A comparison in the quality of care among legally coerced and voluntary clients in outpatient substance abuse treatment programs

Perron, Brian
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Background Mandating treatment, or legal coercion, in the substance abuse treatment system is a common practice. There has been extensive debate on the ethical issues of this practice. However, very little is known whether the quality of care for persons who are legally coerced differs from persons who attend voluntarily. The purpose of this study is to examine differences in service quality. Methods This study used data from the National Treatment Improvement Evaluation Study (NTIES). The NTIES was a prospective study of the impact of treatment programs on persons in publicly funded substance abuse treatment program. Subjects for this study were from outpatient non-methadone and non-correctional settings (N = 1,439) from 31 different treatment programs. Objective quality of care was measured by the presence of a treatment plan, whether subjects were in agreement with the treatment goals, and the proportion of service needs that were matched. Subjective quality was measured using an indicator of overall treatment satisfaction. The primary analytic strategy was multilevel linear and logistic modeling. Results Approximately 41% of the subjects were legally coerced to attend substance abuse treatment. No differences were observed in the objective measures of quality of care. However, there were differences in subjective quality of care -- legally coerced persons were less likely to be satisfied with their overall treatment experience. Significant variability across treatment programs for all the quality indicators was observed. Conclusion The results revealed differences in the subjective but not objective quality of care among legally coerced and voluntary persons. Because legal coercion is commonly used, it is important to consider different treatment engagement strategies based on legal status. Additional research is also needed in order to understand the variability in quality across treatment programs.


Related Articles

  • The relationship between legal coercion and dropout from substance abuse treatment. Perron, Brian // BMC Psychiatry;2007 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Background Legal coercion is a popular method for leveraging substance abuse treatment among people who would otherwise not participate voluntarily. Although it is effective for getting people into treatment, the results have been mixed as to whether people who are legally coerced stay in...

  • Methadone center pays fine with a dose of reality. Segal, Marian // FDA Consumer;May94, Vol. 28 Issue 4, p32 

    Informs on a consent decree signed by a narcotics treatment center in New York City in which the center agrees to comply with all Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) regulations. The center's long history of violating government regulations; Reality House.

  • How to heal the body's craving. Mestel, Rosie; Concar, David // New Scientist;10/1/94, Vol. 143 Issue 1945, p32 

    Focuses on the methods and medicines used to treat addicts of their substance abuse problems. Use of ibogaine and methadone to treat heroin addiction; Overdosing of ibogaine; Heroin substitutes; Research on addiction; Behavioral tools in addiction treatment; Voucher-therapy treatment; Relapses....

  • St. Luke's substance abuse center gets state approval.  // Hudson Valley Business Journal;02/14/2000, Vol. 10 Issue 26, p3 

    Focuses on the state approval of the methadone treatment program at the Unity Center for Recovery of the Newburgh, New York-based Saint Luke's Hospital's Outpatient Substance Abuse Treatment Center. Reauthorization of the center to provide chemical dependency services to the community; Other...

  • Approach for treating methadone patients created.  // Healthcare Benchmarks & Quality Improvement;Jul2008, Vol. 15 Issue 7, p66 

    The article offers information about motivated stepped care (MSC) model, an approach for treating methadone patients. Developed by the addiction treatment team of Johns Hopkins Bayview Medical Center in Baltimore, Maryland, MSC puts patients demanding most medical attention under the care of the...

  • What to look for in methadone clinic software. Blumenthal, David; Stoddard, Ray // Behavioral Healthcare;May2006, Vol. 26 Issue 5, p35 

    Looks at the considerations for evaluating methadone clinic management software. Overview of timesaving functions of a substance abuse clinic; Ways to handle billing and payment; Usefulness of on-site software training.

  • Use of Illegally Acquired Medical Opioids by Opiate-Dependent Patients in Detoxification Treatment. Scherbaum, N.; Kluwig, J.; Meiering, C.; Gastpar, M. // European Addiction Research;2005, Vol. 11 Issue 4, p193 

    Take-home dosages in maintenance treatment are of great therapeutic importance, but they include the risk of the substitute being distributed illegally. We reviewed the extent of consumption of illegally acquired medical opiates by 142 opiate- or poly-addicted patients consecutively admitted to...

  • Using Choice Theory in Coerced Treatment for Substance Abuse. Mottern, Ron // International Journal of Reality Therapy;Fall2002, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p20 

    This paper briefly suggests how Choice Theory (CT) may be used in coerced treatment for substance abuse (SA). A differentiation is made between the total behaviors of law breaking with using (LBU), and using as a form of law breaking (U). How alcohol and other illegal drugs (AOD) serve to...

  • Short-course diphenoxylate hydrochloride for treatment of methadone withdrawal symptoms. Ives, T.J.; Stults, C.C. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Nov83, Vol. 143, p513 

    The authors conducted a preliminary trial of a 5-day course of diphenoxylate in the treatment of out-patients with methadone withdrawal symptoms. Diphenoxylate provided substantial relief from detoxification symptoms with no drug-associated adverse effects.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics