The state is still in the bedrooms of the nation: The control and regulation of sexuality in Canadian criminal law

Young, Alan
September 2008
Canadian Journal of Human Sexuality;2008, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p203
Academic Journal
Canada has seen a considerable relaxing of linguistic and visual taboos related to sexuality over the past 50 years. This article explores the response of modern criminal law to such changes with particular emphasis on the inability of obscenity and indecency laws to resist the emergence of highly sexualized materials in society and the lack of any meaningful legal reform in our laws on prostitution. Case examples and legal precedents are drawn upon to illustrate a variety of sexuality-related issues grappled with by legislators, politicians and society in seeking to determine what sexual practices should be prohibited. Canadian laws on prostitution, which put sex workers at risk without significantly diminishing the incidence of the phenomenon, are considered in terms of the rationale for legislated regulation in this domain. An overarching theme in this and other such examples is the role of criminal legislation in addressing the tension between private sexual morality and public policy in a pluralistic society.


Related Articles

  • Constitutional Law.  // California Law Review;Nov69, Vol. 57 Issue 5, p1257 

    Describes legislative guidelines on obscenity in the United States illustrated in the case 'Stanley v. Georgia'. Examination of the evolution of first amendment obscenity doctrine; Discussion of the impact of the case on the doctrine; Analysis of arguments advanced to justify censorship of...

  • California lawyers call for repeal of sex laws.  // Advocate;10/10/73, Issue 122, p5 

    Reports on the endorsed repeal of state sex laws in California. Approval of alternate legislation; Laws that are included in the repeal.

  • Consent bill not dead, says author.  // Advocate;10/10/73, Issue 122, p20 

    Reports on the status of the adult sex act bill in San Francisco, California. Endorsement of the bill; Closing date of the bill; Chances for the bill's approval.

  • Sexual and Textual Indeterminacy: Eighteenth-Century English Representations of Sapphism. Craft-Fairchild, Catherine // Journal of the History of Sexuality;Sep2006, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p408 

    This article presents a perspective on the work of the 18th century authors on sexual and textual indeterminacy. The authors own terminology participates in the very discursive instability he is attempting to represent. Concentrating on eighteenth-century works as sites of unresolved linguistic...

  • Obscenity: Head-in-sand laws stay. Jackson, Ed // Advocate;12/8/71, Issue 74, p29 

    Part IV. Presents a draft of the proposed California Criminal Law. Practice of trafficking in obscenity; Defense of police entrapment; Attempt of discouraging police misconduct.

  • Ontario judge rips into obscenity law "trap". Waldorf, Lee // Body Politic;Jan85, Issue 110, p9 

    Focuses on the judgment handed down on November 27, 1984 by Ontario County Court judge Stephen Borins regarding the obscenity laws of Canada. Advice of Borins for future prosecutions.

  • Hets get relief at 16; Gays have 2-year wait. Jackson, Ed // Advocate;12/27/71, Issue 71, p12 

    Comments on the proposed revision package for the Penal Code in California. Legality of specific sexual acts for consenting adults under the revised proposal; Acceptability of the designation on the normal sexual foreplay of many heterosexuals; Disagreement with the proposed revisions relating...

  • Brown Bill May Get Hearing This Month.  // Advocate;May1969, Vol. 3 Issue 5, p9 

    Reports that the Assembly Criminal Procedures Committee will be considering Assembly Bill 734, the measure that will remove sex acts between consenting adults from California's criminal laws.

  • Puritans triumph still! Jackson, Ed // Advocate;11/24/71, Issue 73, p25 

    Part III. Focuses on the proposal to replace the Penal Code of California. Decision of the staff of the Joint Legislative Committee for Revision of the Penal Code to take the specific sexual acts of consenting adults out of the realm of legal concern; Definition of sexual intercourse, deviant...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics