Identification of Children's Stuttered and Nonstuttered Speech by Highly Experienced Judges: Binary Judgments and Comparisons With Disfluency-Types Definitions

Bothe, Anne K.
August 2008
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Aug2008, Vol. 51 Issue 4, p867
Academic Journal
Purpose: The purposes of this study were (a) to determine whether highly experienced clinicians and researchers agreed with each other in judging the presence or absence of stuttering in the speech of children who stutter and (b) to determine how those binary stuttered/nonstuttered judgments related to categorizations of the same speech based on disfluency-types descriptions of stuttering. Method: Eleven highly experienced judges made binary judgments of the presence or absence of stuttering for 600 audiovisually recorded 5-s speech samples from twenty 2- to 8-year-old children who stuttered. These judgments were compared with each other and with disfluency-types judgments in multiple interval-by-interval assessments and by using multiple definitions of agreement. Results: Interjudge agreement for the highly experienced judges in the binary stuttered/ nonstuttered task varied from 39.0% to 89.1%, depending on methods and definitions used. Congruence between binary judgments and categorizations based on disfluency types also varied depending on methods and definitions, from 21.6% to 100%. Conclusions: Agreement among highly experienced judges, and congruence between their binary judgments of stuttering and categorizations based on disfluency types, were relatively high using some definitions and very low using others. These results suggest the use of measurement methods other than those based on disfluency types for quantifying or describing children's stuttering. They also suggest both the need for, and potential methods for, training to increase judges' accuracy and agreement in identifying children's stuttering.


Related Articles

  • The Kids' Speech.  // Working Mother;Jun/Jul2011, Vol. 34 Issue 5, p93 

    The article offers tips on how to help kids from stuttering through speaking slowly, keeping questions simple, and listening to children with patience.

  • A control/experimental trial of an operant treatment for early stuttering. Onslow, Mark; Andrews, Cheryl // Journal of Speech & Hearing Research;Dec94, Vol. 37 Issue 6, p1244 

    Presents a study designed to replicate and expand the findings of M. Onslow, L. Costa and S. Rue in 1990 on verbal response-contingent stimulation (RCS) as an effective treatment for stuttering in children younger than 5 years. Treatment program; Outcome measures; Measurement reliability.

  • Bivariate Genetic Analyses of Stuttering and Nonfluency in a Large Sample of 5-Year-Old Twins. van Beijsterveldt, Catharina Eugenie Maria; Felsenfeld, Susan; Boomsma, Dorret Irene // Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Jun2010, Vol. 53 Issue 3, p609 

    Purpose: Behavioral genetic studies of speech fluency have focused on participants who present with clinical stuttering. Knowledge about genetic influences on the development and regulation of normal speech fluency is limited. The primary aims of this study were to identify the heritability of...

  • Phonotactic Probability Effects in Children Who Stutter. Anderson, Julie D.; Byrd, Courtney T. // Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Aug2008, Vol. 51 Issue 4, p851 

    Purpose: The purpose of this study was to examine the influence of phonotactic probability, which is the frequency of different sound segments and segment sequences, on the overall fluency with which words are produced by preschool children who stutter (CWS) as well as to determine whether it...

  • Comparisons of Audio and Audiovisual Measures of Stuttering Frequency and Severity in Preschool-Age Children. Rousseau, Isabelle; Onslow, Mark; Packman, Ann; Jones, Mark // American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology;May2008, Vol. 17 Issue 2, p173 

    Purpose: To determine whether measures of stuttering frequency and measures of overall stuttering severity in preschoolers differ when made from audio-only recordings compared with audiovisual recordings. Method: Four blinded speech-language pathologists who had extensive experience with...

  • Serving children with limited English proficiency in the schools: A national survey. Roseberry-McKibbin, Celeste A.; Eicholtz, Glenn E. // Language, Speech & Hearing Services in Schools;Jul94, Vol. 25 Issue 3, p156 

    Presents findings of a national survey of public school clinicians to assess their services to limited English proficient (LEP) children. Ethnic group served most-commonly by clinicians; Type of treatment most frequently provided for LEP children; Percentage of respondents who did not speak a...

  • BULLIES IN BLACK ROBES.  // Editor & Publisher;11/26/2001, Vol. 134 Issue 46, p12 

    Editorial. Comments on the decision of judges motivated by personal pique. Attention of press organization to jailed writer Vanessa Leggett; Prohibition to news outlets not to publish names of jurors; Dismissal of Richard Weinberger case.

  • ORDER IN THE COURT. Miller, Holly G. // Saturday Evening Post;Sep/Oct2006, Vol. 278 Issue 5, p62 

    The article presents an interview with judge Judith Sheindlin of Los Angeles, California. She shares that she inherited the communication skills of her father. The judge mentions that she understands the importance of family and the complexity of marriage. According to Sheindlin, her affection...

  • Linguistic Development in Stuttering Children. Pamplona, M.; Ysunza, A.; Gonz├ílez, F. // Open Otorhinolaryngology Journal;2008, Vol. 2, p1 

    Normal fluency errors usually appear during language development, especially during the transition between the stages of one-word and simple phrases. In cases of stuttering the speaker produces several involuntary repetitions of phonemes, syllables, or words. The speaker can also show phoneme...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics