Older Patients' Unexpressed Concerns About Orthopaedic Surgery

Pamela L. Hudak; Kristy Armstrong; Clarence Braddock, III; Richard M. Frankel; Wendy Levinson
July 2008
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Jul2008, Vol. 90-A Issue 7, p1427
Academic Journal
Background: As the U.S. population ages, orthopaedic surgeons will increasingly be required to counsel older patients about major surgical procedures. Understanding patient concerns or worries about surgery could help orthopaedic surgeons to assist their patients in making these decisions. The objectives of this study were to explore the nature of patient concerns regarding orthopaedic surgery and to describe how patients raise concerns during visits with orthopaedic surgeons and how orthopaedic surgeons respond. Methods: As part of a study involving audiotaping of 886 visits between patients and orthopaedic surgeons, fifty-nine patients sixty years of age or older who were considering surgery were recruited to participate in semistructured telephone interviews at five to seven days and one month after the visit. Patients were asked about their perceptions of the visit and how they made their decision about surgery. These interviews were analyzed to identify patients' concerns with the use of qualitative content analysis and then compared with the audiotaped visits to determine whether these concerns were actually raised during the visit and, if so, how well the orthopaedic surgeons responded. Analyses based on patient race (black or white) were also performed. Results: One hundred and sixty-four concerns pertaining to (1) the surgery (anticipated quality of life after the surgery, the care facility, the timing of the operation, and the patient's capacity to meet the demands of the surgery) and (2) the surgeons (their competency, communication, and professional practices) were identified. Patients raised only 53% of their concerns with the orthopaedic surgeons and were selective in what they disclosed; concerns about the timing of the operation and about the care facility were frequently raised, but concerns about their capacity to meet the demands of the surgery and about the orthopaedic surgeons were not. Orthopaedic surgeons responded positively to 66% of the concerns raised by the patients. Only two concerns were raised in response to direct surgeon inquiry. Conclusions: Patients raised only half their concerns regarding surgery with orthopaedic surgeons. Orthopaedic surgeons are encouraged to fully address how patients' capacity to meet the demands of the surgery, defined by their resources (such as social support, transportation, and finances) and obligations (to family members, employers, and religion), may impinge on their willingness to accept recommended surgery.


Related Articles

  • PUBLISHER'S NOTE. Schneider, Frank // Reflections;2012, Vol. 12 Issue 3, pii 

    An introduction is presented in which the author discusses various reports within the issue on topics including the patient-doctor communication, the physical and psychological aspects of surgical treatment and the improvement of the overall health of local communities.

  • Surgery Lite. Oz, Mehmet // Time;12/13/2010, Vol. 176 Issue 24, p53 

    The author offers opinions on surgery and the physician-patient relationship. The concept of minimally invasive surgery is said to be a subjective one which is best defined by the patient's willingness to undergo the procedure. It is noted that surgeons are likely to regard relatively minor...

  • Avoid dysmorphic patients, senior surgeon cautions. Nash, Karen // Cosmetic Surgery Times;Jun2005, Vol. 8 Issue 5, p16 

    Reports on the lecture by cosmetic surgeon Mark Gorney on dysmorphic patients at the American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery's Aesthetic Meeting 2005 in New Orleans, Louisiana. Advice for surgeons to avoid dysmorphic patients because their problems are not physical; Causes of dysmorphic...

  • Septorhinoplasty-Aspects of the Consultation and Patient Selection. Eynon-Lewis, Nick // Otolaryngology: Current Research;2012, Vol. 2 Issue 4, Special section p1 

    The article discusses the psychological aspects of patient selection and expectation in septorhinoplasty surgery. The surgeon needs to consult with patients to ascertain his or her psychological preparation before undergoing the procedure. Sans questionnaires about the mental fitness of the...

  • Futility and the Care of Surgical Patients: Ethical Dilemmas. Grant, Scott; Modi, Parth; Singer, Eric // World Journal of Surgery;Jul2014, Vol. 38 Issue 7, p1631 

    Futility has been a contentious topic in medicine for several decades. Surgery in critical or end-of-life situations often raises difficult questions about futility. In this article, we discuss the definition of futility, methods for resolving futility disputes, and some ways to reframe the...

  • PRACTICE PERFECT. Controlling Patient Expectations. SHAPIRO, JARROD // Podiatry Management;Jun/Jul2012, Vol. 31 Issue 5, p49 

    The article discusses the benefits that podiatrists and their patients will find from entering into conversations about what each expects from surgical treatment which is provided to the patients. In the article the author offers his opinions on differences in the expectations of surgical...

  • Listening to tapes improves surgery outcomes.  // Modern Medicine;Sep96, Vol. 64 Issue 9, p3 

    Reports on the research finding that pre- and post-surgery patients who listen to soothing music and tape-recorded readings that suggest positive outcomes heal better and feel better. Positive result from listening to music.

  • Helping Children Cope During and After Medical Treatment and Procedures.  // People's Medical Society Newsletter;Dec2002, Vol. 21 Issue 6, p4 

    Reports the findings of a study on the psychological effect of medical procedures on children.

  • Psyched-op.  // Men's Health (10544836);Jun94, Vol. 9 Issue 5, p82 

    Discusses various aspects of why patients fare better undergoing surgery when they know all the details of the surgery. European researchers found patients had better mood, less pain and medication, shorter hospital stays and quicker recoveries.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics