A factor analytic investigation of the Tripartite model of affect in a clinical sample of young Australians

Buckby, Joe A.; Cotton, Sue M.; Cosgrave, Elizabeth M.; Killackey, Eoin J.; Yung, Alison R.
January 2008
BMC Psychiatry;2008, Vol. 8, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Background: The Mood and Anxiety Symptom Questionnaire (MASQ) was designed to specifically measure the Tripartite model of affect and is proposed to offer a delineation between the core components of anxiety and depression. Factor analytic data from adult clinical samples has shown mixed results; however no studies employing confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) have supported the predicted structure of distinct Depression, Anxiety and General Distress factors. The Tripartite model has not been validated in a clinical sample of older adolescents and young adults. The aim of the present study was to examine the validity of the Tripartite model using scale-level data from the MASQ and correlational and confirmatory factor analysis techniques. Methods: 137 young people (M = 17.78, SD = 2.63) referred to a specialist mental health service for adolescents and young adults completed the MASQ and diagnostic interview. Results: All MASQ scales were highly inter-correlated, with the lowest correlation between the depression- and anxiety-specific scales (r = .59). This pattern of correlations was observed for all participants rating for an Axis-I disorder but not for participants without a current disorder (r = .18). Confirmatory factor analyses were conducted to evaluate the model fit of a number of solutions. The predicted Tripartite structure was not supported. A 2-factor model demonstrated superior model fit and parsimony compared to 1- or 3-factor models. These broad factors represented Depression and Anxiety and were highly correlated (r = .88). Conclusion: The present data lend support to the notion that the Tripartite model does not adequately explain the relationship between anxiety and depression in all clinical populations. Indeed, in the present study this model was found to be inappropriate for a help-seeking community sample of older adolescents and young adults.


Related Articles

  • Achieving and Sustaining Remission in Depression and Anxiety Disorders: Introduction. O'Donovan, Claire // Canadian Journal of Psychiatry;Mar2004 Supplement, Vol. 49, p5S 

    Major depressive disorder (MDD) is a prevalent medical condition that is frequently associated with comorbid psychiatric and medical conditions and has a high risk for morbidity and mortality (1). Approximately 8% of adults will experience MDD at some time in their lives, and the 1-year...

  • The Edmonton Symptom Assessment System as a Screening Tool for Depression and Anxiety. Vignaroli, Ernesto; Pace, Ellen A.; Willey, Jie; Palmer, J. Lynn; Tao Zhang; Bruera, Eduardo // Journal of Palliative Medicine;Apr2006, Vol. 9 Issue 2, p296 

    Purpose: Mood disorders are among the most important psychiatric problems in patients with cancer. However, they are frequently underdiagnosed and therefore undertreated. This may lead to difficulties with symptom control, social withdrawal, and poor quality of life. This study was conducted to...

  • Recurrence in affective disorder. Kessing, Lars Vedel; Andersen, Per Kragh; Mortensen, Preben Bo; Bolwig, Tom Gert // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jan98, Vol. 172, p23 

    Background In recent years, studies of the risk of recurrence in affective disorder in relation to the number of prior episodes have given contradictory results. Method Survival analysis was used to calculate the rate of recurrence after successive episodes in a case register study including all...

  • The occurrence of secondary affective disorder in an in-patient population with severe and recurrent affective disorder. Stancer, Harvey C.; Persad, Emmanuel; Jorna, Thecla; Flood, Christine; Wagener, Diane K.; Stancer, H C; Persad, E; Jorna, T; Flood, C; Wagener, D K // British Journal of Psychiatry;Jun84, Vol. 144, p630 

    One hundred and eighty nine consecutive in-patients with treatment-resistant affective disorder were administered the Renard Diagnostic Interview to determine whether the 45 with secondary affective disorder (SAD) differed from the 144 with primary affective disorder (PAD). The SAD group,...

  • The Relationship of Massage and Exercise to Mood Enhancement. Weinberg, Robert; Jackson, Allen; Kolodny, Kathleen // Sport Psychologist;Sep1988, Vol. 2 Issue 3, p202 

    The purpose of the present investigation was to assess the relationship between exercise, massage, and positive mood enhancement. Subjects were students in physical education classes including swimming, jogging, tennis, and racquetball, with each separate activity comprising a level of the...

  • Mood and whole blood adenosine triphosphate. Jenner, F. A.; Vlissides, Dimitrios N.; Kenyon, Patricia; Chard, N.; Grant, L.; Vlissides, D N; Kenyon, P // British Journal of Psychiatry;Nov75, Vol. 127, p478 

    The claim of Hansen (1969) and Hansen and Dimitrakoudi (1974) that whole blood adenosine triphosphate (ATP) levels correlate with depressed affect was examined. The findings from 84 patients failed to confirm any relationship between mood and whole blood ATP. One patient showing the highest...

  • RELATIONS AMONG POSITIVE AFFECT, NEGATIVE AFFECT, AND SOMATIC SYMPTOMS IN A MEDICALLY ILL... Kvaal, Steven A.; Patodia, Shobhana // Psychological Reports;Aug2000, Vol. 87 Issue 1, p227 

    Assesses the relationships among positive affect, negative affect and somatic symptoms and pain in a medically ill hospital population using the Positive and Negative Affect Scale (PANAS). Positive correlation of Positive Affect scores with pairs severity; Usefulness of the PANAS in assessing...

  • Use of health care services in seasonal affective disorder. Eagles, John M.; Howie, Fiona L.; Cameron, Isobel M.; Wileman, Samantha N.; Andrew, Jane E.; Robertson, Carol; Naji, Simon A.; Wileman, Samantha M // British Journal of Psychiatry;May2002, Vol. 180, p449 

    Background: Little is known about the presentation and management of seasonal affective disorder (SAD) in primary care.Aims: To determine the use of health care services by people suffering from SAD.Method: Following a screening of patients consulting in...

  • Genetics, molecular biology, neuropathology and phenotype of frontal lobe dementia: a case history. Lovestone, Simon; Philpot, Michael; Connell, James; Lantos, Peter; Powell, John; Russ, Carsten; Anderton, Brian // British Journal of Psychiatry;May2002, Vol. 180, p455 

    Background: Mutations in tau have been found in a group of related disorders including the frontal lobe dementias.Aims: To describe the clinical features and molecular pathology changes in a single case of a patient with frontal lobe dementia.Method: A case...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics