Psychiatry and the law: do the fields agree in their views on coercive treatment?

Arboleda-Florez, Julio
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Coercion is an element of some treatments in psychiatry and it is contemplated in legislation, which often dictates parameters for involuntary admissions and use of restrictive treatments. A trend in the past years has been to widen the parameters required for commitment, thus extending coercive elements of psychiatric treatments to less immediate situations and into the community as in assertive community treatment strategies and, most pointedly, as in community treatment orders. Elements of coercion could be applied in different ways that range from voluntary acceptance to seemingly adherence to outright refusal and force. How these elements compaginate with legal mandates and how are they justified in psychiatry and in law in a balance between needs for protection and individuality and autonomy will be concepts and strategies to be developed in this lecture. The ethics of coercion will be reviewed from a point of view of human and civil rights, both negative and positive rights of mental patients. In this respect, attention will be placed to the experience of coercion by patients, who is coerced and reasons for the use of this expedient strategy in psychiatry and law.


Related Articles

  • Sergey Sergeevich Korsakov (1854–1900). Vein, Alla // Journal of Neurology;Oct2009, Vol. 256 Issue 10, p1782 

    The article focuses on the life and works of Sergey Sergeevich Korsakov, first professor of psychiatry in Russia. It states that Korsakov, born in 1854 in a village in Russia, was a physician at the Moscow Preobrazhenskij mental hospital in Russia. It mentions that his thesis on alcoholic...

  • Taking the Role of the Family Seriously in Treating Chinese Psychiatric Patients: A Confucian Familist Review of China's First Mental Health Act. RUIPING FAN; MINGXU WANG // Journal of Medicine & Philosophy;Aug2015, Vol. 40 Issue 4, p387 

    This essay argues that the Chinese Mental Health Act of 2013 is overly individualistic and fails to give proper moral weight to the role of Chinese families in directing the process of decision-making for hospitalizing and treating the mentally ill patients. We present three types of reactions...

  • Community treatment orders: current evidence and the implications. Rugkåsa, Jorun; Dawson, John // British Journal of Psychiatry;Dec2013, Vol. 203 Issue 6, p406 

    Community treatment orders (CTOs) have been widely introduced to address the problems faced by 'revolving door' patients. A number of case-control studies have been conducted but show conflicting results concerning the effectiveness of CTOS. The Oxford Community Treatment Order Evaluation Trial...

  • Involuntary Civil Commitment: Communicating With the Court Regarding "Danger to Other". Evans, Stephanie A.; Salekin, Karen L. // Law & Human Behavior (American Psychological Association);Aug2014, Vol. 38 Issue 4, p325 

    Beginning in the 1990s, researchers in the field of violence risk assessment recognized that even the most accurate and valid assessment could not assist fact-finders if the information was communicated in an unclear, imprecise, and/or incomplete manner (Monahan & Steadman, 1996; Schopp, 1996)....

  • How to do Research in Community Mental Health Agencies. Anderson, Wayne // Personnel & Guidance Journal;Apr81, Vol. 59 Issue 8, p517 

    Offers suggestions for conducting research in community mental health agencies. Practitioners' attitude toward research; Initiation of a research program; Types of research.

  • An evaluation of the ten friends diner: A collaborative community project. Page, Stewart; Lafreniere, Kathryn; Out, Jennifer // Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal;Fall1999, Vol. 23 Issue 2, p171 

    Evaluative data, from interviews and two psychometric scales, were gathered from 16 consumer-survivors employed at the Ten Friends Diner, a community-based commercial enterprise in a large Canadian city. The scales were the Self-Efficacy scale (Scherer et al., 1982), and Social Contact scale...

  • Proposal for a risk management axis in psychiatric classifications. Mellsop, Graham // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Risk assessment and management are central issues in many compulsory treatment legislations. Comprehensive clinical assessment and patient management plans have been enhanced by the development of multiaxial classificatory systems. Assessment of risk is an essential clinical task for which the...

  • Coercion and cooperation and psychiatry for the person. Mezzich, Juan E. // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Coercive treatment in its various forms represents a critical challenge for clinical care. This can be usefully discussed vis-á-vis the opportunities open by cooperation and engagement. The framework of Psychiatry for the Person, a major WPA initiative, can be helpful for such analyses. This...

  • Joyce Brown's freedom. Evans, H. // U.S. News & World Report;5/23/88, Vol. 104 Issue 20, p78 

    Editorial. Comments on the hundreds of thousands of displaced mentally sick people on the streets after they were de- institutionalized since 1963's mental-health act. Discusses the case of Joyce Brown (New York City), a schizophrenic who went to court to be allowed to continue living on the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics