Consolidation and News Content: How Broadcast Ownership Policy Impacts Local Television News and the Public Interests

Smith, Laura K.
January 2009
Journalism & Communication Monographs;Winter2009, Vol. 10 Issue 4, p387
Academic Journal
In 1999, the Federal Communications Commission changed the Local Television Ownership Rule, allowing a single company to own two television stations in the same media market. The new rules led to the creation of dozens of "duopolies" nationwide. This longitudinal case study analyzed the newscasts of one of the nation's first duopolies. The author sought to discover what kind of long-term impact ownership consolidation had on newscasts in Jacksonville, Florida. Using a quasi-experimental research design, the newscast content of two stations was compared when they were separately owned. After consolidation, content produced by the duopoly was compared with pre-consolidation newscasts. Sixty newscasts and 1,048 stories were analyzed to answer the question: Do the combined resources of two television stations translate into higher quality local coverage? Results were mixed. The study empirically measured diversity and localism - two factors critical in the examination of broadcasting in the public interest. Diversity was operationally defined as range of topics, topic of "lead" stories, and range of voices. Results show the duopoly significantly increased its coverage of local government, politics, construction and growth but decreased its coverage of public safety and non-dominant groups. A shift away from crime coverage was seen for lead stories. There was no significant increase in the number of local sources or the diversity of sources (women and minorities) appearing in news coverage. Localism was operationally defined as the amount of locally produced news, the geographic focus of coverage, the number of local reporters featured, and the amount of locally-produced enterprise reporting. Results show the number of stories and time dedicated to local news increased significantly after the duopoly was created. Allocation of reporters to news coverage did not increase. While the number of enterprise stories decreased, the amount of time dedicated to enterprise stories increased - a finding which has methodological implications for future researchers. Results indicate that economies of scale achieved through local television consolidation may translate to higher quality coverage in some content areas but not others. The findings contribute empirical evidence to the long-standing debate between public interest versus free market theorists. Implications for policy-makers are examined.


Related Articles

  • Self-Censoring in the Newsroom. Hirsch, Mark // Broadcasting & Cable;6/21/2004, Vol. 134 Issue 25, p44 

    Talks about the indecency rules of the U.S. Federal Communications Commission. Criticism against the radical self-censorship of live news; Passage of the Broadcast Indecency Enforcement Act of 2004; Need for content providers to protect live news gathering.

  • News, ad staffs may feel impact of new rules. Halonen, Doug; Stark, Steven J. // Electronic Media;08/09/99, Vol. 18 Issue 32, p33 

    Reports on the potential effects of the United States Federal Communications Commission's ruling on television station duopolies on television news broadcasting and advertising. Expansion of news franchises; Consolidation of advertising staff; Economic value of combining staff and sales.

  • Hearst Knows Value of Political Coverage.  // Television Week;4/3/2006, Vol. 25 Issue 14, p12 

    The article reports on the decision of Hearst-Argyle to devote a minimum of 10 minutes of time each weekday on its local TV stations in the U.S. to coverage of political news. It asserts that when a station covers political discourse and does it well, it is encouraging a discussion of a subject...

  • Meaning of ratings is in the eye of the beholder. Frohlichstein, Tripp // St. Louis Journalism Review;Jul2007, Vol. 37 Issue 297, p16 

    This article examines the Nielsen television ratings for news programs in the St. Louis, Missouri, area. KTVI was the leader in the 5:30-6:30am time slot, while KMOV won the midday news slot and was very competitive in the 10pm time period. The author feels that for the first time in decades,...

  • NEWS Briefs.  // Television Week;5/2/2005, Vol. 24 Issue 18, p6 

    Presents news briefs on the television industry in the U.S. as of May 2005. Television ratings received by CBS on April 28, 2005; Plans of Turner Broadcasting to buy the premiere broadcast window for "Matrix Reloaded" from Warner Bros.; Postponement of the hearings on a legislation for...

  • Duopoly Ownership and Local Informational Programming on Broadcast Television: Before-After Comparisons. Yan, MichaelZhaoxu; Park, YongJin // Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media;Jul2009, Vol. 53 Issue 3, p383 

    This study examines the relationship between duopoly ownership structure and the supply of local news and public affairs programming in the local television market. The results show that both duopoly stations and non-duopoly stations significantly increased their local news programming from 1997...

  • Blind TV. Absher, Frank // St. Louis Journalism Review;Dec99/Jan2000, Vol. 30 Issue 222, p3 

    Reports on the United States Federal Communications Commission's (FCC) proposal that television network affiliates provide a special television service for blind people. Audio channel that broadcasts an aural description of action when there are pauses in dialogue; Programming that would be...

  • Comp is prize in ENG package. McConnell, Bill // Broadcasting & Cable;07/10/2000, Vol. 130 Issue 29, p14 

    Reports on the United States Federal Communications Commission's (FCC) plan for reallocating the electronic news gathering (ENG) spectrum that some television stations use for remote news coverage. Enabling of broadcasters to negotiate for compensation from spectrum users; Accommodation of...

  • Media Ownership Regulations and Local News Programming on Broadcast Television: An Empirical Analysis. Napoli, PhilipM.; Yan, MichaelZhaoxu // Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media;Mar2007, Vol. 51 Issue 1, p39 

    This study analyzes the provision of local news programming on local television and its relation with station ownership characteristics and market conditions. The results show that station financial strength and market competition have a significant, positive relation with the quantity of local...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics