Coexistence of genetically modified (GM) and non-GM crops in the European Union. A review

Devos, Yann; Demont, Matty; Dillen, Koen; Reheul, Dirk; Kaiser, Matthias; Sanvido, Olivier
January 2009
Agronomy for Sustainable Development (EDP Sciences);Jan2009, Vol. 29 Issue 1, p11
Academic Journal
The adoption of genetically modified (GM) crops in the European Union (EU) raises questions on the feasibility of coexistence between GM and non-GM crops. Regulations to ensure that different cropping systems can develop side-by-side without excluding any agricultural option are currently implemented or developed by member states. The aim of this review is to explore whether nationally or regionally proposed coexistence strategies comply with the general principles established by the European Commission that ask for science-based and proportionate coexistence measures. In the first part, existing legal requirements and potential sources of adventitious mixing are reviewed. It is discussed what type of coexistence measures might be necessary to keep GM inputs below the legal tolerance threshold of 0.9%. Concentrating on cross-fertilisation as the major biological source of adventitious mixing in maize, it is then assessed to which extent available scientific data on cross-fertilisation can explain the diversity of currently proposed isolation distances by several member states. In the second part, it is analysed whether currently proposed isolation distances reflect contending policy objectives towards GM crops that largely exceed the economic scope of coexistence. It is investigated how coexistence is intersecting with a wider debate about the role of GM crops in agriculture. Based on the analysis of existing cross-fertilisation data, it is concluded that some of the currently proposed isolation distances are not in line with the coexistence principles laid down by the European Commission: they are (i) excessive from a scientific point of view; (ii) difficult to implement in practice; (iii) rarely proportional to the regional heterogeneity in the agricultural landscape; and (iv) not proportional to the farmers' basic economic incentives for coexistence. Hence, the range of proposed isolation distances cannot simply be explained by different interpretations of available scientific data, possible error intervals and remaining uncertainties inherent in the scientific process. It is argued that other than scientific issues must be at play. One might thus claim that coexistence has become an arena of contending values and visions on the future of agriculture and on the role GM crops might play therein.


Related Articles

  • THOUGHT FOR FOOD. Milmo, Sean // ICIS Chemical Business;2/5/2007, Vol. 2 Issue 52, p36 

    The article focuses on the challenge facing the European biotechnology sector over persuading European Union (EU) authorities to allow it to grow genetically modified organisms in crops. The rejection by EU environment ministers of a move made by the European Commission to order Austria to lift...

  • SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT OF ROMANIAN AGRICULTURE WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF EUROPEAN UNION'S REQUIREMENTS. RADULESCU, Carmen Valentina; IOAN, Ildiko // USV Annals of Economics & Public Administration;2015, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p57 

    The rich natural potential for agriculture in Romania is contrasting with the low level of economic performance. Progress toward sustainable development in rural areas depends on processes that lead to increased valuation of the natural resources by cropping and livestock breeding, capturing...

  • The WTO complaint-why now? Kinderlerer, Julian // Nature Biotechnology;Jul2003, Vol. 21 Issue 7, p735 

    Reports on the action taken by the U.S., Canada, Argentina and Egypt at the World Trade Organization regarding the inability to sell genetically modified (GM) foods and crops in the European Union. Need to recognize that science cannot provide all results needed to ensure environmental and...

  • NON-GM FEED DIFFICULT TO SOURCE.  // Irish Farmers Monthly;Apr2009, p13 

    The article reports that non genetically modified (GM) ingredients are difficult and costly to secure by European Union (EU) livestock feed manufacturers. It is said that the acreage of GM crops increased by 9% to top 125 million hectares. It sis aso stated that GM use has increased in Argentina...

  • "Frankenfood" Still on Europe's Plate. Williamson, Gabrielle // Environmental Forum;Nov/Dec2012, Vol. 29 Issue 6, p20 

    The article offers the author's insights on the use of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) in Europe. She states that based on a special Eurobarometer Survey on Biotechnology in 2012, only 23 percent of European Union (EU) residents think that GM food should be promoted. She notes that the...

  • Let's not cave in to the anti-GM lobby. Grant, James // Crops;8/02/2003, p6 

    Genetic modification (GM) technology is the exciting technology of this century, offering dramatic changes to the way people farm and produce food. At the recent GM Nation debates, anti-GM protestors dominated, arguing the same old points. Yet the U.S. has shown beyond any reasonable doubt that...

  • Australia could be one of the largest GM crop-producing nations in 2008.  // Art of Healing;Jun2008, Vol. 2 Issue 23, p7 

    The article reports that Australia could be one of the largest genetically-modified crop-producing countries in 2008. The European Union (EU) is already buying 38% of canola in Australia since 2006. Australia is now considering to introduce genetically-modified canola. However, with the...

  • How to model and simulate the effects of cropping systems on population dynamics and gene flow at the landscape level: example of oilseed rape volunteers and their role for co-existence of GM and non-GM crops. Colbach, Nathalie // Environmental Science & Pollution Research;May2009, Vol. 16 Issue 3, p348 

    The article offers information on how to model and simulate the effects of cropping systems on population dynamics and gene flow a the landscape level. It notes that the models aims to evaluate and propose innovative cropping systems adapted to particular agricultural concerns. It discusses the...

  • Ethics of Sustainable Development--a Study of Swedish Regulations for Genetically Modified Organisms. Karlsson, Mikael // Journal of Agricultural & Environmental Ethics;Jan2003, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p51 

    In spite of stricter provisions in the new European Union directive on deliberate release of genetically modified organisms (GMOs), critics still advocate a moratorium on permits for cultivation of GMOs. However, in an attempt to meet concerns raised by the public, the directive explicitly gives...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics