TITLE

The Illusion of Legitimacy: Two Assumptions that Corrupt Health Policy Deliberation

AUTHOR(S)

TROTTER, GRIFFIN

PUB. DATE

October 2008

SOURCE

Journal of Medicine & Philosophy;Oct2008, Vol. 33 Issue 5, p445

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

Public deliberation about health policy in the United States often hinges on two untenable basic assumptions about political legitimacy. The first assumption, common in public debate throughout the United States, is that federal oversight of health care is justified under a federal compact binding all citizens. This assumption is false because the federal compact precludes such oversight. Indeed, the ascendancy of national government (and demise of federalism) over the past 70 years was engineered through the subversion of the federal compact, creating an expansive legitimation gap. The second assumption--that political legitimacy can be established through appeals to expert consensus about fundamental conceptions of justice or human rights--is prevalent among bioethicists. I argue that this assumption is illicit because it hinges on a weak, rationalistic form of majoritarian democracy that conflates public acquiescence with public approval. If the public mission of academic bioethics involves protecting the integrity of public deliberation, then these two basic assumptions should be challenged.

ACCESSION #

35939178

Tags: MEDICAL policy;  MEDICAL care -- United States;  PUBLIC health -- United States;  FEDERAL government -- United States;  BIOETHICS

 

Related Articles

• Caring Relationships: An Investment in Health? Gorski, Peter A. // Public Health Reports;Mar-Jun2000, Vol. 115 Issue 2/3, p144 

  Argues that health providers and policy makers have neglected the effect of human relationships on health. Health condition of people in the United States (U.S.); Factors affecting people's health; Conditions required in a relationship-based approach to medical care.

• Lessons for (and From) America. Klein, Rudolf // American Journal of Public Health;Jan2003, Vol. 93 Issue 1, p61 

  Drawing lessons from international experience for health care reform in the United States requires striking a difficult balance between historical determinism and free will, between cynical pessimism and na�ve optimism. The key to this puzzle may lie in a paradox: the United States is the most...

• Policy Without Politics: The Limits of Social Engineering. Navarro, Vicente // American Journal of Public Health;Jan2003, Vol. 93 Issue 1, p64 

  The extent of coverage provided by a country's health services is directly related to the level of development of that country's democratic process (and its power relations). The United States is the only developed country whose government does not guarantee access to health care for its...

• Health Care Explained, Though Not Beautifully. Baily, Mary Ann // Hastings Center Report;Mar/Apr2004, Vol. 34 Issue 2, p43 

  Reviews the report "Insuring America's Health: Principles and Recommendations," from the Committee on the Consequences of Uninsurance, Board on Health Care Services, Institute of Medicine.

• High-Performance Health Care: How Do We Get There? Wakefield, Mary K. // Nursing Economic$;Sep/Oct2006, Vol. 24 Issue 5, p265 

  The article focuses on high-performance health care system in the United States. In July 2005, a commission was established by the Commonwealth Fund to define the characteristics of a high-performance health system. The main purpose of the high-performance health care system is to help everyone...

• Creating a Progressive Health Agenda. Robbins, Anthony // American Journal of Public Health;Aug84, Vol. 74 Issue 8, p775 

  The article presents a speech by Anthony Robbins, professional staff member of the Committee on Energy and Commerce at the U.S. House of Representatives, delivered at the Opening General Session of the 111th Annual Meeting of the American Public Health Association on November 14, 1983 in Dallas,...

• Continuing care network: Building a disability-based payment and delivery model. Temkin-Greener, Helena; Meiners, Mark R.; Fatula, James E. // Policy & Practice of Public Human Services;Sep99, Vol. 57 Issue 3, p38 

  Discusses the Continuing Care Network (CCN) program that will integrate primary, acute, and long-term care for senior Medicare beneficiaries in the United States. Services for impaired and dually eligible seniors; CCN demonstration in Monroe County, New York; Risk-adjusted payment model;...

• Health for All. Dean, Joshua // Government Executive;Aug2000 Special Annual Issue Top, Vol. 32 Issue 10, p33 

  Reports on the success of the 100 Percent Access, Zero Health Disparities Campaign of the United States Department of Health and Human Services' Bureau of Primary Health Care. Contributing factors to health status disparities; Bureau's involvement in performance partnerships; Bureau's creation...

• Time to Embrace Public health Approaches to National and Global Challenges. Walker, Deborah Klein // American Journal of Public Health;Nov2008, Vol. 98 Issue 11, p1934 

  The article presents the author's comments on the challenges facing public health programs in the U.S. on local, national and global levels. The author suggests that with a change in the country's administration the focus should be on developing a political will to improve the public health...

Read the Article