TITLE

Mental health courts -- a human rights perspective

AUTHOR(S)

Kerr, Grace

PUB. DATE

January 2007

SOURCE

BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

This presentation analyzes specialised mental health courts (MHCs), as one solution to the long-standing, growing challenge of dealing fairly and justly with persons with mental illness (PMIs) coming before the criminal justice system, from a human rights (HR) perspective. MHCs have garnered professional and political support in North America. Redefining their primary purpose from the determination of fault and the imposition of punishment to the provision of treatment and the enhancement of well-being, to date little consideration has been given to whether the costs of MHCs in terms of de-individualised justice are worth their benefits. As Harris points out, 'sometimes wise policies and practices can have unintended side effects'. And as Thomas Jefferson reminds us, 'the price of liberty is eternal vigilance'. Thus, addressing the HR implications of MHCs should rank highly on its advocates' agendas. Potential HR concerns, arising from MHCs and relating to PMIs essential dignity rights as well as their rights to non-degrading treatment, autonomy, privacy, due process and non-discrimination, will be assessed. Like other writers, the presenter urges that only through respecting PMIs' rights to services and fulfilling society's duty to provide same, and not through MHCs, will PMIs be afforded the full rights that democratic states ought to provide their citizens. The manner in which MDOs are managed (or not) by the multiple services and systems they typically encounter creates a broad measure of dissatisfaction that goes beyond any single jurisdiction or country. Moreover, the sufficient issue overlaps and fundamental commonalities in approaches to the problems faced by MDOs provide a general societal and judicial context for an analysis of MHCs and a related HR discussion, notwithstanding the presenter references the provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) (1950) for her HR analysis.

ACCESSION #

35704268

 

Related Articles

• Internal Perspectives on Chinese Human Rights Reform: The Death Penalty in the PRC. Monthy, Jeremy T. // Texas International Law Journal;Winter98, Vol. 33 Issue 1, p189 

  Discusses China's social or Confucian reliance on executions as public and moral forms of justice. Arbitrariness and politicization of the judicial process leading up to the execution; Examination of what is being said about the death penalty in the international arena; Ways in which the...

• THE MANIFESTO ON EUROPEAN CRIMINAL PROCEDURE LAW - FOUNDATION FOR CREATING A COMMON SPACE OF EUROPEAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE. PANAINTE, Rodica // Centre for European Studies (CES) Working Papers;2015 Supplement, Vol. 7 Issue 2a, p566 

  In this article, we propose to analyze the content of the Manifesto on European Criminal Procedure Law of 2013, and how this document can represent a foundation for the legal cooperation of the European states, and also for creating a unique, common space of European criminal justice. Elaborated...

• International Norms on Execution of the Insane and the Mentally Retarded. Schabas, William A. // Criminal Law Forum;1993, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p95 

  The article discusses the international norms on the execution of the insane. It is stated that international human rights law is considering the abolition of death penalty especially for certain categories of people such as juveniles, pregnant women, and the insane. However, no treaty provision...

• Where Human Rights Meet Administrative Law: Essential Elements and Limits to Delegation: European Court of Justice, Grand Chamber C-355/10: European Parliament v. Council of the European Union. den Heijer, Maarten; Tauschinsky, Eljalill // European Constitutional Law Review;Dec2013, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p513 

  Case C-355/10 deals with institutional questions and with the delicate issue of intercepting migrants at sea, and thus with fundamental rights. The European Parliament had sought the annulment of a decision of the Council, adopted under the regulatory procedure with scrutiny (PRAC), on the...

• Does Capital Punishment Amount to Cruel, Inhuman and Degrading Punishment: A Reflection on Botswana and South Africa. Swartz, Nico P. // Journal of Politics & Law;Dec2012, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p100 

  In a recent debate over the radio in Botswana on the death penalty, the majority of callers seemed to be in favour of the death penalty. The purpose of this paper is to clarify that capital punishment is cruel, inhuman and degrading contrary to the norms set out in the Convention against...

• THE EUROPEAN UNION AND TRANSITIONAL JUSTICE: HUMAN RIGHTS AND POST-CONFLICT RECONCILIATION IN EUROPE AND BEYOND. CROSSLEY-FROLICK, KATY A. // Contemporary Readings in Law & Social Justice;2011, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p33 

  Since the end of the Cold-War, the field of transitional justice has metamorphosed from an initially narrow focus on justice and retribution to a much more complex study of how human rights abuses, genocide and other mass atrocities are confronted by societies emerging from violent conflict...

• UNELE CONSIDERAÅ¢II IN LEGÄ‚TURA CU RESPECTAREA CARTEI DREPTURILOR FUNDAMENTALE A UNIUNII EUROPENE DE CÄ‚TRE INSTANÅ¢ELE NAÅ¢IONALE. SALOMIA, OANA-MIHAELA // Dreptul; 

  The author highlights the manner in which the observance of fundamental rights enshrined and guaranteed under the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union is ensured by the national constitutional rules and the main provisions of the Civil Code, the Code of Civil Procedure, the...

• The Impact of International Standards and Guidelines on Prisoner Health in Eastern and Central Europe. MacDonald, Morag // HEUNI Papers;2008, Vol. 28, p40 

  The article considers the impact of international standards and guidelines on prisoner health in Eastern and Central Europe and draws on some common themes from research carried out in various European prison systems both in adult and juvenile prisons in the new EU member states (MacDonald,...

• ECOMMUNITY LEGISLATIVE PROVISIONS AND THEIR IMPLEMENTATION REGARDING THE ACCESS TO JUSTICE WITH RESPECT TO CROSS-BORDER DISPUTES. Elise Nicoleta Vâlcu; Ionel Didea // International Conference : CKS - Challenges of the Knowledge Soc;Jan2010, p972 

  The access to justice is a general right recognised by the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms of 4th November 1950, reaffirmed by article 47, paragraph 3 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, which states that legal aid shall be made available to...

Read the Article