Marginal Integrity of Self- and Total-etching Adhesives in Two Different Application Protocols

Ernst, Claus-Peter; Tim Kötter; Victor, Anja; Canbek, Kerem; Brandenbusch, Mathias; Willershausen, Brita
March 2004
Journal of Adhesive Dentistry;2004, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p25
Academic Journal
Purpose: The aim of this study was to evaluate the marginal integrity of four self-etching adhesives (Prompt L-Pop III, Resulcin Aqua Prime & MonoBond N, AC Bond, AC Bond + Desensitizer) and three total-etch adhesives (Opti-Bond FL, Excite, Gluma Comfort Bond) in two different application protocols. Materials and Methods: Standardized MOD cavities (n = 40) were prepared in 280 extracted human teeth (one cervical margin in cementum, one in enamel). In one application protocol, the adhesive was applied prior to placement of the Tofflemire matrix (n = 20); in the other, the metal matrix was placed first (n = 20). Light curing was carried out from the occlusal aspect. After thermocycling (5000 times, 5°C and 55°C), specimens were immersed in 2% methylene blue for 10 s. Then the median percentages of dye-penetrated margins (surface analysis) were determined separately for the cervical cementum, cervical enamel, and lateral enamel margins of the proximal boxes. Results: At the cervical cementum margins, statistically significantly worse results were obtained for all adhesives when the matrix system was placed prior to application of the adhesive. In the cervical enamel margins, OptiBond FL, Gluma Comfort Bond, and Prompt L-Pop III performed significantly better when the adhesive was applied prior to the matrix. On lateral enamel margins, only OptiBond FL and Resulcin Aqua Prime showed significantly less dye penetration if the matrix was placed first. Conclusion: Most of the total-etch materials produced marginal integrity significantly superior to that of the majority of the self-etching materials. Due to a significant influence of the application protocol on marginal integrity, it is strongly recommended to apply the adhesive system before placement of the matrix.


Related Articles

  • Cusp Reinforcement by the Acid-etch Technique. MORIN, D.; DeLONG, R.; DOUGLAS, W. H. // Journal of Dental Research;Aug1984, Vol. 63 Issue 8, p1075 

    Strain gauges were mounted on 12 maxillary pre-molars which were subjected to a sequence of restorative procedures for MOD preparations. An occlusal stress was applied using servohydraulics, and the cuspal flexure was assessed using a strain gauge. Two bonded and three non-bonded restorative...

  • Water Concentration in Self-etching Primers Affects their Aggressiveness and Bonding Efficacy to Dentin. Hiraishi, N.; Nishiyama, N.; Ikemura, K.; Yau, J. Y. Y.; King, N. M.; Tagami, J.; Pashley, D. H.; Tay, F. R. // Journal of Dental Research;Jul2005, Vol. 84 Issue 7, p653 

    Water is required to ionize acid resin monomers for demineralization of tooth substrates. We tested the null hypothesis that altering the water concentration in two-step self-etching primers has no effect on their aggressiveness and bonding efficacy to dentin. Five experimental self-etching...

  • A Comparison of the Tensile Bond Strengths of Composite Resins to Longitudinal and Transverse Sections of Enamel Prisms in Human Teeth. MUNECHIKA, T.; SUZUKI, K.; NISHIYAMA, M.; OHASHI, M.; HORIE, K. // Journal of Dental Research;Aug1984, Vol. 63 Issue 8, p1079 

    The tensile bond strengths of composite resins to transverse and longitudinal sections of enamel prisms etched with phosphoric acid were examined. The tensile bond strengths were 18-19 MPa to the transverse and 10-11 MPa to the longitudinal sections and thus were influenced by the nature of the...

  • Bond Strength of Adhesive/Composite Combinations to Dentin Involving Totaland Self-etch Adhesives. Moll, Karlheinz; Hyun-Jung Park; Haller, Bernd // Journal of Adhesive Dentistry;2002, Vol. 4 Issue 3, p171 

    Purpose: To compare the bonding potential to human dentin of adhesive/composite combinations including five 2-step and two 3-step total-etch (TE) bonding systems, two systems with self-conditioning (SC) primers, and one SC all-in-one adhesive by use of the microtensile bond test. Methods: Hybrid...

  • Bond strength of adhesives to dentin involving total and self-etch adhesives. Feridun Hürmüzlü; A. Kemal Özdemir; Hubbezoglu, Ihsan; Coskun, Akin; Seyda Hergüner Siso // Quintessence International;Apr2007, Vol. 38 Issue 4, p206 

    Objective: Currently, the trend in dentin adhesion seems to be shifting from moist bonding systems to self-etching systems and from several application steps to single steps. However, recent studies have indicated that the performance of single-step adhesives was lower than the 2-step self-etch...

  • An in vitro comparative assessment of different enamel contaminants during bracket bonding. Faltermeier, Andreas; Behr, Michael; Rosentritt, Martin; Reicheneder, Claudia; Müßig, Dieter // European Journal of Orthodontics;Dec2007, Vol. 29 Issue 6, p559 

    In orthodontics, adhesive failures can occur because of saliva contamination during bonding. However, most in vitro studies concerning bond strength of saliva-contaminated enamel disregard the influence of temperature changes in a wet environment. The aim of the present study was to compare the...

  • Hydrolytic Stability of One-step Self-etching Adhesives Bonded to Dentin.  // Journal of Adhesive Dentistry;2011, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p243 

    Purpose: To evaluate the hydrolytic stability of three one-step self-etching adhesives (1-SEAs) bonded to dentin through bond strength testing and ultra-morphological interfacial analysis before and after long-term thermocycling. Materials and Methods: Eighteen flattened mid-coronal dentin...

  • Marginal Integrity: Is the Clinical Performance of Bonded Restorations Predictable In Vitro? Frankenberger, Roland; Krämer, Norbert; Lohbauer, Ulrich; Nikolaenko, Sergej A.; Reich, Sven M. // Journal of Adhesive Dentistry;2007, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p107 

    Purpose: In vitro testing of dental materials is daily routine for the preclinical investigation of restoratives. Although clinical trials remain the ultimate instrument, preclinical screenings are still important. However, it is still not fully understood whether clinical performance is...

  • Selective Enamel Etching Reconsidered: Better than Etch-and-Rinse and Self-etch? Frankenberger, Roland; Lohbauer, Ulrich; Roggendorf, Matthias J.; Naumann, Michael; Taschner, Michael // Journal of Adhesive Dentistry;2008, Vol. 10 Issue 5, p339 

    Purpose: This study evaluated the marginal quality of differently bonded direct resin composite restorations in enamel and dentin, before and after thermomechanical loading (TML). Special attention was focussed on the performance of selective enamel etching, etch-and-rinse, and self-etching...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics