Comparison of Irrigation Solutions and Devices in a Contaminated Musculoskeletal Wound Survival Model

Owens, Brett D.; White, Daniel W.; Wenke, Joseph C.
January 2009
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Jan2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 1, p92
Academic Journal
Background: There is much to learn about the effectiveness of different methods currently used for the irrigation of open wounds. The purpose of this study was to compare various approaches in a survival animal model. Methods: We used an established goat model involving the creation of a reproducible complex musculoskeletal wound followed by inoculation with Pseudomonas aeruginosa (lux) bacteria. This genetically altered luminescent bacterium provides the ability for quantitative analysis with a photon-counting camera system. For Study 1, wound irrigation was performed six hours after the injury and inoculation; the goats were assigned to four treatment groups: normal saline solution, bacitracin solution, castile soap, and benzalkonium chloride. All wounds received sharp débridement and irrigation with use of a pulsatile lavage device (19 psi). Images and photon counts were obtained prior to irrigation, after irrigation, and forty-eight hours after injury and inoculation. For Study 2, we used the same animal model and compared bulb syringe and pulsatile lavage irrigation with saline solution. Results: In Study 1, the irrigation treatment lowered the bacterial counts in all treatment groups. The greatest reduction was seen with castile soap, which lowered the photon count to 13% of the pretreatment level. This was followed by benzalkonium chloride, bacitracin, and saline solution at 18%, 22%, and 29%, respectively. At forty-eight hours, imaging showed a rebound in bacterial counts in every group. The highest rebound was measured in the castile soap group, which rebounded to 120% of the pretreatment level. The benzalkonium chloride group experienced a rebound to 94% of the pretreatment level. These were followed by bacitracin solution (89%) and normal saline solution (68%). In Study 2, both treatment methods were effective in removing 75% of the bacteria initially. At forty-eight hours, the bacterial levels in the pulsed lavage group rebounded to 94% of the original levels (compared with 48% in the bulb syringe group). The difference in the mean photon count ratios at forty-eight hours was significant (p = 0.048). Conclusions: Approaches used to remove bacteria from wounds, such as irrigants other than saline solution or high- pressure devices, may not have the best clinical outcome. Clinical Relevance: These data suggest that use of a low-pressure device and saline solution to irrigate wounds is the best choice.


Related Articles

  • The use of MelMax® in the healing of chronic wounds. Jones, Menna Lloyd // British Journal of Nursing;6/11/2009, Vol. 18 Issue 11, pS30 

    Chronic wounds can have detrimental consequences for the quality of life of patients as well as presenting a huge financial burden to the NHS. An imbalance in the level of matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) and the tissue inhibitors of MMPs (TIMPs) in chronic wounds impedes the healing process. In...

  • Does moist wound healing influence the rate of infection? Slater, Maggie // British Journal of Nursing;11/13/2008, Vol. 17 Issue 20, pS4 

    Background: Wound infections account for 9% of all healthcare-associated infection. Traditional wound dressings have been shown to give limited protection against microbes in comparison with modern dressings, yet they remain the main dressings of choice. While modern dressings facilitate a moist...

  • Evaluating Cutimed® Sorbact®: using a case study approach. Powell, Gail // British Journal of Nursing;8/13/2009, Vol. 18 Issue 15, pS30 

    This article uses a case study approach to demonstrate good clinical outcomes using a bacterial binding dressing range on a variety of difficult wounds. A case study approach can demonstrate a clinician's perspective on the practicalities of dressing choice in practice. All wounds, whether acute...

  • Surgical Treatment of Early Wound Complications Following Primary Total Knee Arthroplasty. Galat, Daniel D.; McGovern, Scott C.; Larson, Dirk R.; Harrington, Jeffrey R.; Hanssen, Arlen D.; Clarke, Henry D. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Jan2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 1, p48 

    Background: Wound-healing problems are a known complication after primary total knee arthroplasty. However, little is known about the clinical outcomes for patients who require surgical treatment of these early wound-healing problems. The purpose of the present study was to determine the...

  • Four layer bandage compared with short stretch bandage for venous leg ulcers: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials with data from individual patients. O'Maera, Susan; Tierney, Jayne; Cullum, Nicky; Bland, J. Martin; Franks, Peter J.; Mole, Trevor; Scriven, Mark // BMJ: British Medical Journal (Overseas & Retired Doctors Edition;5/2/2009, Vol. 338 Issue 7702, p1054 

    Objective To compare the effectiveness of two types of compression treatment (four layer bandage and short stretch bandage) in people with venous leg ulceration. Design Systematic review and meta-analysis of patient level data. Data sources Electronic databases (the Cochrane Central Register of...

  • The use of Flivasorb® in highly exuding wounds. Tadej, Martin // British Journal of Nursing;8/13/2009, Vol. 18 Issue 15, pS38 

    Exudate can be an excellent indicator of what is happening within a wound and, therefore, provides valuable information during patient assessment. The volume, consistency, and particularly odour and colour, of any exudate will inform the practitioner about bacterial contamination, infection and...

  • Gentle foam dressings: interim results of an evaluation of the Allevyn range. Grothier, Lorraine // British Journal of Nursing;6/11/2009, Vol. 18 Issue 11, pS12 

    An understanding of how wounds heal is vital to any practitioner involved in wound management, and an understanding of how dressings function and perform while on a patient's wound is important in the decision-making process of dressing selection. This article outlines the interim results of an...

  • In-vitro test for comparing the efficacy of wound rinsing solutions. Kaehn, Kurt; Eberlein, Thomas // British Journal of Nursing;6/11/2009, Vol. 18 Issue 11, pS4 

    Wound coatings can severely delay chronic wound healing by inducing ischaemia and degradation of viable tissue and increasing susceptibility to infection. It is, therefore, essential to cleanse wounds gently and thoroughly to remove the detrimental coatings. In this study, an in-vitro model that...

  • Mepitel: a non-adherent wound dressing with Safetac technology. White, Richard; Morris, Clare // British Journal of Nursing;1/8/2009, Vol. 18 Issue 1, p58 

    Objective: Wound pain and tissue trauma are two main considerations of wound management, and appropriate dressing selection plays an important role in both. Traditional dressings may adhere to wounds resulting in significant pain and trauma to new tissue upon removal. The development of primary...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics