The importance of the concepts of disaster, catastrophe, violence, trauma and barbarism in defining posttraumatic stress disorder in clinical practice

Braga, Luciana L.; Fiks, Jose P.; Mari, Jair J.; Mello, Marcelo F.
January 2008
BMC Psychiatry;2008, Vol. 8, Special section p1
Academic Journal
Background: Several terms in the scientific literature about posttraumatic stress disorder are used with different meanings in studies conducted by different authors. Words such as trauma, violence, catastrophe, disaster and barbarism are often used vaguely or confusingly, and their meanings change in different articles. The lack of conceptual references for these expressions complicates the organization of literature. Furthermore, the absence of clear concepts may be an obstacle to clinical treatment because the use of these words by the patients does not necessarily point to a diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder. Discussion: A critical review of scientific literature showed that stress can be divided in stages to facilitate specific terminological adjustments to the event itself, to the subject-event interaction and to psychological responses. Moreover, it demonstrated that the varying concept of trauma expands into fundamental psychotherapeutic definitions and that the meanings of violence associated with barbarism are an obstacle to resilience. Therefore, this study updates the etymological origins and applications of these words, connects them to the expansions of meanings that can be operated in the clinical care of patients with posttraumatic stress disorder, and analyzes them critically according to the criterion A of DSM-IV and ICD-10. Summary: The terminology in the literature about posttraumatic stress disorder includes a plethora of terms whose meanings are not fully understood, and that, therefore, limit this terminology. The analysis of these terms suggested that the transformation of the concept of trauma led to a broader understanding of this phenomenon in its psychic dimensions, that a barbarian type of violence constitutes an obstacle to resilience, and that the criterion A of the DSM-IV and ICD-10 shows imprecision and conceptual fragilities. Methods: To develop this debate article, a current specialized literature review was achieved by searching and retrieving the key terms from two major databases: PubMed and PsycINFO. The key terms included "disaster", "catastrophe", "barbarism", "terrorism", "trauma", "psychic trauma" and "violence", also in combination with the terms "PTSD", "concept" and "conceptual aspects". The data were captured specially from review articles. The included studies were those mostly identified by the authors as relevant by the presence of a conceptual approach in any part of the paper. Researches that relied solely on empirical indicators, like psychopathological, neurobiological or pharmacological aspects, were excluded. The focus here was in conceptual aspects, even when some few empirical studies were included. As it was noted a paucity of medical references related to conceptual aspects of these terms, a wider literature needed to be included, including chapters, books and articles proceeded from the Humanities areas. "Interdisciplinary research is needed in this area to include perspectives from a range of different disciplines" once that "to promote public health (...) new dimensions of such interactions and the implications thereof should be pursued in collaboration with researchers from broader areas" [1].


Related Articles

  • Post-traumatic stress reactions among Rwandan children and adolescents in the early aftermath of genocide. Neugebauer, Richard; Fisher, Prudence W.; Turner, J. Blake; Yamabe, Saori; Sarsfield, Julia A.; Stehling-Ariza, Tasha // International Journal of Epidemiology;Aug2009, Vol. 38 Issue 4, p1033 

    The article presents a study on post-traumatic stress reactions among Rwandan children who survived the 1994 Rwandan genocide. The research involved an assessment by the National Trauma Survey (NTS) of children aged eight-19 for possible post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Among the results...

  • Introduction to a Special Issue on Research with Youth Exposed to Disasters and Violence. Carrión, Victor; Weems, Carl // Child & Youth Care Forum;Aug2013, Vol. 42 Issue 4, p257 

    An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses various reports within the issue on topics including disaster related trauma, the perspective for the establishment partnerships in trauma teams, and in building resilience for the teachers of children affected by war.

  • Individual differences in spatial configuration learning predict the occurrence of intrusive memories. Meyer, Thomas; Smeets, Tom; Giesbrecht, Timo; Quaedflieg, Conny; Girardelli, Marta; Mackay, Georgina; Merckelbach, Harald // Cognitive, Affective & Behavioral Neuroscience;Mar2013, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p186 

    The dual-representation model of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD; Brewin, Gregory, Lipton, & Burgess, Psychological Review, 117, 210-232 ) argues that intrusions occur when people fail to construct context-based representations during adverse experiences. The present study tested a specific...

  • Military and civilian disaster response and resilience: from gene to policy. Hamaoka, Derrick A.; Kilgore, Jocelyn A.; Carlton, Janis; Benedek, David M.; Ursano, Robert J. // Military Medicine;Jul2010 Supplement, Vol. 175, p32 

    Disasters, such as war, terrorism, and natural disasters, affect individuals, groups, and communities. Although the focus is often on post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), it is only one of many potential responses to traumatic experiences. Fostering community and individual resilience can help...

  • Trauma Through the Life Cycle: A Review of Current Literature. Straussner, Shulamith; Calnan, Alexandrea // Clinical Social Work Journal;Dec2014, Vol. 42 Issue 4, p323 

    This paper provides an overview of common traumatic events and responses, with a specific focus on the life cycle. It identifies selected 'large T' and 'micro' traumas encountered during childhood, adulthood and late life, and the concept of resilience. It also identifies the differences in...

  • Chapter 9: Contextual Influences on Posttraumatic Adjustment: Retraumatization and the Roles of Revictimization, Posttraumatic Adversities, and Distressing Reminders. Layne, Christopher M.; Warren, Jared S.; Saltzman, William R.; Fulton, John B.; Steinberg, Alan M.; Pynoos, Robert S.; Schein, Leon A.; Spitz, Henry I.; Burlingame, Gary M.; Muskin, Philip R.; Vargo, Shannon // Psychological Effects of Catastrophic Disasters;2006, p235 

    Chapter 9 of the book "Psychological Effects of Catastrophic Disasters: Group Approaches to Treatment" is presented. It explores the various uses of the term retraumatization. It defines serial trauma as repeated exposure to the same class of trauma. Vulnerability and protective processes...

  • An Integrated Model for Understanding and Developing Resilience in the Face of Adverse Events. de Terte, Ian; Becker, Julia; Stephens, Christine // Journal of Pacific Rim Psychology;May2009, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p20 

    The Five Part Model or Five Areas Model has been a pivotal component of cognitive behavioural therapy and the treatment of various psychological disorders. The Five Part Model consists of five components that represent the interaction of an individual's environment, thoughts, feelings,...

  • Community Mental Health Service Utilization After the L'Aquila Earthquake. Stratta, Paolo; Cataldo, Stefano; Bonanni, Roberto; Rossi, Alessandro // Community Mental Health Journal;May2015, Vol. 51 Issue 4, p504 

    This study investigated the use of the facilities for the mental health by the population affected by the L'Aquila (Italy) 2009 earthquake. The data about the activities of the Mental Health Centre of L'Aquila during the years from 2008 to 2010 were obtained by the service Information System. In...

  • Psychological distress and resources among siblings and parents exposed to traumatic events. Punamäki, Raija-Leena; Qouta, Samir; El Sarraj, Eyad; Montgomery, Edith // International Journal of Behavioral Development;Sep2006, Vol. 30 Issue 5, p385 

    We examined symmetries and asymmetries within family members' psychological distress and resources in general and when exposed to traumatic events in particular. PTSD and depressive symptoms indicated distress and resilient attitudes, and satisfaction with quality of life indicated resources. We...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics