Tiananmen Democracy Movement in 1989. The movement led to the economic liberalization of the country. Three economic breakthroughs emerged: grain rationing was abolished; a stock market was opened; and privatization of...

  • The Privatization Experience in Malaysia. Hensley, Matthew L.; White, Edward P. // Columbia Journal of World Business;Spring93, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p70 

    The Malaysian privatization program is perhaps the most ambitious program found amongst developing or emerging market economies. While the program did not immediately flourish, it is characterized by its development of a well structured institutional framework and creative use of a series of...

  • How to Define Property Rights? A Social Documentation of the Privatization of Collective Ownership. Zhe Xiaoye; Chen Yingying // Polish Sociological Review;2009, Issue 167, p351 

    Since rural China began to implement economic structural reforms in the late 1970s, township and village collective enterprises (TVEs) have attained significant expansion for a long time. They have became not only sections with most rapid economic development, but also experimental sites for the...

  • East-West Corporate Joint Ventures. Cs�ki, Gy�rgy // Eastern European Economics;Summer93, Vol. 31 Issue 4, p51 

    The establishment of joint ventures is probably the most topical issue of the transformation of any former centrally planned, socialist command economy into a market one. Foreign direct investments, technology imports, the involvement of supplementary funds into the national economy, market...

  • China's Charm Offensive. Moore, St. John; Schache, Ilse // China Business Review;Aug2013, p2 

    The article reports on the efforts of China to enhance its cultural influence on the international economy. Noted is the need for foreign companies in the country to adopt public affairs approach that is more substantive, multifaceted and, sophisticated. Knowledge of the impact of the country's...

  • China's Economic Development Performance Under the Prereform System. Qin Hui // Chinese Economy;Jul/Aug2005, Vol. 38 Issue 4, p61 

    The article assesses the development of the Chinese economy. The author focuses on the factors which contributed to the Chinese economic growth, including the economic system. He emphasizes the merits of reform policies. The author assesses development performance within a specific context of...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics