Design and Implementation of a System-Based Course in Musculoskeletal Medicine for Medical Students

Bilderback, Karl; Eggerstedt, Jane; Sadasivan, Kalia K.; Seelig, Leonard; Wolf, Robert; Barton, Shane; McCall, Richard; Chesson, Jr., Andrew L.; Marino, Andrew A.
October 2008
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Oct2008, Vol. 90-A Issue 10, p2292
Academic Journal
Background: The amount of time devoted to musculoskeletal medicine in the typical undergraduate curriculum is disproportionately low compared with the frequency of musculoskeletal complaints that occur in a general practice. Consequently, whether because of the quantity or quality of the education, the competence level of graduating physicians regarding musculoskeletal problems is inadequate. Our purposes were to design a self-contained, system-based course in musculoskeletal medicine for medical students in the preclinical years and to measure the level of competence achieved by a class of first-year medical students who took the course. Methods: The course was formulated by faculty from the departments of orthopaedic surgery, anatomy, and rheumatology and included elements of both objectives-based and problem-centered curricular models. The clinical lectures were preceded by pertinent anatomy lectures and dissections to provide a context for the clinical information. The lectures on basic science were designed to rationalize and explicate clinical practices. Small-group activities were incorporated to permit engagement of the students in critical thinking and problem-solving. A general musculoskeletal physical examination was taught in two two-hour-long small-group sessions with the orthopaedic residents serving as instwctors. Cognitive competency was evaluated with use of comprehensive anatomy laboratory and written examinations, the latter of which included a validated basic competency examination in musculoskeletal medicine. Process-based skills were evaluated in the small-group meetings and in a timed, mock patient encounter in which each student's ability to perform the general musculoskeletal physical examination was assessed. Results: The course lasted six weeks and consisted of forty-four lecture hours, seventeen hours of small-group meetings, and twenty-eight hours of anatomy laboratory. The average student score on the basic competency examination was 77.8%, compared with 59.6% for a historical comparison group (p <0.05). Each student demonstrated the ability to adequately perform a general musculoskeletal physical examination in twenty minutes. The survey of student opinion after the course indicated a high level of student satisfaction. Conclusions: The main features of the course were: (1) an emphasis on both cognitive and process-based knowledge; (2) more contact hours and broader content than in previously described courses in musculoskeletal medicine; (3) the use of small groups to focus on problem-solving and physical examination competencies; (4) basic-science content directly related to clinical goals. These features might be used at other institutions that employ a system-based curriculum forthe preclinical years to help improve competence in musculoskeletal medicine.


Related Articles

  • Boost to medical student numbers confirmed.  // New Zealand Doctor;9/9/2009, p10 

    The article focuses on the addition of 60 students who will begin training at Otago and Auckland Medical Schools in New Zealand in 2010, in line with the government's plan to strengthen the health workforce. The government has a desire to increase medical student places by 200 every year in a...

  • Should all medical students be graduates first? George, Charles // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);11/24/2007, Vol. 335 Issue 7629, p1073 

    The author reflects on the question of whether all medical students in Great Britain should be graduates before entering into five year medical courses. He suggests that there do not need to be modifications made to the country's current system. He argues that to do so would discriminate against...

  • Overcome barriers to effective workbased learning. Jedaar, Zareena; Marrin, Ceri; Pugsley, Lesley // Education for Primary Care;Nov2009, Vol. 20 Issue 6, p477 

    The article provides insights for medical students and trainees on how to overcome barriers to attain effective workbased learning (WBL). It stresses that it is vital for medical students and trainees to work and participate alongside with others and to adopt the behaviour and articles of the...

  • Survey of Palliative Care Concepts among Medical Interns in India. Bharadwaj, Parag; Vidyasagar, M.S.; Kakria, Anjali; Tanvir Alam, U.A. // Journal of Palliative Medicine;Jun2007, Vol. 10 Issue 3, p654 

    Background: Medical knowledge, if theoretical, will fade away if not reinforced especially if not clinically implemented. We conducted a survey study amongst interns to assess awareness and confidence of common palliative care issues. Undergraduate medical education in India is a 4½ -year...


    The article presents a summary of the paper presenting tips for using digital storytelling for reflective learning of medical students. It notes that digital storytelling is a novel technology for teaching. It offers tips in utilizing the method of digital storytelling, including deciding on a...

  • Improving Observation Skill in Physician Assistant Students. Garino, Alexandria // Journal of Physician Assistant Education (Physician Assistant Ed;2008, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p47 

    Purpose: The purpose of this study is to determine whether a 2-hour museum workshop, modeled after a program developed by Dr. Irwin Braverman and his colleagues at the Yale Center for British Art to improve medical students' observation skills, would improve the observation skills of the PA...

  • The Significance of Significance. Scoles, Peter V. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;2/15/2012, Vol. 94-A Issue 4, pe28-1 

    The article presents commentary on an article in this issue by Robert Grunfeld and colleagues, "An Assessment of Musculoskeletal Knowledge in Graduating Medical and Physician Assistant Students and Implications for Musculoskeletal Care Providers." The commentary argues that it is not appropriate...

  • Sneakers, muscles and science. Leyden, Michael B. // Teaching Pre K-8;Apr93, Vol. 23 Issue 7, p30 

    Discusses a method for teaching lessons on human muscles. Analogy of athletic shoes and muscles. Exploration lesson; Muscles occur in pairs; Construction of a model of the arm muscles; Similarities and dissimilarities between the elbow and knee systems; Lists the pronate/ supinate concept spin-offs.

  • Do As I Say: Curricular Discordance in Medical School End-of-Life Care Education. Rabow, Michael; Gargani, John; Cooke, Molly // Journal of Palliative Medicine;Jun2007, Vol. 10 Issue 3, p759 

    Purpose: Prior research indicates that medical students face significant personal and ethical challenges when they perceive differences between what is taught in class (formal curriculum) and what is practiced on the wards (informal curriculum). This study seeks to further describe the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics