Coercive treatment and stigma: is there a link?

Gaebel, Wolfgang
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Coercive treatment comprises compulsory admission of patients as well as coercive treatment measures. Both are sometimes inevitable elements of psychiatric care, with the aim to prevent danger from patients and other persons. The stigma of mental illness is still one of the most challenging treatment obstacles. It is not limited to patients and their families, but is also attached to treatment methods and institutions. The link between coercive treatment and stigma of mental illness is complex. The fact that compulsory treatment is administered within the treatment of mentally ill persons, but not of patients with somatic illness, shapes the public's impression that mentally ill persons are different from others and potentially unpredictable and dangerous - with fear and social distance as consequences. These negative attitudes are also strengthened in sensational media reports on patients being involuntarily admitted to psychiatric institutions, which thereby also become associated with a negative image. It is not yet clear, whether and how mental health professionals' attitudes influence their practice of coercive treatment. In Germany, coercive treatment underlies strict legal regulations. Nevertheless, occasions and justifications for coercive treatment in clinical practice may vary due to individual tolerance limits and competence in deescalation techniques which in turn are influenced by beliefs, attitudes and professional experiences of the ward staff. In case of an interaction between stigma and coercive treatment, the question arises, whether the frequency of compulsory admissions and coercive treatment measures can be reduced by educational and stigma-oriented interventions. Empirical evidence will be discussed examining the link between coercive treatment and stigma, focused on public and professionals' attitudes and behavior as well as patients' perspectives.


Related Articles

  • Clayton's Detention: a risky practice? Saunders, Linda // Australian Nursing Journal;Nov2008, Vol. 16 Issue 5, p31 

    The article discusses Clayton's Detention arrangement for the care, treatment and custody of those with a mental illness and at a risk of harming themselves or others. It discusses the case of Sandra Sanders, a detained patient, in confinement or custody, who was able to leave Moodbury Hospital...

  • Mencap greets MP's bid to end detention.  // Community Care;2/21/2002, Issue 1410, p9 

    Reports on the introduction of a bill regarding the rights of the informally detained mentally ill patients under the Mental Health Act 1983 in Great Britain. Application of the bill; Ruling on the case of a man with severe learning difficulties who was informally detained in hospital by...

  • THE BOURNEWOOD GAP (AS AMENDED?). Allen, Neil // Medical Law Review;Winter2010, Vol. 18 Issue 1, p78 

    The author discusses efforts in closing the Bournewood gap, for the benefit of those who lack the capacity for consent to be treated and detained for mental illnesses. New provisions are to be introduced in the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA) which would also amend the Mental Health Act 1983...

  • Racial Disparities In Involuntary Outpatient Commitment: Are They Real? Swanson, Jeffrey; Swartz, Marvin; van Dorn, Richard A.; Monahan, John; McGuire, Thomas G.; Steadman, Henry J.; Robbins, Pamela Clark // Health Affairs;May/Jun2009, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p816 

    In this paper we explore racial disparities in outpatient civil commitment, using data from Kendra's Law in New York State. Overall, African Americans are more likely than whites to be involuntarily committed for outpatient psychiatric care in New York. However, candidates for outpatient...

  • Community Treatment Orders and 'Brian's Law'. Weitz, Don // Canadian Dimension;Sep/Oct2000, Vol. 34 Issue 5, p12 

    Criticizes the proposal in Canada which authorizes keeping psychiatrically-labeled people on chemical treatment. Confinement if they violate their psychiatric parole; Origin of Bill 68, 'Brian's Law,' amendments to the Mental Health Act and Health Care Consent Act; Misconception about killings...

  • Running the Asylum: A schizophrenic tries to save the mentally ill in a land gone mad. Wood, Graeme // Atlantic;May2011, Vol. 307 Issue 4, p27 

    This article reports on a mental health clinic in Peshawar, Pakistan founded by retired army major Gulzar Wazir. Difficulties encountered by the clinic are discussed, including stigmatization of mental illness, addiction of some patients to hashish and opium, and the scarcity of mental health...

  • Public Stigma against People with Mental Illness in the Gilgel Gibe Field Research Center (GGFRC) in Southwest Ethiopia. Girma, Eshetu; Tesfaye, Markos; Froeschl, Guenter; Möller-Leimkühler, Anne Maria; Müller, Norbert; Dehning, Sandra // PLoS ONE;Dec2013, Vol. 8 Issue 12, p1 

    Background: Public understanding about mental illnesses and attitudes towards people with mental illness (PWMI) play a paramount role in the prevention and treatment of mental illness and the rehabilitation of PWMI. The aim of this study was to measure public stigma against PWMI and the factors...

  • Civil Commitment--Involuntary Treatment--People v. Medina.  // American Journal of Law & Medicine;1985, Vol. 11 Issue 3, p393 

    Discusses the Supreme Court of Colorado's ruling that an involuntarily civilly committed mental patient deemed incompetent to make treatment decisions has a right to a hearing where the state must prove that such treatment is appropriate. Court's reliance on both common law and statutory law;...

  • Treat the 1 Percent. FULLER TORREY, E. // National Review;1/28/2013, Vol. 65 Issue 1, p26 

    The article looks at treatment for people with severe mental illness in the U.S., as of 2013. The author reports that a very small fraction of the severely mentally ill are responsible for a disproportionate number of violent crimes, saying this is due to their going untreated. He presents a...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics