Seclusion practice: a critical examination of the nurses' decision-making process

Holmes, Dave; Jacob, Jean Daniel
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Background Seclusion continues to be a widespread measure used in psychiatric settings. Furthermore, the humanitarian, ethical and legal issues associated with the use of seclusion make it one of the most controversial management strategies available. Despite these important issues, little nursing research has sought to gain an understanding of the nurses' decision-making process regarding the use of seclusion in psychiatric settings. Objective: The objective of this presentation is to outline the research results of a grounded theory study conducted in two major Canadian university affiliated psychiatric hospitals. Methods/results After conducting 27 semi-structured interviews with registered nurses, our qualitative analysis shows that the decision-making process involved in the use of seclusion is highly complex and relies on a combination of personal, professional, and organizational discourses and practices. Conclusion Several dimensions of the professional role must be considered in relation to seclusion; however, structural variables (examples: peer pressure, culture of blame) are most influential in the decision-making process involved in using seclusion. This is true even when those variables are in opposition to legal and ethical obligations of nurses.


Related Articles

  • A DAY IN THE LIFE OF AN ACUTE HOSPITAL PSYCHIATRIC NURSE. Murphy, Russell // Kai Tiaki Nursing New Zealand;Oct2005, Vol. 11 Issue 9, p24 

    This article describes the experience of an acute hospital psychiatric nurse in New Zealand. Challenges and tasks include: taking on an allocation of four to five patients, locating these patients for tests, receiving the doctor's account of the last 24 hours for each patient on the ward,...

  • Putting the person first. Lafferty, Sharon; Davidson, Robert // Mental Health Today;Mar2006, p31 

    Discusses the application of the tidal model for improving the provision of mental health nursing services at an adult acute admission ward in Glasgow, Scotland. Background on nursing practice developments in Great Britain, as of March 2006; Features of the tidal model; Impact of the...

  • Forget about being a caring professional.  // Mental Health Practice;Dec2007, Vol. 11 Issue 4, p5 

    The article reports that mental health nurses are encouraged to forsake the notion that they are in a caring profession, according to professor Phil Barker at the University of Dundee in Scotland. He discloses that nurses attending a recent workshop were being told that the sense of care in...

  • Impact of the physical environment of psychiatric wards on the use of seclusion. van der Schaaf, P. S.; Dusseldorp, E.; Keuning, F. M.; Janssen, W. A.; Noorthoorn, E. O. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Feb2013, Vol. 202 Issue 2, p142 

    Background: The physical environment is presumed to have an effect on aggression and also on the use of seclusion on psychiatric wards. Multicentre studies that include a broad variety of design features found on psychiatric wards and that control for patient, staff and general ward...

  • Psychiatric liaison nurses valuable.  // Australian Nursing Journal;Oct2005, Vol. 13 Issue 4, p45 

    Focuses on the significant role of psychiatric consultation liaison nurse (PCLN) in mental health care in Australia according to registered nurse Julie Sharrock. Benefits of the expansion of the role of PCLN to mental health care; Responsibilities of PCLN.

  • Nurse prescribing in mental health: a person-centred approach. Jones, Martin; Oddoye, Mayvis; Whitfield, Simon; Gray, Richard // Nursing Standard;9/3/2008, Vol. 22 Issue 52, p35 

    This article outlines how Surrey and Borders Partnership NHS Foundation Trust, a mental health and learning disability trust, implemented a preceptorship prescribing pathway for mental health nurses. The aim was to support nurses to move from supplementary prescribing to independent prescribing...

  • Praise for practice success.  // Nursing Standard;7/6/2005, Vol. 19 Issue 43, p10 

    Reports on the commendation of the "Running on Empty" to the work of psychiatric nurse Sarah Keen in addressing the physical health problems of patients with serious mental illness in Surrey,England. Job responsibilities as a psychiatric nurse; Success to practice nursing in mental health;...

  • Key recommendations.  // Nursing Standard;4/26/2006, Vol. 20 Issue 33, p8 

    This article presents the recommendations on Great Britain psychiatric nursing practice made by the report "From Values to Action" by Chris Beasley. Psychiatric nurses should maintain positive therapeutic relationships with mental patients, their families, and their caregivers. Training in risk...

  • How we prepared to prevent suicide. Hogarty, Susan S.; Rodaitis, Cecilia M. // RN;May88, Vol. 51 Issue 5, p21 

    Focuses on the training program at Shadyside Hospital in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania which deals with the role of nurses in the prevention of suicide. Identification of patients with high suicide potential; Need to ask the patient about his suicidal potential; Monitoring of the patient with...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics