Comparison of Closed Reduction Alone versus Primary Open Repair of Acute Nasoseptal Fractures

DeFatta, Robert J.; Ducic, Yadranko; Adelson, Robert T.; Sabatini, Peter R.
August 2008
Journal of Otolaryngology -- Head & Neck Surgery;Aug2008, Vol. 37 Issue 4, p502
Academic Journal
Objective: Nasoseptal injuries have traditionally been treated via closed reduction. Historically, the high incidence of postreduction deformities has led some surgeons to consider alternative approaches to obtain superior results. Here we compare simple closed reduction versus primary open repair of the nasoseptal fracture. Study Design: This was a prospective study of 40 consecutive patients treated with simple closed reduction of their combined nasal bone and septal fracture versus 40 patients treated with closed reduction of their nasal bone fracture and open treatment of the septum. Group outcomes were then compared. Results: In the closed reduction group, 60% had significant postoperative septal deviation, whereas only 12.5% suffered from residual septal deformity in the open group. This resulted in a statistically significant reduction (p < .01) of patients requiring a second operation to formally address the septum. Conclusion: By addressing the septum through an open approach, a statistically significant reduction in the number of patients requiring revision rhinoplasty was achieved.


Related Articles

  • Nasal Bone Fracture: Timely Intervention a Need. K. N., Manjunath; S., Shanthakumar // International Journal of Neurology & Neurosurgery;Jul-Dec2012, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p63 

    Nose is a central projection in the face with fragile skeleton. A trivial trauma can result in a significant deformity. Although majority suffer a bony injury, overlying swelling masks the deformity. If such deformity is not identified and intervened, it can lead to soft tissue changes as well...

  • Single-stage reconstruction of alar defect of the nose by subcutaneous island nasolabial and remnant alar flap. Gupta, Devendra // European Journal of Plastic Surgery;Oct2014, Vol. 37 Issue 10, p555 

    A single-stage technique for reconstruction of the medial nasal ala with a nasolabial flap and an inferiorly based remnant alar flap is presented in this article. The technique has been used in four cases. All the flaps healed uneventfully with aesthetically pleasing results using the one-stage...

  • A nose for trouble. GERACI, RON // Men's Health;Dec98, Vol. 13 Issue 10, p60 

    Provides some tips on how to handle nose injuries. Controlling nose bleeds; Test for a fracture; Breathing pattern evaluations.

  • The use of degloving approach in the treatment of nasal-orbital-ethmoid fracture. Peng Guo-guang; Wang Ke; Ding Xu-xuan; Wu Jun-wei; Yan Xin; Xie Jian-ya // Shanghai Journal of Stomatology;Apr2012, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p215 

    PURPOSE: To explore the method and effect of degloving approach in the treatment of nasal-orbital-ethmoid (NOE) complex fracture surgery. METHODS: Eleven eases of unilateral nasal-orbital-ethmoid fracture (NOE) were selected from Medical Center of Stomatology, Foshan Hospital of Traditional...

  • Clinical Study of Graft Selection in Malaysian Rhinoplasty Patients. Singh Gendeh, Balwant // ISRN Otolaryngology;2013, p1 

    Graft selection remains the greatest challenge for surgeons performing rhinoplasty. The preferred choice thus far for nasal reconstruction would be autograft compared to allograft due to its lower rate of infection and extrusion as it does not induce an immune response. We have evaluated 26...

  • Namaste (counterbalancing) technique: Overcoming warping in costal cartilage. Agrawal, Kapil S.; Bachhav, Manoj; Shrotriya, Raghav // Indian Journal of Plastic Surgery;May-Aug2015, Vol. 48 Issue 2, p123 

    Background: Indian noses are broader and lack projection as compared to other populations, hence very often need augmentation, that too by large volume. Costal cartilage remains the material of choice in large volume augmentations and repair of complex primary and secondary nasal deformities....

  • Reconstruction of nose in leprosy. Husain, S. // Indian Journal of Plastic Surgery;July-Dec2007, Vol. 40 Issue 2, p230 

    The article discusses the causes and the reconstruction of nasal deformity caused by leprosy. It relates that a collapsed nose is a deformity of lepromatous leprosy, which occurs due to the direct infiltration of bacteria into the mucous membrane, followed by cellular infiltration, edema and...

  • Traumatic Nasal Bone Graft Fracture. Enoz, Murat; Payasli, Goksun; Yazgin, Ilker; Cevli, Salih Cenap // Internet Journal of Otorhinolaryngology;2007, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p11 

    In cases of facial trauma, nasal fractures account for approximately 40 percent of bone injuries but traumatic nasal bone graft fracture is a very rare entity and treatment of this condition is complicated. A patient with nasal bone graft fracture due to trauma is presented and treatment...

  • Acute nasal injury. Razavi, A.; Farboud, A.; Skinner, R.; Saw, K. // BMJ: British Medical Journal;1/3/2015, Vol. 350 Issue 7989, pg6537 

    The article discusses research which examined the discontinuation and non-publication of surgical randomised controlled trials. Topics covered include the reasons behind the discontinuation of trials such as poor recruitment of patients, the association of industry funding with lower odds of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics