March 2008
Journal of International Political Theory;Mar2008, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p55
Academic Journal
Notions such as ‘guilt’ and ‘forgiveness’ can be defined in objective terms, but more normally have an emotional dimension that cannot be experienced by the institutions examined in this collection of articles. Nevertheless, analogs to these emotions can be discerned in the behaviour of states – and exploring these reveals important insights into what are more (and less) effective ways of responding to, and making amends for, institutional failure. In the 1990s the Western powers were engaged in dealing with a sequence of crises which appeared to call for some kind of intervention – Bosnia 199195, Somalia 19923, Haiti, 19934, Rwanda 1994, Kosovo 19989 – and this essay explores the extent to which it can be said that action/inaction in one case can be related back to moral judgements of behaviour in earlier cases. What emerges is not a single narrative of guilt and rectificatory action, but two narratives focusing on different referent objects: obligations towards one's own citizens and toward the putative common good. The picture is complex, yet some significant lessons can be drawn from this analysis. One is the counter-intuitive point that a ‘guilty conscience’ may actually be more effective when the guilt in question is not attributable to the individual whose behaviour is affected, but rather is seen to be borne by the institution that he or she represents. Assuming that guilt is generated by ignorance rather than ill-will, another, more general, lesson is that better intelligence in the broadest sense of the term – including intelligence of the past moral failures of institutions – may be of more value than a (probably difficult to achieve) theory of institutional guilt.


Related Articles

  • Sociology of Nostalgia: Sport Halls of Fame and Museums in America. Snyder, Eldon E. // Sociology of Sport Journal;1991, Vol. 8 Issue 3, p228 

    Nostalgia is an important emotion in society that also has significance for the analysis of sport. Two types of nostalgia are discussed: collective and private nostalgia. The data for this paper were qualitative and collected at sport halls of fame, museums, and archives. Data collection...

  • How to Handle Death in the School. Stevenson, Robert G.; Powers, Harry L. // Education Digest;May1987, Vol. 52 Issue 9, p42 

    The article discusses how to handle death in schools. When one considers that each year one out of every 750 young people will die or be killed, the urgency of establishing a procedure for informing students of "bad news" becomes obvious. Young people are looking for models or standards for...

  • The What, Why, and Where of the Alternatives Movement. Fantini, Mario D. // Education Digest;Nov1985, Vol. 51 Issue 3, p139 

    The article presents information on an alternative educational movement in the U.S. There is an alternative schools movement beginning in this country that could very well become the major thrust of reform in the decades ahead. This trend toward educational diversity has grown out of several...

  • Getting help.  // Current Health 2;May85, Vol. 11 Issue 9, p14 

    The time and place to get help when emotions are out of control. When hospitalization may be necessary. How do you know if you need help? A list of classic warning signs.

  • Jealous? Envious? Goodman, S. // Current Health 2;Dec88, Vol. 15 Issue 4, p22 

    Discusses the emotional feelings of jealousy and envy which are often used interchangeably, but are not the same. Defines and distinguishes the two emotions. Offers suggestions for handling these feelings.

  • Why you're shy. Kamberg, M.L. // Current Health 2;Nov89, Vol. 16 Issue 3, p27 

    Discusses shyness, what causes it and how to deal with it. INSET: Are animals shy? How to relax..

  • The many faces of anger. Arbetter, M.R. // Current Health 2;Jan1990, Vol. 16 Issue 5, p4 

    Discusses the emotion of anger and its biological, social and psychological causes. Displacement or suppression; Handling anger. INSET: Is anger a problem for you?.

  • Reacting to rejection.  // Current Health 1;Nov89, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p22 

    Discusses how to deal with rejection. Reasons for rejection; Different reactions; Dealing with fears.

  • What are you feeling?  // Current Health 1;Jan1990, Vol. 13 Issue 5, p3 

    Discusses feelings, what they are, and how to deal with them. Recognizing, accepting and communicating feelings. INSET: Color me happy (discusses how colors can affect your feelings)..


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics