How can variations in civil commitment rates within and between countries be understood?

Kjellin, Lars; Engberg, Marianne; Høyer, Georg; Kaltiala-Heino, Riittakerttu; Sigurjónsdóttir, Maria
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Background To compare civil commitment rates between different catchment areas in the Nordic countries and to explore how variations in civil commitment rates can be understood. Methods One psychiatric setting in Denmark, three in Finland, one in Iceland, four in Norway and three in Sweden participated in this part of the Nordic study on the use of coercion in the mental health care system. Data from medical records and related documents were registered for about 5,500 admissions of committed and voluntarily admitted patients in the years 1996-1999. A registration form specially designed for the study was used, including demographical and medical data and data on legal status for each admission. Information about the structure of the participating wards was collected separately. Results Nearly a tenfold difference was found between the catchment area with the highest and the area with the lowest civil commitment rate. Within countries, the greatest area variation was found between the three Swedish centers, with a threefold difference. The same magnitude of variation was found with regard to quotas of involuntary admissions, i.e. the proportion of civil commitments of all admissions. In preliminary analyses, no clear associations were found between civil commitment rates and demographic and clinical characteristics of the patients and organizational characteristics of the participating psychiatric wards. Conclusion Differences in legal prerequisites may be one factor explaining international variation in commitment rates, but predictors for variations within jurisdictions, with a uniform legislation, need to be further examined. The results of forthcoming analyses of the Nordic data will be presented.


Related Articles

  • A COMMENTARY: WHY CIVIL COMMITMENT LAWS DON'T WORK THE WAY THEY'RE SUPPOSED TO. Arben, Philip D. // Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare;Sep1999, Vol. 26 Issue 3, p61 

    It is often presumed that the legal rights of those who are mentally ill or alleged to be mentally ill are adequately protected by the changes in civil commitment statutes that most states instituted during the 1970s. The author who participated in the writing of these reform statutes recently...

  • Interpretations of legal criteria for involuntary psychiatric admission: a qualitative analysis. Feiring, Eli; Ugstad, Kristian N. // BMC Health Services Research;2014, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p228 

    Background The use of involuntary admission in psychiatry may be necessary to enable treatment and prevent harm, yet remains controversial. Mental health laws in high-income countries typically permit coercive treatment of persons with mental disorders to restore health or prevent future harm....

  • FATORES RELACIONADOS COM AS REINTERNAÇÕES DE PORTADORES DE ESQUIZOFRENIA. Sanches Pinheiro, Tânia de Lázari; de Oliveira Cazola, Luiza Helena; de Moura Sales, Cibele; de Andrade, Ana Rachel Oliveira // Cogitare Enfermagem;abr-jun2010, Vol. 15 Issue 2, p302 

    This descriptive study aimed to identify factors involved in readmissions of schizophrenic patients in a psychiatric hospital in a Brazilian capital. The research subjects were schizophrenic patients with a history of three or more admissions in the institution within one year. Secondary data...

  • Perceived coercion and its determinants at psychiatric admission -- are there sex specific patterns? Renberg, Ellinor Salander; Johansson, Britt-Marie; Kjellin, Lars // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Background To investigate determinants for perceived coercion during the admission process among voluntarily and involuntarily admitted psychiatric patients, with special focus on sex-specific patterns. Methods Patients (n = 282) were interviewed using the Nordic Admission Interview (NorAI),...

  • Comparison of involuntary hospitalization rates. Engberg, Marianne; Kaltiala-Heino, Riittakerttu; Høyer, Georg; Kjellin, Lars; Sigurjónsdóttir, Maria // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Background Civil commitment rates show substantial variation between different countries and over time. Legislation, professionals' ethics and attitudes, socio-demographic variation, and psychiatric services have been suggested as reasons for this. International variations in procedures and...

  • Patients' experiences of coercive treatment and coercive measures in psychiatric care. Wallsten, Tuula; Kjellin, Lars // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Background To study coercive treatment like forced medication and coercive measures like seclusion and mechanical restraint during inpatient psychiatric care among committed and voluntarily admitted patients and also to study patients attitudes to coercive treatment and measures. Methods A...

  • Urbanisation as a risk indicator for complex psychiatric disorders and forced admissions. Schoevers, Robert; Peen, Jaap; Dekker, Jack // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Background To determine both prevalence and complexity of psychiatric disorders in the Amsterdam area in relation to other major cities and less urbanized areas in the Netherlands, and to assess whether this is related to higher levels of (coercive) admissions. Methods These associations were...

  • Report refutes claims that Scotland's detention rates outstrip rest of UK. McMillan, Ian // Mental Health Practice;Dec2004, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p4 

    Reports that the study conducted by the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland have refuted the claims that people in Scotland are more likely to be detained under mental health legislation than people in England and Wales. Difference in the detention rate among Scotland, England and Wales;...

  • Opening Up and Closing Down: Notes on the End of an Asylum. Finnane, Mark // Health & History: Journal of the Australian & New Zealand Societ;2009, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p9 

    Deinstitutionalisation describes the process in which, throughout the western world, psychiatric hospitals discharged most of their patients and most often closed their doors. It coincided with an influential rethinking of the status of the mentally ill as citizens. At Wolston Park Hospital,...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics