Defining Substantial Clinical Benefit Following Lumbar Spine Arthrodesis

Glassman, Steven D.; Copay, Anne G.; Berven, Sigurd H.; Polly, David W.; Subach, Brian R.; Carreon, Leah Y.
September 2008
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Sep2008, Vol. 90-A Issue 9, p1839
Academic Journal
Background: Validated health-related quality-of-life measures have become important standards in the evaluation of the outcomes of lumbar spine surgery. However, there are few well-defined criteria for clinical success based on these measures. The minimum clinically important difference is an important demarcation, but it could be considered a floor value rather than a goal in defining clinical success. Therefore, we sought to define thresholds of substantial clinical benefit for commonly used health-related quality-of-life measures following lumbar spine arthrodesis. Methods: Prospectively collected preoperative and one-year postoperative health-related quality-of-life measures from 357 patients who were managed with lumbar spine arthrodesis for the treatment of degenerative conditions were identified. Candidate substantial clinical benefit thresholds for the Short Form-36 physical component score, Oswestry Disability Index, and back and leg pain numeric rating scales were identified with use of receiver operating characteristic curve analysis. Receiver operating characteristic curves were used to discriminate between patients who reported being "much better" or "about the same" with use of the validated Short Form-36 health transition item and between those who reported being "mostly satisfied" or "unsure" with use of a nonvalidated but more surgery-specific satisfaction-with-results survey. For each health-related quality-of-life measure, three response parameters were used: net change, percent change, and raw score at the time of the one-year follow-up. Results: Substantial clinical benefit thresholds for the Short Form-36 physical component score were a 6.2-point net improvement, a 19.4% improvement, or a final raw score of ≥35.1 points. Substantial clinical benefit thresholds for the Oswestry Disability Index were an 18.8-point net improvement, a 36.8% improvement, or a final raw score of <31.3 points. Substantial clinical benefit thresholds for the back pain and leg pain numeric rating scales were a 2.5-point net improvement or a final raw score of <3.5 points. Substantial clinical benefit thresholds for percent change were 41.4% for the back pain numeric rating scale and 38.8% for the leg pain numeric rating scale. Conclusions: We believe that thresholds of substantial clinical benefit for commonly used health-related quality-of-life measures following lumbar spine arthrodesis are important as they describe a magnitude of change that the patient recognizes as a major improvement.


Related Articles

  • Lumbar Discectomy Outcomes Vary by Herniation Level in the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial. Lurie, J. D.; Faucett, S. C.; Hanscom, B.; Tosteson, T. D.; Ball, P. A.; Abdu, W. A.; Frymoyer, J. W.; Weinstein, J. N. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Sep2008, Vol. 90-A Issue 9, p1811 

    Background: The Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial showed an overall advantage for operative compared with nonoperative treatment of lumbar disc herniations. Because a recent randomized trial showed no benefit for operative treatment of a disc at the lumbosacral junction (L5-S1), we reviewed...

  • Video-Assisted Thoracoscopic Spinal Fusion Compared with Posterior Spinal Fusion with Thoracic Pedicle Screws for Thoracic Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis. Lonner, Baron S.; Auerbach, Joshua D.; Estreicher, Michael; Milby, Andrew H.; Kean, Kristin E. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Feb2009, Vol. 91-A Issue 2, p398 

    Background: Although the gold standard for the surgical treatment of thoracic adolescent idiopathic scoliosis has been posterior spinal fusion, video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery recently has become a viable alternative. In the treatment of structural thoracic curves, video-assisted...

  • Tratamiento postquirúrgico de hernia discal lumbar en rehabilitación. Revisión sistemática. Santana-Ríos, J. S.; Chávez-Arias, D. D.; Coronado-Zarco, R.; Cruz-Medina, E.; Nava-Bringas, T. // Acta Ortopedica Mexicana;Mar/Apr2014, Vol. 28 Issue 2, p114 

    Various programs and interventions are available for the rehabilitation of patients who have undergone surgery for symptomatic lumbar disc herniation (LDH). Our aim is to determine the value of the different rehabilitation interventions included in the postoperative treatment of patients with...

  • Canadian Association of General Surgeons and American College of Surgeons Evidence-Based Reviews in Surgery. 27. Latosinsky, Steve; Dabbs, Kelly; Moffat, Frederick // Canadian Journal of Surgery;Dec2008, Vol. 51 Issue 6, p483 

    The article reports on the results of research which was conducted in an effort to compare quality of life and arm morbidity outcomes among patients with clinically node negative invasive breast cancer who received either sentinel lymph node biopsy or standard axillary treatment. Researchers...

  • Free-living physical activity in COPD: Assessment with accelerometer and activity checklist. Moy, Marilyn L.; Matthess, Kirby; Stolzmann, Kelly; Reilly, John; Garshick, Eric // Journal of Rehabilitation Research & Development;2009, Vol. 46 Issue 2, p277 

    To assess physical activity and disability in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), we evaluated the use of an accelerometer and checklist to measure free-living physical activity. Seventeen males with stable COPD completed a daily activity checklist for 14 days. Ten subjects...

  • Health related quality of life after combined hormone replacement therapy: randomised controlled trial. Welton, Amanda J.; Vickers, Madge R.; Kim, Joseph; Ford, Deborah; Lawton, Beverley A.; MacLennan, Alastair H.; Meredith, Sarah K.; Martin, Jeannett; Meade, Tom W. // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);9/6/2008, Vol. 337 Issue 7669, p550 

    Objective To assess the effect of combined hormone replacementtherapy (HRT) on health related quality of life. Design Randomised placebo controlled double blind trial. Setting General practices in United Kingdom (384), Australia (94), and New Zealand (24). Participants Postmenopausal women aged...

  • Dysphagia in Stroke: A New Solution. Langdon, Claire; Blacker, David // Stroke Research & Treatment;2010, p1 

    Dysphagia is extremely common following stroke, affecting 13%-94% of acute stroke sufferers. It is associated with respiratory complications, increased risk of aspiration pneumonia, nutritional compromise and dehydration, and detracts from quality of life. While many stroke survivors experience...

  • Preoperative determinants of outcomes of laparoscopic gastric bypass in the treatment of morbid obesity. García Díaz, E.; Martín Folgueras, T. // Nutricion Hospitalaria;jul/ago2011, Vol. 26 Issue 4, p851 

    Introduction: Laparoscopic gastric bypass (LGBP) is the predominant technique in surgical treatment of morbid obesity. Objectives: To evaluate the results of LGBP and measure the validity of some hypothetical variables as predictors of these outcomes. Methods: We carried out a historical cohort...

  • The use of MelMax® in the healing of chronic wounds. Jones, Menna Lloyd // British Journal of Nursing;6/11/2009, Vol. 18 Issue 11, pS30 

    Chronic wounds can have detrimental consequences for the quality of life of patients as well as presenting a huge financial burden to the NHS. An imbalance in the level of matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) and the tissue inhibitors of MMPs (TIMPs) in chronic wounds impedes the healing process. In...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics