Amazing Grace?

Cateau, Heather
June 2008
Journal of Caribbean History;2008, Vol. 42 Issue 1, p111
As we commemorate the bicentenary of the abolition of the trade in enslaved Africans, it is important that we reflect on the development of the historiography surrounding this important theme. This essay is aimed at a re-conceptualization of the people we have dubbed "The Abolitionists". It urges us to rethink our sometimes casual use of the term. The approach to this is two fold: a re-examination of the British anti-slavery leaders, and a reassessment of the role of resistance by enslaved people in the Caribbean, with specific focus on the Barbados revolt of 1816. The presence of the Antislavery Society and its supporters cannot be denied. However, Caribbeanists like C.L.R. James, Eric Williams, Hilary Beckles and Eugene Genovese have told another story. Building on the base that they established, this essay reminds us that the British "anti-slavers" were very much representative of their time, in so far as they shared the economic views and ideas inherent in the new philosophies that were emerging in their country. They were against enslavement, and they were for free trade; they were the new capitalists, and they were among the rising economic elite. Abolition was not due simply to humanitarian factors — much more was involved than amazing grace. The second part of the paper focuses on the Caribbean and adds another dimension. The role of the enslaved population in their emancipation, a growing field of research today, can be traced to two Trinidadians, James and Williams. Enslaved persons had insisted throughout enslavement on their right to be free. The nineteenth century added another dimension, as enslaved persons weighed in by making their feelings felt with every development in the metropole. These developments are important. They impacted on the emancipation debate that, up to this point, had pursued a course of gradualism based on the premise that an increasingly Creole enslaved population could be depended on for a controlled transition at some vague future date without any major disruption of the societies in question. In fact, ending the slave trade was greatly supposed to facilitate this change. Clearly, they had read the enslaved population wrongly. Their direction would have to change. The above factors clearly illustrate that to understand abolition we must look at both metropolitan and colonial developments.


Related Articles

  • 3: Nat Turner. Taylor, Kimberly Hayes // Black Abolitionists & Freedom Fighters;1996, p42 

    This chapter profiles African American abolitionist Nat Turner. When Nat Turner led his insurrection in 1831, he became the most feared slave in the United States. Although this uprising failed and Turner was executed, his actions sparked unrest among U.S. slaves and helped to keep alive the...

  • THE NELSON MANDELA METROPOLE AND THE ABOLITION OF THE OCEANIC SLAVE TRADE IN 1807. Shell, Robert C.-H. // Quarterly Bulletin of the National Library of South Africa;Jan-Mar2007, Vol. 61 Issue 1, p28 

    The article discusses the abolition of the oceanic slave trade in 1807. It was stated that the founding of Port Elizabeth in South Africa should be considered in its relationship to the abolition of the oceanic slave trade and the rise of the Exeter Hall abolitionists calling for the end of...

  • Faith in Action: Ending Slavery Together. Choi-Fitzpatrick, Austin // Tikkun;Jul/Aug2008, Vol. 23 Issue 4, p25 

    The article focuses on the issue of slavery. It reveals that the practice has been taking place in those least able to defend themselves, in which they were forced to work, with little or no pay, and being violated. The author also explores the move of several groups in responding to the issue....

  • The Northern Response to Slavery (1964).  // Left Out: The Politics of Exclusion: Essays 1964-2002;2002, p5 

    The article discusses the anti-slavery stance of the Northerners. Northerners are said to be more of the "nonextensionists" who prefer to indirectly address slavery by limiting its spread. Abolitionists, on the other hand, seek to destroy slavery wherever it existed. This attitude of the...

  • Changing Metropolitan Attitudes to the Transatlantic Slave Trade. Cobley, Alan Gregor // Journal of Caribbean History;2008, Vol. 42 Issue 1, p91 

    This paper discusses the widespread support in England for the development of transatlantic slavery during the seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. It demonstrates the inherent respectability of the trade so far as the English elite were concerned, who saw it as merely the latest and most...

  • Medidas abolicionistas en la Nueva Granada, 1814-18511. Restrepo, Eduardo // Revista CS;Jan-Jun2012, Issue 9, p235 

    The paper focuses on the analysis of the narrative of various abolitionist acts and the impact they had on the problematization of slavery. The author argues that, from the very beginning, the analysis of abolitionist acts manifests a contradiction with the independence discourse with regards to...

  • Women and the Abolition Campaign in the African Atlantic. Shepherd, Verene A. // Journal of Caribbean History;2008, Vol. 42 Issue 1, p131 

    The passing of the British Abolition Act in 1807 owed much to the activism of women, enslaved and free, who employed diverse strategies to agitate for the ending of what was arguably the greatest crime against humanity. Indeed, the partial ending of the trade, starting in 1805, acted as a...

  • VIRTUAL SLAVERY. Hecht, David // New Republic;05/12/97, Vol. 216 Issue 19, p9 

    Investigates claims that slavery persists in the African nation of Mauritania. Claims by some that slavery has been ended, while others maintain that it continues; Arguments pro and con; Evidence presented by anti-slavery activists to two congressional subcommittees on slave purchase in the...

  • Introduction. Hall, Catherine // History Workshop Journal;Oct2007, Vol. 64 Issue 1, p1 

    The article establishes the significance of commemorating the history of slavery, including the slave trade and its abolition, in Great Britain in 1807. Abolition of slavery in Great Britain has been significant in the history with two widely popular campaigns such as campaign against the slave...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics