TITLE

Household vacuum cleaners vs. the high-volume surface sampler for collection of carpet dust samples in epidemiologic studies of children

AUTHOR(S)

Colt, Joanne S.; Gunier, Robert B.; Metayer, Catherine; Nishioka, Marcia G.; Bell, Erin M.; Reynolds, Peggy; Buffler, Patricia A.; Ward, Mary H.

PUB. DATE

January 2008

SOURCE

Environmental Health: A Global Access Science Source;2008, Vol. 7, Special section p1

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

Background: Levels of pesticides and other compounds in carpet dust can be useful indicators of exposure in epidemiologic studies, particularly for young children who are in frequent contact with carpets. The high-volume surface sampler (HVS3) is often used to collect dust samples in the room in which the child had spent the most time. This method can be expensive and cumbersome, and it has been suggested that an easier method would be to remove dust that had already been collected with the household vacuum cleaner. However, the household vacuum integrates exposures over multiple rooms, some of which are not relevant to the child's exposure, and differences in vacuuming equipment and practices could affect the chemical concentration data. Here, we compare levels of pesticides and other compounds in dust from household vacuums to that collected using the HVS3. Methods: Both methods were used in 45 homes in California. HVS3 samples were collected in one room, while the household vacuum had typically been used throughout the home. The samples were analyzed for 64 organic compounds, including pesticides, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), using GC/MS in multiple ion monitoring mode; and for nine metals using conventional microwave-assisted acid digestion combined with ICP/MS. Results: The methods agreed in detecting the presence of the compounds 77% to 100% of the time (median 95%). For compounds with less than 100% agreement, neither method was consistently more sensitive than the other. Median concentrations were similar for most analytes, and Spearman correlation coefficients were 0.60 or higher except for allethrin (0.15) and malathion (0.24), which were detected infrequently, and benzo(k)fluoranthene (0.55), benzo(a)pyrene (0.55), PCB 105 (0.54), PCB 118 (0.54), and PCB 138 (0.58). Assuming that the HVS3 method is the "gold standard," the extent to which the household vacuum cleaner method yields relative risk estimates closer to unity by increasing random measurement error varies by compound and depends on the method used to calculate relative risk. Conclusion: The household vacuum cleaner method appears to be a reasonable alternative to the HVS3 for detecting, ranking, and quantifying the concentrations of pesticides and other compounds in carpet dust.

ACCESSION #

35703159

Tags: VACUUM cleaners;  ENVIRONMENTAL sampling;  PESTICIDES;  DUST;  ORGANIC compounds

 

Related Articles

• Lunar dust buster designed to keep moon base spick and span. Robson, David // New Scientist;1/24/2009, Vol. 201 Issue 2692, p24 

  The article reports that lunar explorers have discovered that an exotic vacuum cleaner will attract moon dust using electrostatic forces. The new lunar dust buster allows astronauts to clean up and prevent dirt penetrating the moon base. Pamela Clark of the Catholic University of America,...

• Hijacking Your Cute Little Vacuum Bot. Wallich, Paul // Popular Science;Sep2003, Vol. 263 Issue 3, p34 

  The article focuses on Roomba, a vacuum cleaner produced by iRobot Corp., a Massachusetts-based company that also makes pack robots for the U.S. Defense Department. Roomba, which is a persistent floor cleaner, scoops up dust, wood chips, cat hair and other lightweight trash for anyone with no...

• Good for your carpets, great for your health.  // Country Living;Sep2003, Vol. 26 Issue 9, p79 

  Focuses on a vacuum cleaner manufactured by Royal Appliance Manufacturing Co.

• House dust mite products of little use.  // Practice Nurse;4/25/2008, Vol. 35 Issue 8, p10 

  The article reports on the results of a research by the Cochrane Collaboration Research group on house dust mite products. The group concluded that mattress protectors, vacuum cleaners and similar products designed to tackle house dust mites are largely ineffective. They found there was some...

• Keeping Carpets Clean. Wilson, Marianne // Chain Store Age;Apr2004, Vol. 80 Issue 4, p68 

  Presents tips to keep carpets clean and indoor environments healthy. Percentage of dirt on indoor carpet that is tracked in as people walk into buildings; Advantages of using vacuum cleaners with high efficiency particulate air-filtration systems.

• The dust devil. Temple, Ginny // Health (Time Inc. Health);May2005, Vol. 19 Issue 4, p64 

  Provides steps on getting rid of dust at home. Use of vacuum with a high-efficiency particulate air; Advantages of opening the windows; Purchase of upholstered furniture or carpet.

• A clean bill of health.  // RoSPA Occupational Safety & Health Journal;Sep2004, Vol. 34 Issue 9, p46 

  Explains the legal requirements and the solutions available from manufacturers for cleaning up dusts in industry without affecting people's health and safety. Importance of designing a cleaning process so that the occupational exposure limit of the dust is not exceeded; Requirement for choosing...

• An Equipment Approach To Dust Elimination. Mandell, Andy // Industrial Maintenance & Plant Operation;May2008, Vol. 69 Issue 5, p31 

  The article focuses on the ways on how to eliminate air borne particles in the workplace using equipment. Portable vacuum systems that are similar to a vacuum cleaner are ideal since they are portable and can be easily moved around the workplace. However, downdraft tables are sanding tables...

• A Fresh Couch -- Fast! Forte, Carolyn // Good Housekeeping;Apr2009, Vol. 248 Issue 4, p31 

  The article presents the author's suggestions for cleaning sofa and upholstered seats. Usage of a pair of clean rubber gloves to remove pet hair from a sofa is suggested by the author. According to the author, vacuum cleaner is the most effective tool to remove dust and debris. The author...

Read the Article