Use of seclusion and restraint, and its relationship to the patient's gender -- a retrospective multi-center study from three departments' of acute emergency psychiatry

Knutzen, Maria
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Background Previous studies show inconsistent findings about gender association with seclusion and restraint. A study from an acute emergency department showed that the number of women secluded and restrained were lower than for the men. But among repeatedly secluded and restrained patients the women were in the majority and they also had more episodes with seclusion and restraint. Methods In an ongoing multi-center study conducted in three acute emergency psychiatry institutions, we retrospectively examine data from seclusion and restraint protocols and data about all the patients admitted over a two-year period. We note how many patients have had episodes with seclusion and restraint. We also note duration/time/ date of each episode and the reason given for using seclusion and restraint and the relationship by gender. Each patient is only counted once in this period, controlling for readmission. Results Preliminary findings from one of the departments replicate findings in the study from the 1994 - 1999, that the total number of men secluded and restrained was higher than that of women, but among repeatedly secluded and restrained patients the women were in the majority. At the congress we will present results from all three departments. Conclusion Our data indicate that the use of seclusion and restraints varies by gender and show the need to study not only the rate of seclusion and restraint, but also the episodes of seclusion and restraint by gender.


Related Articles

  • A fifteen-year review of female admissions to Carstairs State Hospital. Brooks, Patrick W.; Mitchell, Geoffrey; Brooks, P W; Mitchell, G // British Journal of Psychiatry;Nov75, Vol. 127, p448 

    A survey was made of all female admissions to the State Hospital, Carstairs, between the time of the first female admission in 1959, and 31 December 1973. There were 66 female admissions, constituting 7-1 per cent of the total admissions over the same period. The females fall into two separate...

  • The development of a scale to measure staff attitude to coercion. Husum, Tonje Lossius; Ruud, Torleif // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Previous studies have shown that there is considerable variation in the degree to which coercion is used in mental health institutions. This variation between institutions and even between wards is seen in many countries. Many factors have been put foreword to explain this variation in the use...

  • Collaboration between a state alliance for the mentally ill and a state mental health authority in monitoring the consequences of downsizing. Evans, Carol J.; McGee, Chuck; Evans, C J; McGee, C // Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research;Feb98, Vol. 25 Issue 1, p43 

    As consumers are released from hospitalization as a result of the downsizing of inpatient psychiatric facilities, their ability to sustain themselves in the community becomes a concern to a number of constituencies. This article describes the development of a program for monitoring persons who...

  • PREPARING LONG-TERM INPATIENTS FOR COMMUNITY RE-ENTRY. Bellus, Stephen B.; Kost, Peter P.; Vergo, Joseph G. // Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal;Spring2000, Vol. 23 Issue 4, p359 

    Describes the strategies used to assist long-term inpatients in considering discharge from hospital and community reintegration in the United States. Notion on the closure of long-term psychiatric inpatient units; Identification of hospital dependency of inpatients as institutionalization;...

  • The Nithsdale Schizophrenia Survey. VI. Relatives' expressed emotion: prevalence, patterns, and clinical assessment. McCreadie, R. G.; Robinson, A. D. T.; Robinson, A D // British Journal of Psychiatry;May87, Vol. 150, p640 

    A review of all known schizophrenics (n = 142) in Nithsdale, Scotland, found 50% were living with relatives or friends. Of these, 32% had high contact with a relative showing high expressed emotion (EE); put another way, 87% of all Nithsdale schizophrenics were not living in a high contact/high...

  • DEPRESSION: OUR COMMON CURSE. Steinmann, Marion // Saturday Evening Post;Dec1975, Vol. 247 Issue 9, p54 

    Focuses on the depression illness. Events that trigger depression, including Christmas; Percentage of psychiatric hospitalizations that are accounted for depression in the U.S. in 1975; Symptoms of clinical depression, including loneliness.

  • Downsizing psychiatric hospitals: needs for care and services of current and discharged long-stay inpatients. Lesage, Alain D; Morissette, Raymond; Fortier, Linda; Reinharz, Daniel; Contandriopoulos, Andre-Pierre; Lesage, A D; Morissette, R; Fortier, L; Reinharz, D; Contandriopoulos, A P // Canadian Journal of Psychiatry;Aug2000, Vol. 45 Issue 6, p526 

    Background: With the psychiatric deinstitutionalization movement in its fourth decade, questions are being raised concerning its relevance for long-stay inpatients with severe disabilities and the risk that those discharged into the community may be abandoned.Methods: A...

  • Urbanisation as a risk indicator for complex psychiatric disorders and forced admissions. Schoevers, Robert; Peen, Jaap; Dekker, Jack // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Background To determine both prevalence and complexity of psychiatric disorders in the Amsterdam area in relation to other major cities and less urbanized areas in the Netherlands, and to assess whether this is related to higher levels of (coercive) admissions. Methods These associations were...

  • Changes in the positive and negative symptoms of schizophrenic in-patients in China. Phillips, Michael A.; Zuan Zhao; Xianzhang Xiong; Xiufang Cheng; Guirong Sun; Ningsheng Wu; Phillips, M R; Zhao, Z A; Xiong, X Z; Cheng, X F; Sun, G R; Wu, N S // British Journal of Psychiatry;Aug91, Vol. 159, p226 

    Positive and negative symptoms at admission and discharge of 401 unselected schizophrenic patients from four psychiatric hospitals around China were studied. On admission 58% of patients had prominent negative symptoms and the overall severity of negative symptoms was similar to that of positive...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics