Antibody-protein interactions: benchmark datasets and prediction tools evaluation

Ponomarenko, Julia V.; Bourne, Philip E.
January 2007
BMC Structural Biology;2007, Vol. 7, p64
Academic Journal
Background: The ability to predict antibody binding sites (aka antigenic determinants or B-cell epitopes) for a given protein is a precursor to new vaccine design and diagnostics. Among the various methods of B-cell epitope identification X-ray crystallography is one of the most reliable methods. Using these experimental data computational methods exist for B-cell epitope prediction. As the number of structures of antibody-protein complexes grows, further interest in prediction methods using 3D structure is anticipated. This work aims to establish a benchmark for 3D structure-based epitope prediction methods. Results: Two B-cell epitope benchmark datasets inferred from the 3D structures of antibodyprotein complexes were defined. The first is a dataset of 62 representative 3D structures of protein antigens with inferred structural epitopes. The second is a dataset of 82 structures of antibodyprotein complexes containing different structural epitopes. Using these datasets, eight web-servers developed for antibody and protein binding sites prediction have been evaluated. In no method did performance exceed a 40% precision and 46% recall. The values of the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve for the evaluated methods were about 0.6 for ConSurf, DiscoTope, and PPI-PRED methods and above 0.65 but not exceeding 0.70 for protein-protein docking methods when the best of the top ten models for the bound docking were considered; the remaining methods performed close to random. The benchmark datasets are included as a supplement to this paper. Conclusion: It may be possible to improve epitope prediction methods through training on datasets which include only immune epitopes and through utilizing more features characterizing epitopes, for example, the evolutionary conservation score. Notwithstanding, overall poor performance may reflect the generality of antigenicity and hence the inability to decipher B-cell epitopes as an intrinsic feature of the protein. It is an open question as to whether ultimately discriminatory features can be found.


Related Articles

  • Probing conformation and conformational change in proteins is optimally undertaken in relative mode. Errington, Neil; Rowe, Arthur J. // European Biophysics Journal;2003, Vol. 32 Issue 5, p511 

    Hydrodynamic bead modelling has been widely used in attempts to assess the 3D conformation of proteins in solution. Initially, simple models employing only a small number of beads were used, with a considerable degree of success. Latterly, high-resolution bead models based upon atomic...

  • The x-ray crystal structure of the membrane protein prostaglandin H(2) synthase-1. Picot, Daniel; Loll, Patrick J. // Nature;1/20/1994, Vol. 367 Issue 6460, p243 

    Reports on the x-ray crystal structure of the membrane protein prostaglandin H(2) synthase-1 (PGHS). Homology to peroxidases; Three independent folding units; Active sites for the haem-dependent peroxidase and cyclooxygenase activities; Interaction of PGHS with the lipid bilayer; Conformation...

  • The 1.7 Ã… X-Ray Crystal Structure of the Porcine Factor VIII C2 Domain and Binding Analysis to Anti-Human C2 Domain Antibodies and Phospholipid Surfaces. Brison, Caileen M.; Mullen, Steven M.; Wuerth, Michelle E.; Podolsky, Kira; Cook, Matthew; Herman, Jacob A.; Walter, Justin D.; Meeks, Shannon L.; Spiegel, P. Clint // PLoS ONE;Mar2015, Vol. 10 Issue 3, p1 

    The factor VIII C2 domain is essential for binding to activated platelet surfaces as well as the cofactor activity of factor VIII in blood coagulation. Inhibitory antibodies against the C2 domain commonly develop following factor VIII replacement therapy for hemophilia A patients, or they may...

  • Protein-ligand Docking: A Review of Recent Advances and Future Perspectives. Vaqu�, Montserrat; Ard�vol, Anna; Blad�, Cinta; Salvad�, M. Josepa; Blay, Mayte; Fern�ndez-Larrea, Juan; Arola, Llu�s; Pujadas, Gerard // Current Pharmaceutical Analysis;Feb2008, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p1 

    Understanding the interactions between proteins and ligands is crucial for the pharmaceutical and functional food industries. The experimental structures of these protein/ligand complexes are usually obtained, under highly expert control, by time-consuming techniques such as X-ray...

  • Structural interpretation of protein-protein interaction network. Katebi, Ataur R.; Kloczkowski, Andrzej; Jernigan, Robert L. // BMC Structural Biology;2010 Supplement 1, Vol. 10, Special section p1 

    Background: Currently a huge amount of protein-protein interaction data is available from high throughput experimental methods. In a large network of protein-protein interactions, groups of proteins can be identified as functional clusters having related functions where a single protein can...

  • Structural and functional characterization of Rpn12 identifies residues required for Rpn10 proteasome incorporation. BOEHRINGER, Jonas; RIEDINGER, Christiane; PARASKEVOPOULOS, Konstantinos; JOHNSON, Eachan O. D.; LOWE, Edward D.; KHOUDIAN, Christina; SMITH, Dominique; NOBLE, Martin E. M.; GORDON, Colin; ENDICOTT, Jane A. // Biochemical Journal;11/15/2012, Vol. 448 Issue 1, following p55 

    The ubiquitin-proteasome system targets selected proteins for degradation by the 26S proteasome. Rpn12 is an essential component of the 19S regulatory particle and plays a role in recruiting the extrinsic ubiquitin receptor Rpn10. In the present paperwe report the crystal structure of Rpn12, a...

  • Structural Basis for the Oligomerization-State Switch from a Dimer to a Trimer of an Engineered Cortexillin-1 Coiled-Coil Variant Bjelić, Saša; Wieser, Mara; Frey, Daniel; Stirnimann, Christian U.; Chance, Mark R.; Jaussi, Rolf; Steinmetz, Michel O.; Kammerer, Richard A. // PLoS ONE;May2013, Vol. 8 Issue 5, p1 

    Coiled coils are well suited to drive subunit oligomerization and are widely used in applications ranging from basic research to medicine. The optimization of these applications requires a detailed understanding of the molecular determinants that control of coiled-coil formation. Although many...

  • The structure of the periplasmic nickel-binding protein NikA provides insights for artificial metalloenzyme design. Cherrier, Mickaël; Girgenti, Elodie; Amara, Patricia; Iannello, Marina; Marchi-Delapierre, Caroline; Fontecilla-Camps, Juan; Ménage, Stéphane; Cavazza, Christine // Journal of Biological Inorganic Chemistry;May2012, Vol. 17 Issue 5, p817 

    Understanding the interaction of a protein with a relevant ligand is crucial for the design of an artificial metalloenzyme. Our own interest is focused on the synthesis of artificial monooxygenases. In an initial effort, we have used the periplasmic nickel-binding protein NikA from Escherichia...

  • Structure of the Full-Length Major Pilin from Streptococcus pneumoniae: Implications for Isopeptide Bond Formation in Gram-Positive Bacterial Pili. Paterson, Neil G.; Baker, Edward N. // PLoS ONE;2011, Vol. 6 Issue 7, p1 

    The surface of the pneumococcal cell is adorned with virulence factors including pili. The major pilin RrgB, which forms the pilus shaft on pathogenic Streptococcus pneumoniae, comprises four immunoglobulin (Ig)-like domains, each with a common CnaB topology. The three C-terminal domains are...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics