The system of coercive (court mandated) medical measures in the Russian Federation

Dianov, Dmitry; Maltseva, Maya; Kotov, Vyacheslav
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Coercive treatment (CT) in Russia is a court mandated medical measure applied to persons who committed a punishable "socially dangerous act" (SDA) and who are suffering from a mental disorder if it is proved that their dangerousness is due to such disorder. The CT is applied to the irresponsible, to the person fallen ill after having committed the crime, and to the "partially responsible". There are four types of CT: 1) the outpatient CT is ordered to the patients who had committed the SDA in an acute psychotic state that has no tendency to be repeated or to the chronically ill patients after inpatient CT (the mean length of stay (LOS) in 2005 was 382.9 days). 2) The CT at a general (low security) psychiatric hospital is given to the patients suffering from a well curable acute disorder or relapse of chronic disorder. These patients are generally well adjusted to living in the community and their dangerousness is associated solely with their psychotic experiences; but their LOS is much longer (428.3 days) than that of the ordinary patients owing to the necessity to obtain a stable remission. 3) The dangerousness of the patients at a specialized (medium secure) hospital is caused by their deficient and personality disorders with antisocial orientations. The developing of socially acceptable stereotypes of conduct requires a long CT (603.4 lays). 4) The patients of a specialized hospital with intensive observation are united by their particular dangerousness associated with mental disorder (aggressiveness, persistent recidivism, severe violation of hospital regimen; the LOS here exceeds 1,226 days). The above mentioned measures function as a system owing to their right choice, the possibility of their successive substitution, and active preventive follow ups after completion of CT. The effectiveness of CT remains moderate: about 1/3 of the discharged patients commit repeated SDA, there is a slow accumulation of long stay patients (10 years or more) in all types of hospitals.


Related Articles

  • Symptoms, dangerousness and involuntary admission. Mulder, Cornelis L. // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Background The number of involuntary admissions in the Netherlands increased from 40 per 100,000 citizens in 1997 to 48 in 2005. During this period the mental health law did not change. In the Netherlands patients can be involuntarily admitted if they have a mental disorder causing dangerous...

  • Report refutes claims that Scotland's detention rates outstrip rest of UK. McMillan, Ian // Mental Health Practice;Dec2004, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p4 

    Reports that the study conducted by the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland have refuted the claims that people in Scotland are more likely to be detained under mental health legislation than people in England and Wales. Difference in the detention rate among Scotland, England and Wales;...

  • A systematic literature review on application and effects of forced admissions. van de Ven-Dijkman, Marieke V.; Schoevers, Robert; Sikkens, Erik // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Background The Dutch Association for Psychiatrists is working on a guideline when to decide to use involuntary measures. Therefore, it's necessary to research the (side) effects of forced admission. The main question in a literature research is: What's the effect of forced admission on the...

  • Crisis intervention and acute psychiatry in Amsterdam: 20 years of change? A historical comparison of consultations in 1983 and 2004 - 2005. Dekker, Jack; van der Post, Louk; Visch, Irene; Schoevers, Robert // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Background To establish a picture of the changes in emergency psychiatry that have contributed to the sharp increase in the number of acute compulsory admissions in the Netherlands since 1992. Treatment in Amsterdam psychiatric clinics is in danger of being dominated by coercive treatment. These...

  • Reform of the Mental Health Act 1983. An effective tribunal system. Wood, Sir John; Wood, J // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jan93, Vol. 162, p14 

    The article discusses areas of the British Mental Health Act's tribunal system that need reform, despite the effectiveness of the system as a permanent aspect of the detention of psychiatric patients. The Mental Health Act introduced compulsory admission for assessment that could be challenged...

  • Compulsory admission to hospital: an operational review of the Mental Health (Scotland) Act 1960. Elliott, William A.; Timbury, Gerald C.; Walker, Margaret M.; Elliott, W A; Timbury, G C; Walker, M M // British Journal of Psychiatry;Aug79, Vol. 135, p104 

    The working of the Mental Health (Scotland) Act 1960 is examined by analysis of compulsory admissions both nationally and to one Glasgow hospital. Comparisons are drwn with England and Wales. Despite a six-fold increase in admissions since 1945 the use of compulsory powers has remained almost...

  • Admission to a psychiatric unit and changes in tobacco smoking. Ker, Suzy; Owens, David // Clinical Practice & Epidemiology in Mental Health;2008, Vol. 4, Special section p1 

    Smoking and withdrawal from smoking complicates the assessment and treatment of mental illness. We aimed to establish whether psychiatric inpatients smoke different amounts after admission than beforehand and, if so, to find out why. Forty-three inpatients on a working age adult psychiatry ward...

  • Coerced psychiatric treatment in the community: perspective from England and Wales. Exworthy, Tim // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Background The UK Government has been pursuing a program to update the mental health law in England and Wales. The various proposals have met with sustained, widespread criticism. The intention now is to amend the statute in limited areas. This presentation will examine the clinical and legal...

  • From Rogers to Rivers: The Rights of the Mentally Ill to Refuse Medication. Clayton, Ellen Wright // American Journal of Law & Medicine;1987, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p7 

    Many individuals with mental illness wish to avoid psychotropic drugs, a type of treatment that may relieve their symptoms only at the risk of unpleasant, even permanent, side effects. In marked contrast to the widely-held view that most patients may refuse any treatment and that even patients...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics