Consistency in Women's Reports of Sensitive Behavior In an Interview Mode Experiment, São Paulo, Brazil

Mensch, Barbara S.; Hewett, Paul C.; Jones, Heidi E.; Luppi, Carla Gianni; Lippman, Sheri A.; Pinho, Adriana A.; Diaz, Juan
December 2008
International Family Planning Perspectives;Dec2008, Vol. 34 Issue 4, p169
Academic Journal
CONTEXT: Inaccurate reporting of sexual behavior creates a misleading picture of individuals' risk for STI infection. Despite a substantial body of U.S. research on the consistency of self-reports of sensitive behavior, only a few such studies have been conducted in developing countries. METHODS: Consistency in the reporting of sexual activity and other sensitive behaviors was assessed among 818 women aged 18-40 who enrolled in 2004 in a study examining STI screening and diagnosis in São Paulo, Brazil. Participants were randomized into face-to-face interview and audio computer-assisted self-interview(audio-CASI) groups, and a six-week follow-up interview was conducted using audio-CASI for all participants. Differences between groups were assessed using t tests, and logistic regression analyses were used to estimate the likelihood of inconsistency within the enrollment interview and between the enrollment and follow-up interviews. RESULTS: Consistency in reporting at the enrollment interview was higher in the face-to-face group than in the audio-CASI group, likely because interviewers prompted women to reconcile discrepant responses, whereas the audio-CASI program did not enforce logical consistency. However, consistency between enrollment and follow-up was significantly lower in the face-to-face group for abortion, marijuana use, transactional sex, coerced sex and number of lifetime sexual partners, because of increased reporting at follow-up using audio-CASI. CONCLUSION: Although the analysis of internal consistency at enrollment suggests that computerized interviewing may increase random measurement error, it appears to reduce social desirability bias and encourage higher reporting of sensitive behaviors.


Related Articles

  • Gonorrhea Rates: What Denominator is Most Appropriate? Aral, Sevgi O.; Schaffer, Jean E.; Mosher, William D.; Cates Jr., Willard // American Journal of Public Health;Jun88, Vol. 78 Issue 6, p702 

    We used traditional crude population denominators and four different definitions of sexual activity to calculate progressively more refined gonorrhea rates among reproductive age women. Refining denominators to take sexual activity into account had the largest impact on morbidity rates for young...

  • Subgroups of US Women Differ Widely in Exposure to Sexual Intercourse. Klitsch, M. // Family Planning Perspectives;Mar/Apr90, Vol. 22 Issue 2, p94 

    This article focuses on a study that explored associations between sexual behavior and a woman's risk of contracting a sexually transmitted disease (STD). An unpublished data from the 1982 National Survey of Family Growth show that adolescents were substantially less likely to have been sexually...

  • YOU CAN GET MORE... Satisfaction. Karbo, Karen // Organic Style;May/Jun2003, Vol. 3 Issue 3, p66 

    Presents an article on better sex at the age of 40. Factors that make sex better at the age of 40; Physical changes on a woman's body at the age of 40.

  • Cosmo's 10 commandments of sex. O'Connor, Gail // Cosmopolitan;Jan1999, Vol. 226 Issue 1, p138 

    Offers tips for women about sex. How to please the partner; Advice about faking orgasm; Benefits of fantasizing while having sex.

  • POLE POSITIONS.  // Ralph;Apr2004, p72 

    Interviews Carla, Brooke and Lina Jade, three former West Australia Miss Indy 2003 finalists on their preferred sex positions. Views on multiple positions in one session; Best position for a quickie; Undesirable sexual positions.

  • Uncover Your Sensual Side. Kemp, Kristen // Cosmopolitan;Oct99, Vol. 227 Issue 4, p176 

    Reveals some tips on how to heighten the man's sexual pleasure through the woman's moves. Erotic eye contact; Importance of scents when making love; Importance of mood-setting music when making love. INSET: Round-the-World Randy Recipes.

  • Eating Spring Rice: Transactional Sex in the Era of Epidemics. Hyde, Sandra Teresa // Harvard China Review;Spring2004, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p77 

    Discusses the complication of sexually transmitted infection (STI) and sex culture in China. Factors that contributed to the prevalence of STI in the country in the 1990s, including tourism; Role of hair salons in prostitution; Challenge faced by Chinese women regarding their sexual citizenship.

  • Sex Lies.  // Dolly;Mar2007, Issue 437, p123 

    The article provides information on sexual intercourse. Sixteen is the legal age to have sex in most, but not all, states and territories in Australia. In South Australia and Tasmania, the legal age to have sex is seventeen. According to a doctor, sexually transmitted infections are caused by...

  • sexually transmitted disease (STD):. Huber, Jeffrey T.; Gillaspy, Mary L. // Encyclopedic Dictionary of AIDS-Related Terminology;2000, p199 

    A definition of the term "sexually transmitted disease" is presented. It refers to a disease acquired as a result of sexual intercourse, heterosexual or homosexual, with an infected partner. The term is more inclusive than venereal disease, as it includes certain conditions that can also be...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics