Impact of Spatial Reference Frames on Human Performance in Virtual Reality User Interfaces

Bernatchez, Marc; Robert, Jean-Marc
December 2008
Journal of Multimedia;Dec2008, Vol. 3 Issue 5, p19
Academic Journal
The design of virtual reality user interfaces (VRUI) is still an open field of research and development. One category of VRUI is the 3D floating menus that can be manipulated by users in free space. These menus can contain various controls such as buttons, sliders, and text. This article presents an experimental study that aims at testing the impact of five spatial reference frames on human performance with VRUI. Fifteen subjects participated in the study. Wearing a head-mounted display (HMD) and tracking hardware, they were asked to move a slider on a floating menu in a 3D virtual space. The menus were completely virtual such that no physical surface was providing haptic feedback to the user. Main results show that the reference frame has a determinant impact on task execution time, positional accuracy and user preference. We also found a link between the number of degrees of freedom shared between these reference frame and user performance. Results also show that user preference can greatly differ from experimental results obtained by measuring task completion times and positional accuracy.


Related Articles

  • An Efficient and Feasible Color-based Technique for Object Picking. Zhonglan Luo; Kai Lu; Xiaoping Wang // Applied Mechanics & Materials;2014, Issue 644-650, p3988 

    3D object picking, or 3D object selection, is a very important human-computer interaction technique. By touching the object in the 2D screen, users can change some properties of the corresponding object in the 3D virtual world. 3D object picking is widely studied and applied in the following...

  • Using a 3D Virtual Supermarket to Measure Food Purchase Behavior: A Validation Study. Waterlander, Wilma Elzeline; Jiang, Yannan; Steenhuis, Ingrid Hendrika Margaretha; Mhurchu, Cliona Ni // Journal of Medical Internet Research;Apr2015, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p1 

    Background: There is increasing recognition that supermarkets are an important environment for health-promoting interventions such as fiscal food policies or front-of-pack nutrition labeling. However, due to the complexities of undertaking such research in the real world, well-designed...

  • 3DUI-EF: Towards a Framework for Easy Empirical Evaluation of 3D User Interfaces and Interaction Techniques. Domingues, Christophe; Otmane, Samir; Mallem, Malik // International Journal of Virtual Reality;2010, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p73 

    Designing usable and effective 3D User Interfaces and 3D Interaction Techniques is very challenging for Virtual Reality system developers and human factors specialists. Indeed, time consuming empirical evaluation is necessary to have an idea about the goodness of the 3D User Interface (3DUI) and...

  • On studying a 3D user interface for OLAP. Lafon, S├ębastien; Bouali, Fatma; Guinot, Christiane; Venturini, Gilles // Data Mining & Knowledge Discovery;Jul2013, Vol. 27 Issue 1, p4 

    In this paper, a new visual and interactive user interface for OLAP is presented, and its strengths and weaknesses examined. A survey on 3D interfaces for OLAP is detailed, which shows that only one interface that uses Virtual Reality has been proposed. Then we present our approach: it consists...

  • EYE TRACKING APPLICATIONS. Barbuceanu, F.; Antonya, C. // Bulletin of the Transilvania University of Brasov, Series I: Eng;2009, Vol. 2 Issue 51, p17 

    As computer applications keep growing in complexity, human-computer interaction must keep the pace accordingly. Being the most important human sense, eye sight is considered a powerful new solution for enhancing communication with computers. Recent progress in eye tracking research outlines...

  • TOP 5 PRODUCTS 2003 Visualization.  // Scientific Computing & Instrumentation;Dec2003, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p28 

    This article evaluates various computer software used in visualization applications. PV-WAVE is a family of development solutions that allows users to rapidly import, manipulate, analyze and visualize their data. Tecplot 10 is a technical plotting software with extensive XY 2- and 3-D...

  • Interchanging Interactive 3D Graphics for Astronomy. C. J. Fluke; D. G. Barnes; N. T. Jones // Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia;2009, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p37 

    We demonstrate how interactive, three-dimensional (3D) scientific visualizations can be efficiently interchanged between a variety of mediums. Through the use of an appropriate interchange format, and a unified interaction interface, we minimize the effort to produce visualizations appropriate...

  • On the design of a Dual-Mode User Interface for accessing 3D content on the World Wide Web. Sadoski, Mark // Information Design Journal (IDJ);2013, Vol. 20 Issue 2, p181 

    A review of the article "On the design of a Dual-Mode User Interface for accessing 3D content on the World Wide Web," by J. Jankowski and S. Decker, which appeared in the 2013 issue of the periodical "International Journal of Human-Computer Science," is presented.

  • The Abyss Observatory Designing for Remote Collaboration, Self-directed Discovery and Intuition Development in Multi-User Interactive 3D Virtual Environments. Hajime Nishimura; Lim, Kenneth Y. T.; Koji Koyamada // Journal of Virtual Worlds Research;Sep2012, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p1 

    The Abyss Observatory is a museum of Earth Systems Science, Marine Life and Undersea Technology created in Second Life, currently supported by JAMSTEC as a test bed for remote collaboration and 3D visualization to create new scientific value. First, Second Life is a remarkable platform for...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics