The Value of Mentorship in Orthopaedic Surgery Resident Education: The Residents' Perspective

Flint, John H.; Jahangir, A. Alex; Browner, Bruce D.; Mehta, Samir
April 2009
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Apr2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 4, p1017
Academic Journal
Background: The concept of mentoring is believed to be influential in an effective medical and surgical educational environment. Several authors have discussed the issue of mentorship and its challenges, yet no one has studied the prevalence of mentoring among orthopaedic residency programs and its perceived value from the orthopaedic residents' perspective. Methods: Between January 1, 2008, and February 1, 2008, a survey created by the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons was distributed by mail and e-mail to 3655 orthopaedic residents to obtain their opinion of the value of and their experience with mentorship. Results: Five hundred and six (14%) of the surveyed residents responded. Nearly half of the responding residents either had a mentor or were involved in a mentoring program. Nearly all ranked the value of mentorship as very high and anticipated substantial help from their mentor in their career, research, and education. Only 44% were satisfied with their mentoring environment, and only 17% were highly satisfied. The residents were most satisfied with mentoring when there was a formal program in place. Ninety-six percent of the respondents thought that mentors were either critical or beneficial to their training. Residents who had selected their own mentor were more satisfied with their mentor than were those who had their mentor assigned. Conclusions: Residents with mentors, residents in mentoring programs, and residents who selected their own mentors had higher satisfaction with their mentoring environmentthan did those with no formal mentoring program. Residency programs should consider establishing formal mentorship programs and encourage residents to select their own mentors.


Related Articles

  • Mentoring in Resident Education: How to Make it Work. Krueger, Chad A.; Stinner, Daniel J.; Ficke, James R. // AAOS Now;Jul2012, Vol. 6 Issue 7, p9 

    The article focuses on how to achieve successful mentoring in resident education among orthopaedic organizations in the U.S. It mentions that mentoring can be a significant professional development medium and is considered as an essential facet of resident training. It notes that pairing mentors...

  • Quality of Principal Mentoring Uneven, Report Says. Olson, Lynn // Education Week;4/18/2007, Vol. 26 Issue 33, p5 

    The article discusses the topic of mentoring for school principals. Many states require mentoring for new principals during their first years on the job, but many are not getting the mentoring they need, according to report by the New York City-based Wallace Foundation. The report, "Getting...

  • Mentoring Radiation Therapy Students: A Review and Survey. Trad, Megan L. // Radiation Therapist;Fall2009, Vol. 18 Issue 2, p101 

    The article discusses the significance of mentorship programs for radiation therapy students. It notes the survey which was conducted on radiation therapy students to evaluate the need and effectiveness of mentorship programs. It mentions the results which found more confidence and positive...

  • Portraits of Mentor-Junior Faculty Relationships: From Power Dynamics to Collaboration. COWIN, KATHLEEN M.; COHEN, LEONORA M.; CIECHANOWSKI, KATHRYN M.; OROZCO, RICHARD A. // Journal of Education;2011/2012, Vol. 192 Issue 1, p37 

    The article focuses on the mentoring experiences of three junior faculty members at Oregon State University. The authors describe how they created portraits to conduct their self-study, explain their utilized theoretical framework Cultural-Historical Activity Theory (CHAT), and provide...

  • Evaluation of a School-based Mentoring Program for At-Risk Middle School Youth. Converse, Noelle; Lignugaris/Kraft, Benjamin // Remedial & Special Education;Jan/Feb2009, Vol. 30 Issue 1, p33 

    This study investigated the impact of a school-based mentoring program on at-risk students' office referrals, unexcused absences, and school attitude. Students who participated in the mentoring program had statistically significant reductions in office referrals and statistically significant...

  • MENTORING RESEARCH STUDENTS. GARG, Indu // Journal Plus Education / Educatia Plus;2014, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p119 

    Mentoring is a professional relationship between a mentor and a mentee to support and encourage learning in the mentee. Research in educational institutions is a scholarly activity facilitated by a faculty member who is the research supervisor and also a mentor who can introduce the young...

  • A STUDY OF MENTORING PROCESS IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF PERSONNEL IN THE FIELD OF HIGHER EDUCATION. Shukla, Shiva; Mathur, Anshu // Golden Research Thoughts;Oct2013, Vol. 3 Issue 4, p1 

    Strategic Human Resource Management (HRM) decisions have unique influence on the organizational performances. The management employee relationship has gone under major change in recent times more than ever. Mentoring is a relationship aimed at fostering the development of the less experienced...

  • Asserting the Right to Belong: Feminist Co-Mentoring among Graduate Student Women. GODBEE, BETH; NOVOTNY, JULIA C. // Feminist Teacher;2013, Vol. 23 Issue 3, p177 

    The article discusses an empirical study that identified how mentoring women graduate students assert their right to belong in their chosen academic field. Topics covered include analysis of recorded data on two-way feminist co-mentoring in the interviews and videos of tutor-writer pairings and...

  • Group-Advantaged Training of Research (GATOR): A Metamorphosis of Mentorship. Edwards, Thea M.; Smith, Barbara K.; Watts, Danielle L.; Germain-Aubrey, Charlotte C.; Roark, Alison M.; Bybee, Seth M.; Cox, Clayton E.; Hamlin, Heather J.; Guillette Jr., Louis J. // BioScience;Apr2011, Vol. 61 Issue 4, p301 

    We describe Group-Advantaged Training of Research (GATOR), a yearlong structured program at the University of Florida that guided graduate student mentors and their undergraduate mentees through the mentored research process. Using the national Survey of Undergraduate Research Experiences for an...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics