Involuntary treatment of eating disorders: legal, scientific and ethical dimensions

Ragione, Laura Dalla; Pettinelli, Cristian; Scoppetta, Marta; Mencarelli, Sabrina
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Background The aim of this work is to evaluate whether patients affected by severe eating disorders (ED) should be submitted to coercive treatment or not. Methods Relevant international studies, identified by means of a medline-search, were examined, reviewed and integrated with our experience in Palazzo Francisci. APA guidelines and international legislation were consulted too. Results Among the DSM-IV-disorders, ED show the highest mortality rate after drug addictions. The mortality rate is even higher for anorexia nervosa because the frequent refusal of treatment delays diagnosis and treatment and influences prognosis. The American guidelines for ED treatment (2000) tackle the problem in two or three passages "Legal interventions, including involuntary hospitalization and legal guardianship, may be necessary to ensure the safety of treatment of reluctant patients whose general medical conditions are life-threatening"; "On these rare occasions staff have to take over the responsibilities for providing life-preserving care. Naso-gastric feedings are preferable to intravenous feedings...total parenteral feeding is required only very rarely and in life-threatening situations"; "In situations where involuntary forced feeding is considered, careful thought should be given to clinical circumstances, family opinion, and relevant legal and ethical dimensions of the patient's treatment". In Italian legislation, compulsory medical treatment is specified for mental illnesses but there are no specific indications. Phenomena such as anorexia nervosa do not have their own position in the legislation. Conclusion The bibliographic review showed that there are no agreed guidelines on the use of compulsory medical treatment. In our experience too, CBT-type interventions in patients without severe psychiatric co-morbidities appear to drastically reduce or even eliminate any recourse to such an extreme measure seen as aggressive, intrusive and linked to a lack of value of the patients.


Related Articles

  • Compulsory treatment in anorexia nervosa. Ramsay, Rosalind; Ward, Anne; Treasure, Janet; Russell, Gerald F. M. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Aug99, Vol. 175, p147 

    Background Anorexia nervosa is a mental disorder with a high long-term mortality. Patients are ambivalent about treatment and often avoid it. Of necessity, compulsory treatment sometimes must be considered. A report from the Mental Health Act Commission has helped to reduce previous confusion....

  • Możliwość czy przymus leczenia? Anoreksja psychiczna -- uregulowania prawne. Opis przypadku. Tylec, Aneta; Olajossy, Marcin; Dubas-Ślemp, Halina; Spychalska, Katarzyna // Psychiatria Polska;2013, Vol. 47 Issue 3, p531 

    Anorexia nervosa is diagnosed on the basis of well-defined diagnostic criteria and requires treatment, as it is associated with the highest mortality rate of all mental illnesses. In Poland, anorexia nervosa is not considered a mental illness, although the opinion of researchers and clinicians...

  • Treating anorexics without consent: some reservations. Draper, Heather; Draper, H // Journal of Medical Ethics;Feb98, Vol. 24 Issue 1, p5 

    Editorial. Discusses anorexia nervosa, with reference to the fact that in the United Kingdom (UK) it is classified as a mental disorder. Number of persons dying yearly of anorexia in the UK; Mandate issued by the Mental Health Commission in August, 1997 in relation to anorexics; Reference to...

  • BC's eating disorders program looks toward outpatient model. Kent, Heather // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;3/07/2000, Vol. 162 Issue 5, p684 

    Focuses on the changes in the Eating Disorders Program at Vancouver's St. Paul's Hospital in Canada. Increase in the number of anorexia nervosa patients; Inpatient therapy; Mortality statistics; Specifics of the program.

  • Anorexia nervosa. Schmidt, Ulrike // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jul2015, Vol. 207 Issue 1, p4 

    The article presents a brief description of anorexia nervosa, a mental disorder mainly affecting women.

  • Childhood sexual experiences with adults reported by women with eating disorders: an extended series. Palmer, R.L.; Oppenheimer, R.; Dignon, A.; Chaloner, D.A.; Howells, K. // British Journal of Psychiatry;May90, Vol. 156, p699 

    A total of 158 women presenting with clinical eating disorders have been investigated using a self-report questionnaire and subsequent interview concerning their recollections of sexual experiences with adults before the age of 16 and later adverse sexual experiences. About a third reported...

  • Compulsory treatment of the mentally ill.  // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);3/29/1986, Vol. 292 Issue 6524, p888 

    Focuses on the compulsory treatment of patients who are not detained in hospital as inpatients. Role of medical workers in the intervention of psychiatric cases; Implications of the attitude on the serious deprivation of liberty; Effect of compulsory treatment in temporary detention.

  • Attitudes Toward Compulsory Treatment for Anorexia Nervosa.  // Eating Disorders Review;Mar/Apr2009, Vol. 20 Issue 2, p5 

    The article reports on the result of the study which assesses the attitude of psychiatrists in treating patients with anorexia nervosa (AN). The study was participated by more than 1,300 psychiatrists were they completed a questionnaire concerning the implementation of compulsory treatment to AN...

  • The experience of caregiving for severe mental illness: a comparison between anorexia nervosa and psychosis. Treasure, J.; Murphy, T.; Szmukler, T.; Todd, G.; Gavan, K.; Joyce, J.; Szmukler, G // Social Psychiatry & Psychiatric Epidemiology;2001, Vol. 36 Issue 7, p343 

    Background: The aim of this study was to examine the experience of care giving for people with anorexia nervosa and to compare it with the experiences of those people who care for a person with a psychotic illness.Method: Carers (parents, siblings and husbands) of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics