Central ethical issues in coercive treatment of children and adolescents, with special reference to the reasoning of the staff members

Thorsén, Håkan
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Background The aim of the study was to describe the child and adolescent psychiatric staff opinions about ethical problems in relation to coercion, with specific focus on the ethical justification of different forms of coercion. Methods Two empirical studies were made. The first study used an ethical diary from sixty-seven staff members of different professions, including psychiatrists. The diaries were analyzed with focus on value and interest conflicts. The second study was an interview study with twenty staff members from different professions, where the interviews were analyzed with focus on ethical reflections of varying forms of coercion. Results The main result was that the staff found formal coercion easy to justify from an ethical perspective, whereas informal coercion often created uncertainty with regard to everyday care. Seclusion, body inspection and forced medication were found to be less ethical problematic than restraint by belt, which was found considerably more problematic and sometimes unnecessary as well. The values which the staff has to balance are autonomy and integrity vis a vis health, diminished suffering and personal development. The work with the parents could be of different kinds: cooperation, conflict or totally absent parents. In some cases, the parents were more viewed upon as co-patients. The most evident arguments for coercion were that coercion is justified when it is necessary to protect both the patient and others, when it is considered necessary for good treatment, and when the conditions under which treatment occurs need to be clarified. Conclusion The psychiatric ward staff often reflected about ethical issues, especially about how to handle the patient's autonomy and integrity in everyday care situations. They sometimes questioned formal coercive measures, but nobody questioned the possibility to use formal coercion in certain cases.


Related Articles

  • Seclusion and restraints: a neglected area of research in child and adolescent psychiatry? Schimmelmann, Benno // European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry;May2011, Vol. 20 Issue 5, p219 

    An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses various reports within the issue on topics including child and adolescent psychiatry and the effectiveness of melatonin for the sleeping problems treatment in autism.

  • Professionals’ Attitudes Toward Reducing Restraint: The Case of Seclusion in The Netherlands. Van Doeselaar, Marjan; Sleegers, Peter; Hutschemaekers, Giel // Psychiatric Quarterly;Jun2008, Vol. 79 Issue 2, p97 

    Despite public opinion and policy interventions, restraint remains a common practice. This is also the case in the Netherlands, where projects aimed to reduce seclusion, have not lead to a decreased use of restraint. Is this lack of effectiveness related to attitudes of the professionals? The...

  • Prevalence and correlates of seclusion and restraint use in children and adolescents: a systematic review. Hert, Marc; Dirix, Nele; Demunter, Hella; Correll, Christoph // European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry;May2011, Vol. 20 Issue 5, p221 

    Seclusion and restraint are frequent procedures to intervene in aggressive and potentially dangerous patients in psychiatric settings. However, little is known about their utilization and effectiveness in pediatric populations. We aimed to examine the prevalence and determinants of seclusion and...

  • ACTMHCN and the Seclusion and Restraint Review.  // ACTCOSS Update;2011, Issue 56, p9 

    The article discusses the establishment of the ACT Mental Health Consumer Network in the Australian Capital Territory (ACT). It notes that the aim of the group is provide support and services for mental health consumers. It also offers information on the Seclusion and Restraint Review Meeting of...

  • focus. Reducing reliance on seclusion in acute psychiatry. Hamilton, Bridget; Love, Anna // Australian Nursing Journal;Sep2010, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p43 

    The article focuses on plans to reduce the use of seclusion in mental health treatment. A local seclusion reduction plan at an acute unit at St. Vincent's Mental Health in Victoria and a statewide project demonstrated that changes in the use of seclusion could be achieved. A multifaceted...

  • Relating Callous-Unemotional Traits to Physically Restrictive Treatment Measures Among Child Psychiatric Inpatients. Stellwagen, Kurt; Kerig, Patricia // Journal of Child & Family Studies;Oct2010, Vol. 19 Issue 5, p588 

    We examined the association of callous-unemotional (C/U) traits with the rates of seclusion and restraint among a sample of child psychiatric inpatients ( N = 101). Analyses focused on the incremental value of C/U traits as a predictor over and above the influence of other risk factors for...

  • Managing aggression and violence using rapid tranquillisation. Dickinson, Tommy; Ramsdale, Susan; Speight, Geoff // Nursing Standard;10/21/2009, Vol. 24 Issue 7, p40 

    Aggression and violence sometimes occur in mental health settings, and nurses need to know how to de-escalate these situations. If de-escalation techniques are unsuccessful, the patient may need to be physically restrained or placed in seclusion. It may also be necessary to administer medication...

  • Talking About Psychiatric Medications: A Parent-to-Parent Perspective (For Children and Youth) Part I. Cooper, Susan; Rimm, Michael L.; Arensdorf, Alfred M. // Hawaii Medical Journal;Oct2007, Vol. 66 Issue 10, p260 

    This article presents a format for parent-to-parent and parent-to-professional guidance on psychiatric medications for children and youth. It reviews progress in Hawai'i's system of care for child mental health. Between 1999 and 2006, Hawai'i had nationally and internationally renowned experts...

  • Developing Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Workforce for Low- and Middle- Income Countries. Sharan, Pratap // Journal of Indian Association for Child & Adolescent Mental Heal;Jan2008, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p1 

    The author reflects on the need to develop child and adolescent psychiatry workforce for the low-and middle income (LAMI) countries. He reveals that LAMI are faced with problems concerning the insufficient number of practitioners specializing in mental health. The author mentions that these...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics