The influence of a systematic risk assessment and a training course in aggression management on seclusion rates in Switzerland: a multi center study

Needham, Ian; Abderhalden, Christoph
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Background To explore the influence of a systematic risk assessment and a training course in aggression management on seclusion rates in Switzerland. Methods We conducted a multi-center partially randomized controlled trial on 24 acute psychiatric admission wards in the German speaking region of Switzerland. The wards were cluster randomized into 5 study arms (training course, systematic risk assessment, systematic risk assessment and training course combined, control group, preference wards utilizing only the systematic risk assessment). Aggressive incidents and coercive measures (seclusion, involuntary medication, and fixation) were recorded at pre and post intervention. Results We recorded 1,256 coercive measures in 81,255 treatment days of the trial. 1,134 coercive measures were administered in conjunction with aggressive behavior. In the preference arm the coercion rates fell from1.432 (95% CI 1.160 - 1.749) to 0.552 (95% CI 0.402 - 0.788) per 100 treatment days. A significant drop in coercion rates per 1000 treatment days were recorded on the wards having introduced the training course (pre test 23.81, 95% CI = 20.98 - 26.93 versus 17.699, 95% CI = 14.908 - 20.865 post test) and on the risk assessment preference wards test (15.811, 95% CI = 12.945 - 19.128 versus 6.265, 95% CI = 4.515 - 8.468). The main reasons for seclusion were the reduction of stimuli (498), treatment refusal (474), danger to others (460), and aggressive behavior (306). Conclusion A systematic risk assessment (preference arm) and a training course in aggression management are effective in reducing seclusion in psychiatric acute admission wards. The other two interventions (a systematic risk assessment alone and in combination with a training course) have no influence on seclusion rates. The preference arm wards faired well on the reduction of all coercive measures and seclusion. This finding may point to the possible role of motivation as a key factor in the reduction of coercion.


Related Articles

  • Structured risk assessment and violence in acute psychiatric wards: randomised controlled trial. Abderhalden, Christoph; Needham, Ian; Dassen, Theo; Halfens, Ruud; Haug, Hans-Joachim; Fischer, Joachim E. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jul2008, Vol. 193 Issue 1, p44 

    Background: There is a lack of research on the possible contribution of a structured risk assessment to the reduction of aggression in psychiatric in-patient care.Aims: To assess whether such risk assessments decrease the incidence of violence and coercion.Method:...

  • The use of seclusion and emergency medication in a hospital for people with learning disability. Rangecroft, M. E. H.; Tyrer, S. P.; Berney, T. P.; Rangecroft, M E // British Journal of Psychiatry;Mar97, Vol. 170, p273 

    Background: The management of disturbed behaviour in facilities for those with learning disabilities involves a spectrum of approaches including the prescription of emergency medication, restraint and seclusion. The use of these techniques has recently come under close...

  • Locking up patients with psychiatric illness. Wilkinson, Greg // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);2/19/1983, Vol. 286 Issue 6365, p581 

    Investigates the nature of secluding patients with psychiatric illness in Great Britain. Inadequacy of the guidelines set by the Department of Health and Social Security on the management of violent patients; Role of doctors in dealing with seclusion abuses; Need of hospitals to have strict...

  • CORRESPONDENCE. Jarvis, M.J.; Russell, M.A.H.; Hughes, J.A.; Hutchison, D.C.S.; Fountain, William; Shepherd, Mary P.; Townsend, E.R.; Moghissi, K.; Williams, J. Aled; MacDonald, Anne; Rees, Philip; Hart, William A.; Rawlins, M.D.; Tallett, E.R.; Jones, D.B.; Mann, J.I.; Mikhailidis, D.P.; Jeremy, J.Y. // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);3/19/1983, Vol. 286 Issue 6369, p976 

    Presents several letters on medicine in Great Britain. Smoking withdrawal of patients with smoking related diseases; Difficulty of treating oesophageal carcinoma by resection; Necessity for seclusion in the caring professions. INSET: Points.

  • Attitudes to seclusion in Virginia. Mann, Lee S.; Wise, Thomas N.; Mann, L S; Wise, T N // British Journal of Psychiatry;Aug89, Vol. 155, p263 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to an article about psychiatric patients' reaction toward seclusion in the April 1989 issue.

  • Statin Effects on Aggression: Results from the UCSD Statin Study, a Randomized Control Trial. Golomb, Beatrice A.; Dimsdale, Joel E.; Koslik, Hayley J.; Evans, Marcella A.; Lu, Xun; Rossi, Steven; Mills, Paul J.; White, Halbert L.; Criqui, Michael H. // PLoS ONE;7/1/2015, Vol. 10 Issue 7, p1 

    Background: Low/ered cholesterol is linked to aggression in some study designs. Cases/series have reported reproducible aggression increases on statins, but statins also bear mechanisms that could reduce aggression. Usual statin effects on aggression have not been characterized. Methods: 1016...

  • Participants' perceptions of motivation, randomisation and withdrawal in a randomised controlled trial of interventions for prevention of depression. Grant, J. Busby; Mackinnon, A. J.; Christensen, H.; Walker, J. // Journal of Medical Ethics;Dec2009, Vol. 35 Issue 12, p12 

    Aims and background: Little is known about how participants perceive prevention trials, particularly trials designed to prevent mental illness. This study examined participants' motives for participating in a trial and their views of randomisation and the ability to withdraw from a randomised...

  • SWOT Analysis of Contemporary Microfinance Impact Assessment Approaches. Khan, Zahoor; Bahari, Zakaria; Mahnaz Hassan, Syeda // Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences (PJSS);2014, Vol. 34 Issue 2, p485 

    Assessing the impact of microfinance programs is becoming popular among the microfinance practitioners and donors around the world. Appropriate assessment of microfinance programs enables major stakeholders to understand the current scenario and adapt better policy measures in the future. The...

  • Need for proactive approach to risk analysis in phase I trials. Van den Bogert, Cornelis A.; Cohen, Adam F. // BMJ: British Medical Journal;7/25/2015, Vol. 351 Issue 8018, ph3899 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "Quantifying the Risks of Non-Oncology Phase I Research in Healthy Volunteers: Meta-Analysis of Phase I Studies" by E. J. Emanuel, G. Bedarida, and K. Macci et al. in the June 26, 2015 issue.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics