Psychiatry and the law: do the fields agree in their views on coercive treatment?

Arboleda-Florez, Julio
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Coercion is an element of some treatments in psychiatry and it is contemplated in legislation, which often dictates parameters for involuntary admissions and use of restrictive treatments. A trend in the past years has been to widen the parameters required for commitment, thus extending coercive elements of psychiatric treatments to less immediate situations and into the community as in assertive community treatment strategies and, most pointedly, as in community treatment orders. Elements of coercion could be applied in different ways that range from voluntary acceptance to seemingly adherence to outright refusal and force. How these elements compaginate with legal mandates and how are they justified in psychiatry and in law in a balance between needs for protection and individuality and autonomy will be concepts and strategies to be developed in this lecture. The ethics of coercion will be reviewed from a point of view of human and civil rights, both negative and positive rights of mental patients. In this respect, attention will be placed to the experience of coercion by patients, who is coerced and reasons for the use of this expedient strategy in psychiatry and law.


Related Articles

  • Community treatment orders: profile of a Canadian experience. O'Brien, Ann-Marie A.; Farrell, Susan J. // Canadian Journal of Psychiatry;Jan2005, Vol. 50 Issue 1, p27 

    Objective: This study reports the first published Canadian profile of a sample of psychiatric patients from the Royal Ottawa Hospital in Ottawa, Ontario, who were issued community treatment orders (CTOs).Method: We undertook a population study of sociodemographic and...

  • How to do Research in Community Mental Health Agencies. Anderson, Wayne // Personnel & Guidance Journal;Apr81, Vol. 59 Issue 8, p517 

    Offers suggestions for conducting research in community mental health agencies. Practitioners' attitude toward research; Initiation of a research program; Types of research.

  • An evaluation of the ten friends diner: A collaborative community project. Page, Stewart; Lafreniere, Kathryn; Out, Jennifer // Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal;Fall1999, Vol. 23 Issue 2, p171 

    Evaluative data, from interviews and two psychometric scales, were gathered from 16 consumer-survivors employed at the Ten Friends Diner, a community-based commercial enterprise in a large Canadian city. The scales were the Self-Efficacy scale (Scherer et al., 1982), and Social Contact scale...

  • Coercion and cooperation and psychiatry for the person. Mezzich, Juan E. // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Coercive treatment in its various forms represents a critical challenge for clinical care. This can be usefully discussed vis-á-vis the opportunities open by cooperation and engagement. The framework of Psychiatry for the Person, a major WPA initiative, can be helpful for such analyses. This...

  • Community Mental Health in the People's Republic of China: A Critical Analysis. Kam-Shing Yip // Community Mental Health Journal;Feb2006, Vol. 42 Issue 1, p41 

    Community mental health has long been the crucial modality in service delivery of mental health services. This paper is an attempt to evaluate community mental health services in the People's Republic of China. The writer critically argues that community mental health services in the People's...

  • Training in Community Psychiatry: New Opportunities. Cohen, Neal L.; McQuistion, Hunter; Albert, Gail; Edgar, John; Falk, Kathryn; Serby, Michael // Psychiatric Quarterly;Jun1998, Vol. 69 Issue 2, p107 

    The authors describe the impact on training that accompanied an assignment of senior (PGY-4) residents to work one-half day each week for a six month period at a community-based agency concerned with the care of persons with severe and persistent mental illness who were formerly homeless. As the...

  • Community Psychiatric Practice. Drake, Robert E. // Community Mental Health Journal;Feb2003, Vol. 39 Issue 1, p75 

    Introduces a section of the 'Community Mental Health Journal.' Use of this section to stimulate interaction and involve community psychiatrists and other community health professionals; Topics that will be discussed in the section; Invitation by the journal; Contact information.

  • Pretreatment Intervention Increases Treatment Outcomes for Patients with Anxiety Disorders. Buckner, Julia; Cromer, Kiara; Merrill, Katherine; Mallott, Michael; Schmidt, Norman; Lopez, Cristina; Holm-Denoma, Jill; Joiner, Thomas // Cognitive Therapy & Research;Feb2009, Vol. 33 Issue 1, p126 

    The current study evaluated the utility of a pretreatment intervention aimed at increasing treatment attendance. We extended past work by evaluating whether this intervention was associated with less impairment at termination. Given that patients with anxiety disorders demonstrate high rates of...

  • Suicide rate falls but goal missed.  // GP: General Practitioner;4/20/2007, p16 

    The article reports that the introduction of supervised community treatment program into the Mental Health Bill in Great Britain is considered to help in reducing suicide rates. The plan follows a report from the National Institute for Mental Health, which shows suicide rates of 8.5 per 100,000...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics