Comparison of the Collagen Meniscus Implant with Partial Meniscectomy: A Prospective Randomized Trial

Rodkey, William G.; Dehaven, Kenneth E.; Montgomery III, William H.; Baker Jr., Champ L.; Beck Jr., Charles L.; Hormel, Scott E.; Steadman, J. Richard; Cole, Brian J.; Briggs, Karen K.
July 2008
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Jul2008, Vol. 90-A Issue 7, p1413
Academic Journal
Background: Loss of meniscal tissue leads to increased pain and decreased clinical function and activity levels. We hypothesized that patients receiving a collagen meniscus implant would have better clinical outcomes than patients treated with partial medial meniscectomy alone. Methods: Three hundred and eleven patients with an irreparable injury of the medial meniscus or a previous partial medial meniscectomy, treated by a total of twenty-six surgeon-investigators at sixteen sites, were enrolled in the study. There were two study arms, one consisting of 157 patients who had had no prior surgery on the involved meniscus (the `acute" arm of the study) and one consisting of 154 patients who had had one, two, or three prior meniscal surgical procedures (the "chronic" arm). Patients were randomized either to receive the collagen meniscus implant or to serve as a control subject treated with a partial meniscectomy only. Patients underwent frequent clinical follow-up examinations over two years and completed validated outcomes questionnaires over seven years. The patients who had received a collagen meniscus implant were required by protocol to have second-look arthroscopy at one year to determine the amount of new tissue growth and to perform a biopsy to assess tissue quality. Reoperation and survival rates were determined. Results: In the acute group, seventy-five patients received a collagen meniscus implant and eighty-two were controls. In the chronic group, eighty-five patients received the implant and sixty-nine were controls. The mean duration of follow-up was fifty-nine months (range, sixteen to ninety-two months). The 141 repeat arthroscopies done at one year showed that the collagen meniscus implants had resulted in significantly (p = 0.001) increased meniscal tissue compared with that seen after the original index partial meniscectomy. The implant supported meniscus-like matrix production and integration as it was assimilated and resorbed. In the chronic group, the patients who had received an implant regained significantly more of their lost activity than did the controls (p = 0.02) and they underwent significantly fewer non-protocol reoperations (p = 0.04). No differences were detected between the two treatment groups in the acute arm of the study. Conclusions: New biomechanically competent meniscus-like tissue forms after placement of a collagen meniscus implant, and use of the implant appears safe. The collagen meniscus implant supports new tissue ingrowth that appears to be adequate to enhance meniscal function as evidenced by improved clinical outcomes in patients with a chronic meniscal injury. The collagen meniscus implant has the utility to be used to replace irreparable or lost meniscal tissue in patients with a chronic meniscal injury. The implant was not found to have any benefit for patients with an acute injury.


Related Articles

  • New Knee Surgery Prevents Arthritis.  // Prevention;Jan2002, Vol. 54 Issue 1, p128 

    Reports on a surgical technique that saves the meniscus in the knee, rather than removing it, after it has been damaged.

  • Pullout strength of meniscal repair after cyclic loading: comparison of vertical, horizontal, and oblique suture techniques. Kocabey, Yavuz; Taser, Omer; Nyland, John; Doral, Mahmut; Demirhan, Mehmet; Caborn, David; Sarban, Sezgin; Doral, Mahmut Nedim; Caborn, David N M // Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy;Oct2006, Vol. 14 Issue 10, p998 

    This in vitro biomechanical study with cyclic loading compared the pullout strength of vertical, horizontal, and oblique sutures used for meniscal lesion repair. Following repair of vertical longitudinal lesions created in bovine medial menisci, three groups of seven specimens (vertical,...

  • A pull out suture for transection of the posterior horn of the medial meniscus: using a posterior trans-septal portal. Ahn, Jin; Wang, Joon; Yoo, Jae; Noh, Haeng; Park, Jung; Ahn, Jin Hwan; Wang, Joon Ho; Yoo, Jae Chul; Noh, Haeng Kee; Park, Jung Ho // Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy;Dec2007, Vol. 15 Issue 12, p1510 

    A transection (root tear or complete radial tear) injury of the medial meniscus posterior horn is not rare in the oriental area and needs to be repaired to restore the hoop tension and to reduce the extruded meniscus, which leads to osteoarthritis of the knee. In cases with transection of the...

  • Discoid lateral meniscus: diagnosis and results of arthroscopic treatment. Asik, Mehmet; Sen, Cengiz; Taser, Omer F.; Alturfan, Aziz K.; Sozen, Yunus V. // Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy;Mar2003, Vol. 11 Issue 2, p99 

    We evaluated the results of arthroscopic meniscectomy in patients with discoid lateral menisci of the knee. Discoid lateral menisci were detected in 308 patients, of whom 197 (124 males, 73 females; mean age 34.5 years, range 6-67) were clinically, radiologically, and arthroscopically found to...

  • The meniscus: past, present and future. Verdonk, René // Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy;Feb2011, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p145 

    The author chronicles the impact of meniscal treatment algorithms on knee treatment and surgery. The therapeutic regimen for knee lesions evolved from arthroscopic approaches and techniques in 1883 to resection and meniscal replacement in 1975 onwards. An innovation in the treatment options is...

  • Repaired meniscal root tears most affected by rotational force and compressive load. Rapp, Susan M. // Orthopedics Today;Jul2010, Vol. 30 Issue 7, p25 

    The article announces that the study about the impact of several factors on repaired medical meniscus root tears by Christian Stärke of the Orthopaedics Department at the University Hospital Magdeburg was given teh 2010 Theo van Rons Award by European Society of Sports Traumatology, Knee...

  • Determination of the safe penetration depth during all-inside meniscal repair of the posterior part of the lateral meniscus using the FasT-Fix suture repair system. Abouheif, Mohamed; Shibuya, Hayatoshi; Niimoto, Takuya; Kongcharoensombat, Wirat; Deie, Masataka; Adachi, Nobuo; Ochi, Mitsuo // Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy;Nov2011, Vol. 19 Issue 11, p1868 

    Purpose: The objective of this study was to determine the safe penetration depth of the FasT-Fix meniscal suture repair system during all-inside repair of the posterior part of the lateral meniscus. Methods: Thirty-one knees from 17 embalmed and formalin-fixed cadavers (11 women, 6 men) were...

  • Combined medial meniscal transplantation and high tibial osteotomy. Bonasia, Davide Edoardo; Amendola, Annunziato // Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy;Jul2010, Vol. 18 Issue 7, p870 

    This study describes a new surgical technique for combined medial meniscal transplantation and opening wedge high tibial osteotomy for meniscal-deficient knees with malalignment. The technique allows wider medial joint opening, better visualization of the medial compartment as well as easier...

  • Meniscus suture. Eriksson, Ejnar // Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy;Dec2006, Vol. 14 Issue 12, p1231 

    The article presents an editorial looking at different techniques for meniscus suture, including outside-in, inside-out, and all-inside meniscus repair. In the article the author describes his experience with the ESSKA-AOSSM travelling fellows and their trip to the U.S. where Tom Rosenberg...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics