To Get Hold of the Wrong End of the Stick: Reasons for Poor Idiom Understanding in Children With Reading Comprehension Difficulties

Cain, Kate; Towse, Andrea S.
December 2008
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Dec2008, Vol. 51 Issue 6, p1538
Academic Journal
Purpose: The aim was to identify the source of idiom understanding difficulties in children with specific reading comprehension failure. Method: Two groups (ns = 15) of 9- to 10-year-olds participated. One group had age-appropriate word reading and reading comprehension; the other group had age-appropriate word reading but poor reading comprehension. Each child completed an independent assessment of semantic analysis skills and 2 multiple-choice assessments of idiom comprehension. In 1 assessment, idiomatic phrases were embedded in supportive story contexts; in the other assessment, they were presented out of context. Performance on transparent idioms (which are amenable to interpretation by semantic analysis) and opaque idioms (which can only be interpreted by inference from context if the meaning is not known) was compared. Results: The groups demonstrated comparable semantic analysis skills and understanding of transparent idioms. Children with poor comprehension were impaired in the use of supportive context to aid their understanding of the opaque idioms. Conclusions: The study identifies poor inference from context as a source of the idiom understanding difficulties in children with poor reading comprehension; there was no evidence that poor semantic analysis skills contributed to their difficulties. Children with poor comprehension should be supported in the use of context to understand unfamiliar figurative language.


Related Articles

  • Know the News.  // Weekly Reader News - Edition 3;9/23/2005, Vol. 75 Issue 3, p4 

    Presents a reading comprehension quiz for children.

  • Memorial representations as a product of feedback and text variants. Langer, Philip; Keenan, Verne // Psychological Reports;Jun96, Vol. 78 Issue 3, p803 

    Examines the effects of feedback on several memorial representations of a text. Assessment of recall and inferential reasoning protocols; Significant interaction between text version and inferential trial; Interaction between version, type of feedback, and sequence; Analysis of results within...

  • Çıkarımda bulunma becerisi ve çıkarımların okumaanlama sürecindeki iÅŸlevi. Özenici, Salih; Kınsız, Mustafa; Seçkin, Hümset // International Journal of Human Sciences;Jan-Jun2011, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p1665 

    The aim of this study is to explain the relation of reading comprehension and inference. The main target of reading process is to create a coherent mental representation of the text, therefore it is necessary to recognize relations between different parts of the texts and to relate them to one...

  • On-line evidence for elaborative logical inferences in text. Lea, R. Brooke // Journal of Experimental Psychology. Learning, Memory & Cognition;Nov95, Vol. 21 Issue 6, p1469 

    Presents on-line evidence for elaborative logical inferences in text comprehension. Propositional-logic inferences in text; Readers' reaction time to the lexical-decision probes from inference stories and their no-inference counterparts; Construction-integration model proposed by W. Kintsch.

  • Think-Alouds. Wilhelm, Jeffrey D. // Instructor;Nov/Dec2001, Vol. 111 Issue 4, p26 

    Discusses think-alouds strategies for boosting reading comprehension in children. How teachers can incorporate the strategy with students; Tips on developing inferencing skills to students.

  • Detective Questions. Jiménez-Fernández, Gracia // Intervention in School & Clinic;Sep2015, Vol. 51 Issue 1, p45 

    One of the most frequent problems in reading comprehension is the difficulty in making inferences from the text, especially for students with mild disabilities (i.e., children with learning disabilities or with high-functioning autism). It is essential, therefore, that educators include the...

  • Edition 4 Reading Skills Practice Test.  // Scholastic News -- Senior Edition;03/27/2000, Vol. 68 Issue 21, p4A 

    Presents a reading comprehension test exercise for children.

  • Reading in the content areas: Unlocking the secrets and making them work. Dunn, Jacqueline E. // Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy;Oct2000, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p168 

    Presents an article on helping students understand and remember the information presented in their textbooks. Comprehension and information processing among students in reading textbooks; Development of a method called the check and line where students monitor their comprehension line by line.

  • Visualize the story to help students comprehend. Robb, Laura // Instructor-Primary;Mar1997, Vol. 106 Issue 6, p46 

    Recommends activities for teaching students how to comprehend a story through visualization. Drawing and description of elements from nonfiction materials; Illustration of elements from familia books.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics