Open Reduction and Internal Fixation Compared with Circular Fixator Application for Bicondylar Tibial Plateau Fractures

Hall, Jeremy A.; Beuerlein, Murray J.; McKee, Michael D.
March 2009
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Mar2009 Supplement, Vol. 91-A, p74
Academic Journal
BACKGROUND: Standard open reduction and internal fixation techniques have been successful in restoring osseous alignment for bicondylar tibial plateau fractures; however, surgical morbidity, especially soft-tissue infection and wound necrosis, has been reported frequently. For this reason, several investigators have proposed minimally invasive methods of fracture reduction followed by circular external fixation as an alternative approach. To our knowledge, there has been no direct comparison of the two operative approaches. METHODS: We performed a multicenter, prospective, randomized clinical trial in which standard open reduction and internal fixation with medial and lateral plates was compared with percutaneous and/or limited open fixation and application of a circular fixator for displaced bicondylar tibial plateau fractures (Schatzker types V and VI and Orthopaedic Trauma Association types C1, C2, and C3). Eighty-three fractures in eighty-two patients were randomized to operative treatment (forty-three fractures were randomized to circular external fixation and forty to open reduction and internal fixation). Follow-up consisted of obtaining a history, physical examination, and radiographs; completion of the Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS) knee score, the Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC), and the Short Form-36 (SF-36) General Health Survey; and recording of complication and reoperation rates. RESULTS: There were no significant differences between the groups in terms of demographic variables, mechanism of injury, or fracture severity and/or displacement. However, patients in the circular fixator group had less intraoperative blood loss than those in the open reduction and internal fixation group (213 mL and 544 mL, respectively; p = 0.006) and spent less time in the hospital (9.9 days and 23.4 days, respectively; p = 0.024). The quality of osseous reduction was similar in the groups. There was a trend for patients in the circular fixator group to have superior early outcome in terms of HSS scores at six months (p = 0.064) and the ability to return to preinjury activities at six months (p = 0.031) and twelve months (p = 0.024). These outcomes were not significantly different at two years. There was no difference in total arc of knee motion, and the WOMAC scores at two years after the injury were not significantly different between the groups with regard to the pain (p = 0.923), stiffness (p = 0.604), or function (p = 0.827) categories. The SF-36 scores at two years after the injury were significantly decreased compared with the controls for both groups (p = 0.001 for the circular fixator group and p = 0.014 for the open reduction and internal fixation group), although there was less impairment in the circular fixator group in the bodily pain category (a score of 40) compared with the open reduction and internal fixation group (a score of 35) (p = 0.041). Seven (18%) of the forty patients in the open reduction and internal fixation group had a deep infection. The number of unplanned repeat surgical interventions, and their severity, was greater in the open reduction and internal fixation group (thirty-seven procedures) compared with the circular fixator group (sixteen procedures) (p = 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Both techniques provide a satisfactory quality of fracture reduction. Because percutaneous reduction and application of a circular fixator results in a shorter hospital stay, a marginally faster return of function, and similar clinical outcomes and because the number and severity of complications is much higher with open reduction and internal fixation, we believe that circular external fixation is an attractive option for these difficult-to-treat fractures. Regardless of treatment method, patients with this injury have substantial residual limb-specific and general health deficits at two years of follow-up.


Related Articles

  • Thoracolumbar Burst Fractures Treated with Posterior Decompression and Pedicle Screw Instrumentation Supplemented with Balloon-Assisted Vertebroplasty and Calcium Phosphate Reconstruction. Marco, Rex A. W.; Kushwaha, Vivek P. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Jan2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 1, p20 

    Background: The treatment of unstable thoracolumbar burst fractures with short-segment posterior spinal instrumentation without anterior column reconstruction is associated with a high rate of screw breakage and progressive loss of reduction. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the...

  • Fractures of the Capitellum and Trochlea. Guitton, Thierry G.; Doornberg, Job N.; Raaymakers, Ernst L. F. B.; Ring, David; Kloen, Peter // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Feb2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 2, p390 

    Background: Recent work has established that apparently isolated fractures of the capitellum are often more complex and involve the lateral epicondyle, trochlea, and posterior aspect of the distal part of the humerus. We assessed the experience with operative stabilization of fractures of the...

  • Effect of an Unrepaired Fracture of the Ulnar Styloid Base on Outcome After Plate-and-Screw Fixation of a Distal Radial Fracture. Souer, J. Sebastiaan; Ring, David; Matschke, Stefan; Audige, Laurent; Marent-Huber, Marta; Jupiter, Jesse B. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Apr2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 4, p830 

    Background: The impact of an unrepaired fracture of the ulnar styloid base on recovery after internal fixation of a fracture of the distal part of the radius is uncertain. We evaluated a series of patients with an internally fixed fracture of the distal part of the radius to test the hypothesis...

  • Subtalar Fusion After Displaced Intra-Articular Calcaneal Fractures: Does Initial Operative Treatment Matter? Radnay, Craig S.; Clare, Michael P.; Sanders, Roy W. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Mar2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 3, p541 

    Background: Many patients with displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures require subtalar arthrodesis for the treatment of posttraumatic arthritis. We hypothesized that patients who underwent initial operative treatment would have better functional outcomes as compared with those who...

  • A Nonlocking End Screw Can Decrease Fracture Risk Caused by Locked Plating in the Osteoporotic Diaphysis. Bottlang, Michael; Doornink, Josef; Byrd, Gregory D.; Fitzpatrick, Daniel C.; Madey, Steven M. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Mar2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 3, p620 

    Background: Locking plates transmit load through fixed-angle locking screws instead of relying on plate-to-bone compression. Therefore, locking screws may induce higher stress at the screw-bone interface than that seen with conventional nonlocked plating. This study investigated whether locked...

  • Acetabular Revision with Impacted Morselized Cancellous Bone Graft and a Cemented Cup in Patients with Rheumatoid Arthritis. Schreurs, B. Willem; Luttjeboer, Jaap; Thien, Truike M.; de Waal Malefijt, Maarten C.; Buma, Pieter; Veth, René P. H.; Slooff, Tom J. J. H. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Mar2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 3, p646 

    We previously reported our results at a minimum of three years after thirty-five revisions of total hip arthroplasty acetabular components in twenty-eight patients with rheumatoid arthritis. The revisions were performed with use of impacted morselized bone graft and a cemented cup. This update...

  • Combined Intra-Articular and Varus Opening Wedge Osteotomy for Lateral Depression and Valgus Malunion of the Proximal Part of the Tibia. Kerkhoffs, Gino M. M. J.; Rademakers, Maarten V.; Altena, Mark; Marti, René K. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Mar2009 Supplement, Vol. 91-A, p101 

    BACKGROUND: Reconstructive surgical measures for treatment of posttraumatic deformities of the lateral tibial plateau are seldom reported on in the literature. We report the long-term follow-up results of a consecutive series of reconstructive osteotomies performed to treat depression and valgus...

  • Complication Rates Following Open Reduction and Internal Fixation of Ankle Fractures. SooHoo, Nelson F.; Krenek, Lucie; Eagan, Michael J.; Gurbani, Barkha; Ko, Clifford Y.; Zingmond, David S. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;May2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 5, p1042 

    Background: Ankle fractures are among the most common injuries treated by orthopaedic surgeons. The purpose of the present investigation was to examine the risks of complications after open reduction and internal fixation of ankle fractures in a large population-based study. Methods: With use of...

  • Cost-Effectiveness of Antibiotic-Impregnated Bone Cement Used in Primary Total Hip Arthroplasty. Cummins, Justin S.; Tomek, Ivan M.; Kantor, Stephen R.; Furnes, Ove; Engesæter, Lars Birger; Finlayson, Samuel R. G. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Mar2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 3, p634 

    Background: Antibiotic-impregnated bone cement is infrequently used in the United States for primary total hip arthroplasty because of concerns about cost, performance, and the possible development of antibiotic resistance and because it has been approved only for use in revision arthroplasty...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics