Prospective randomised multi-centre trial comparing the clinical efficacy, safety and patient acceptability of circular stapled anopexy with closed diathermy haemorrhoidectomy

M A Thaha
May 2009
Gut;May2009, Vol. 58 Issue 5, p668
Academic Journal
OBJECTIVE: Unlike excisional haemorrhoidectomy, stapled anopexy (SA), which does not involve radical excision, has theoretical advantages, thus offering potential patient benefits. We compared the clinical efficacy, safety and patient acceptability of SA, with closed haemorrhoidectomy (CH). PATIENTS AND METHODS: 182 patients with symptomatic haemorrhoids (grades II, III, IV) were randomly assigned to receive SA or CH and were followed for up to 1 year (6, 12, 24, 48 weeks) after operation. Postoperative pain, symptom control, complications, re-treatment rates, patient satisfaction, and quality of life were compared on an intention-to-treat basis. RESULTS: Postoperative pain in the SA group (n = 91) was significantly lower (p = 0.004, Mann–Whitney U test). At 1 year there were no significant differences in the symptom load, symptom severity or the disease severity between the two groups. Overall complication rates were similar but faecal urgency was reported more frequently following SA (p = 0.093, Fisher’s exact test). Despite a similar rate of residual symptoms, prolapse control was better with CH (p = 0.087, Fisher’s exact test), and more patients in the SA group required re-treatment for residual prolapse at 1 year (p = 0.037, Fisher’s exact test). However, more patients rated SA as an excellent operation at 6 and 12 weeks (p = 0.008 and 0.033, binary logistic regression) and were willing to undergo a repeat procedure if required (p = 0.018, Fisher’s exact test). CONCLUSION: Stapled anopexy offers a significantly less painful alternative to excisional haemorrhoidectomy and achieves a higher patient acceptability. Although the overall symptom control and safety are similar in the majority of the patients, the re-treatment rate for recurrent prolapse at 1 year is higher following SA when compared to CH.


Related Articles

  • Radiofrequency versus conventional diathermy Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy: a prospective, randomized study. Franceschilli, Luana; Stolfi, Vito M.; D' Ugo, Stefano; Angelucci, Giulio P.; Lazzaro, Sara; Picone, Emanuele; Gaspari, Achille; Sileri, Pierpaolo // International Journal of Colorectal Disease;Oct2011, Vol. 26 Issue 10, p1345 

    Background: In the past decade, several new surgical tools have revived the hope for an improved technique to treat radically hemorrhoids with less postoperative pain. Among these radiofrequency (RF), excisional surgery seems to be safe, fast, and accompanied by less postoperative pain. The aim...

  • Navigate Your Way to Proper Internal/External Hemorrhoid Coding.  // General Surgery Coding Alert;Mar2010, Vol. 12 Issue 3, p19 

    The article looks at the guides to help choose the proper internal or external hemorrhoid coding. It discusses the basics on how to specify internal or external hemorrhoid by looking at the internal hemorrhoid excision codes. In addition, a surgeon should use the specific code 46250,...

  • LigaSure-assisted versus diathermy day case haemorroidectomy: a randomized controlled trial. Fok, K. L.; Cheung, M. H. Y.; Poon, C. M.; Lee, K. W. // Ambulatory Surgery;Mar2008, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p1 

    Aim: Milligan-Morgan haemorrhoidectomy is considered the best treatment for haemorrhoidal disease. The major drawback is severe post-operative pain. We postulate that using the LigaSureâ„¢ vessel sealing system to divide the haemorrhoidal pedicle may cause less postoperative pain. Methods:...

  • Hemorrhoidectomy for Thrombosed External Hemorrhoids. Zuber, Thomas J. // American Family Physician;4/15/2002, Vol. 65 Issue 8, p1629 

    Presents information on hemorrhoidectomy, a clinical procedure for thrombosed external hemorrhoids. Materials needed for the procedure; Description of the procedure; Discussion on the need for extensive training and experience prior to attempting the procedure unsupervised.

  • Long term patient satisfaction and quality of life with AMS700CX inflatable penile prosthesis. Vitarelli, Antonio; Divenuto, Lucia; Fortunato, Francesca; Falco, Antonio; Pagliarulo, Vincenzo; Antonini, Gabriele; Gentile, Vincenzo; Sciarra, Alessandro; Salciccia, Stefano; Sansalone, Salvatore; Di Placido, Maria Rosaria; Garaffa, Giulio; Pagliarulo, Arcangelo // Archivio Italiano di Urologia, Andrologia: Organo Ufficiale di S;Sep2013, Vol. 85 Issue 3, p133 

    Objective: Penile prosthesis implantation is the solution of choice in patients who have failed or present contraindication to the use of all conservative treatment for erectile dysfunction (ED). Overall, satisfaction rates are high, with more than 80% of patients and partners fully satisfied...

  • A Comparison of Open versus Closed Techniques Using the Harmonic Scalpel in Outpatient Hemorrhoid Surgery. Sohn, Vance Y.; Martin, Matthew J.; Mullenix, Philip S.; Cuadrado, Daniel G.; Place, Ronald J.; Steele, Scott R. // Military Medicine;Jul2008, Vol. 173 Issue 7, p689 

    Background: Surgical excision using the Harmonic Scalpel is a modem technique for symptomatic third-and fourth-degree hemorrhoids. The resulting mucosal defect is then left open or sutured closed depending on surgeon preference. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to compare the open vs....

  • Operative treatment for volar plate avulsion fractures of the fingers. Lee, Sanglim; Jung, Eui; Kim, Ji // Archives of Orthopaedic & Trauma Surgery;Oct2013, Vol. 133 Issue 10, p1463 

    We present our experience with 14 volar plate avulsion fractures of the fingers that were treated by excision or internal fixation and discuss the factors affecting the operative techniques and results. Fourteen cases were divided into two groups: the volar plate avulsions with excision (eight...

  • Minilaparoscopic Colorectal Resections: Technical Note. Bona, S.; Molteni, M.; Montorsi, M. // Minimally Invasive Surgery (20901445);2012, p1 

    Laparoscopic colorectal resections have been shown to provide short-term advantages in terms of postoperative pain, general morbidity, recovery, and quality of life. To date, long-term results have been proved to be comparable to open surgery irrefutably only for colon cancer. Recently, new...

  • Impact of Facial Dysfunction on Quality of Life After Vestibular Schwannoma Surgery. Lassaletta, Luis; Alfonso, Carolina; Del Rio, Laura; Roda, Jose Maria; Gavilan, Javier // Annals of Otology, Rhinology & Laryngology;Sep2006, Vol. 115 Issue 9, p694 

    Objectives: This study was performed to evaluate the impact of facial dysfunction on quality of life in patients who underwent surgery for vestibular schwannoma. Other factors with a possible impact on quality of life were also assessed. Methods: We performed a retrospective review of 95...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics