Sequence polymorphism can produce serious artefacts in real-time PCR assays: hard lessons from Pacific oysters

Taris, Nicolas; Lang, Robert P.; Camara, Mark D.
January 2008
BMC Genomics;2008, Vol. 9, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Background: Since it was first described in the mid-1990s, quantitative real time PCR (Q-PCR) has been widely used in many fields of biomedical research and molecular diagnostics. This method is routinely used to validate whole transcriptome analyses such as DNA microarrays, suppressive subtractive hybridization (SSH) or differential display techniques such as cDNA-AFLP (Amplification Fragment Length Polymorphism). Despite efforts to optimize the methodology, misleading results are still possible, even when standard optimization approaches are followed. Results: As part of a larger project aimed at elucidating transcriptome-level responses of Pacific oysters (Crassostrea gigas) to various environmental stressors, we used microarrays and cDNA-AFLP to identify Expressed Sequence Tag (EST) fragments that are differentially expressed in response to bacterial challenge in two heat shock tolerant and two heat shock sensitive full-sib oyster families. We then designed primers for these differentially expressed ESTs in order to validate the results using Q-PCR. For two of these ESTs we tested fourteen primer pairs each and using standard optimization methods (i.e. melt-curve analysis to ensure amplification of a single product), determined that of the fourteen primer pairs tested, six and nine pairs respectively amplified a single product and were thus acceptable for further testing. However, when we used these primers, we obtained different statistical outcomes among primer pairs, raising unexpected but serious questions about their reliability. We hypothesize that as a consequence of high levels of sequence polymorphism in Pacific oysters, Q-PCR amplification is sub-optimal in some individuals because sequence variants in priming sites results in poor primer binding and amplification in some individuals. This issue is similar to the high frequency of null alleles observed for microsatellite markers in Pacific oysters. Conclusion: This study highlights potential difficulties for using Q-PCR as a validation tool for transcriptome analysis in the presence of sequence polymorphism and emphasizes the need for extreme caution and thorough primer testing when assaying genetically diverse biological materials such as Pacific oysters. Our findings suggest that melt-curve analysis alone may not be sufficient as a mean of identifying acceptable Q-PCR primers. Minimally, testing numerous primer pairs seems to be necessary to avoid false conclusions from flawed Q-PCR assays for which sequence variation among individuals produces artifactual and unreliable quantitative results.


Related Articles

  • Microsatellite Variation in One Breed of Iranian Sheep with 12 Markers. Zahedi-Zahra; Esmaeelkhanian, S.; Torshizi, R. Vaez // Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences;2007, Vol. 10 Issue 24, p4455 

    Polymorphic loci, genetic parameters (Polymorphic Information Content, heterozygosity, Shannon Index, the number of actual alleles, the number of effective alleles) and genetic variation within Balouchi sheep population located m Abbasabad station of Mashad, was assessed using 12 microsatellite...

  • Identification of Polymorphic Loci in Ambystoma annulatum and Review of Cross-species Microsatellite Use in the Genus Ambystoma. Peterman, William E.; Connette, Grant M.; Spatola, Brett N.; Eggert, Lori S.; Semlitsch, Raymond D. // Copeia;9/20/2012, Vol. 2012 Issue 3, p570 

    We screened 74 published microsatellite primers in Ambystoma annulatum, a species for which no microsatellite markers have been developed. Overall, we had a moderate success rate, identifying 11 polymorphic microsatellites previously developed in four different species of Ambystoma. We also...

  • Development and validation of class I SSR markers targeting (GATA) n repeat motifs in rice. Rajendrakumar, Passoupathy; Biswal, Akshaya Kumar; Sakthivel, Kannabiran; Madhav, Maganti Sheshu; Neeraja, Chirravuri; Balachandran, Sena M.; Srinivasarao, Kommoju; Natarajkumar, Podishetty; Hari, Yadla; Sujatha, Kalidindi; Sundaram, Raman M. // Euphytica;Sep2009, Vol. 169 Issue 2, p263 

    SSR markers targeting (GATA) n motifs are known to be highly polymorphic and useful in many organisms. (GATA) n motif specific SSR markers covering the whole rice genome are not available. The present study was carried out with an objective to identify class I rice microsatellites in the rice...

  • PCR-based markers for the powdery mildew resistance gene Pm4a in wheat. Ma, Z.-Q.; Wei, J.-B.; Cheng, S.-H. // Theoretical & Applied Genetics;Jun2004, Vol. 109 Issue 1, p140 

    Gene tagging is the basis of marker-assisted selection and map-based cloning. To develop PCR-based markers for Pm4a, a dominant powdery mildew resistance gene of wheat, we surveyed 46 group 2 microsatellite markers between Pm4a near-isogenic line (NIL) CI 14124 and the recurrent parent...

  • Real-Time PCR is a Real Advantage. Tuason, Nico // Genomics & Proteomics;Apr2003, Vol. 3 Issue 3, p44 

    Discusses advantages of real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Quantification of the number of DNA molecules in an assay; Results of Omega Beacon's probe for real-time PCR to test its effectiveness; Potential solution to the issue of data quality from microarray analysis.

  • Y chromosome compound haplotypes with the microsatellite markers DXYS265, DXYS266, and DXYS241. Lee, J.; Kotliarova, S. E.; Ewis, A. A.; Hida, A.; Shinka, T.; Kuroki, Y.; Tokunaga, K.; Nakahori, Y. // Journal of Human Genetics;2001, Vol. 46 Issue 2, p80 

    Abstract Two newly developed microsatellite markers on Yp11 (DXYS265) and Yq11.21 (DXYS266) and our previously reported marker, on Yp11 (DXYS241), were typed by triplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in 102 Japanese, 18 white American, and 17 black American males. The DXYS265 locus revealed...

  • A 1-year investigation of the parasite Haplosporidium nelsoni (MSX) in the Pacific oyster Crassostrea gigas from Dayaowan Bay, China. Zhongwei Wang; Xin Lu; Yubo Liang // Parasitology Research;Jun2010, Vol. 107 Issue 1, p189 

    The infection prevalence of the protozoan parasite Haplosporidium nelsoni (MSX) in Pacific oysters ( Crassostrea gigas), collected from Dayaowan Bay on the north coast of the Yellow Sea, China, was investigated in 2007. The traditional histological method of diagnosing H. nelsoni infection in...

  • Haplotypes without children: PCR applied to close loci on individual human sperm. Crouau-Roy, B.; Clayton, J. // Human Biology;Feb95, Vol. 67 Issue 1, p171 

    Investigates the feasibility of multiple polymerase chain reaction (PCR) of linked markers on individual sperm and demonstrates the possibility of microsatellite polymorphism alleles. Use of three loci in the human major histocompatibility complex (MHC); Rate of double typings comparable with...

  • Sequence analysis of the first internal transcribed spacer of rDNA supports the existence of the intermediate Fasciola between F. hepatica and F. gigantica in mainland China. R. Lin; S. Dong; K. Nie; C. Wang; H. Song; A. Li; W. Huang; X. Zhu // Parasitology Research;Aug2007, Vol. 101 Issue 3, p813 

    Abstract  In the present study, a polymerase chain reaction-linked single-strand conformation polymorphism (PCR-SSCP) approach combined with DNA sequencing was used to characterise samples of Fasciola spp. from different host species and geographical locations in mainland China. The first...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics