Governing the Hollow State

Milward, H. Brinton; Provan, Keith G.
April 2000
Journal of Public Administration Research & Theory;Apr2000, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p359
Academic Journal
For the past ten years the authors have conducted a concentrated research program on the dimensions and impact of the hollow state. The hollow state is a metaphor for the increasing use of third parties, often nonprofits, to deliver social services and generally act in the name of the state. The types of structures, incentives, and mechanisms used to control third-party providers have been the focus of this research. The empirical thrust of this research is on how effective various types of mechanisms, structures, and incentives are at promoting the effectiveness of contracted services. The normative question this research has raised, but not answered, is, What effect does government contracting with third-party providers have on the perceived legitimacy of the state ?This article is a summary of the theoretical development and the empirical findings from the authors' research on the dimensions and impact of the hollow state in the domain of health and human services contracting. Elements of this article have appeared previously in this journal and in many others as well. The article's purpose is to integrate the authors' research on the hollow state. This is a summative article that seeks to bring together in one place what the authors have learned. In addition, new directions are explored for future research on the hollow state.


Related Articles

  • Clothed With The Public Interest. Frederickson, H. George // PA Times;Apr2003, Vol. 26 Issue 4, p11 

    Discusses the expansion of the role played by third-party service providers in public administration in the U.S. Comparison between public and government administration; Question of accountability with regards to public functions outsourced to private service providers; Definition of public...

  • State Agent or Citizen Agent: Two Narratives of Discretion. Maynard-Moody, Steven; Musheno, Michael // Journal of Public Administration Research & Theory;Apr2000, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p329 

    In street-level work discretion is inevitable. Scholars have articulated a dominant view or narrative that addresses the role of discretion in the administrative state. This state-agent narrative acknowledges inevitability of discretion and emphasizes that self-interest guides street-level...

  • SUBSIDIARITY: A TOOL FOR THE OMBUDS. Robardet, Patrick // Optimum Online;Sep2009, Vol. 39 Issue 3, p7 

    The article discusses the role of an ombudsman. It points out that the main objective of an ombudsman is to correct the wrong deeds of public authorities that affect the citizens by obtaining reparation, case by case, through meek interventions. However, the author thinks that ombudsmen failed...

  • THE EFFICACY OF EXTRA-JURISDICTIONAL FACILITATION OF ELECTORAL PARTICIPATION:A STUDY OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION. Sykes, Vernon // Administrative Theory & Praxis (Administrative Theory & Praxis);Jun2001, Vol. 23 Issue 2, p285 

    Deals with a study which examined interventions designed to enhance professional public administrative appointees' facilitation of electoral participation but it excludes both legislative and administrative elected officials. Results of the study.

  • Representing Interventions from the Base of the Pyramid. Jagtap, Santosh; Kandachar, Prabhu // Journal of Sustainable Development;2010, Vol. 3 Issue 4, p58 

    The base of the world economic pyramid, generally called the base of the pyramid (BoP), consists of four billion people with average per day income of four dollars. While some authors suggest a systems approach to design and develop products and services (i.e. interventions) for BoP markets, a...

  • The Influence of Scale Preferences on the Design of a Water Innovation: A Case in Dutch River Management. Vreudenhil, Heleen; Slinger, Jill; Kater, Emiel; Thissen, Wil // Environmental Management;Jul2010, Vol. 46 Issue 1, p29 

    The debate on scale use in river management focuses primarily on the (lack of) fit between the bio-geophysical and institutional systems. However, in this article we focus on the ‘subjective’ aspect of scale preferences in water governance. We apply an adapted version of the...

  • Why outsourcing may be the key for heftier profit margins. Smith, Pedro // Caribbean Business;5/2/1996, Vol. 24 Issue 17, pS5 

    States that outsourcing traditional human resources services could be a company's answer to reducing overheads in return for large profit margins. Company's reorganization of internal employee benefits issues by hiring other firms to do the job for them; What are the implications; What...


    Government contracting has become a common practice at all levels of governments. However, the motivations behind government make-or-buy decisions are still not well understood. Public management operates in a complex organizational environment, integrating both political and pragmatic forces....

  • ADMINISTRATIVE REFORM ENHANCING PEOPLE PARTICIPATION IN LOCAL AFFAIRS. Ciprian, Ungureanu; Gabriela, Nemtoi; D�mbu, Dumitru // Journal of Law & Psychology;Sep2010, Vol. 1 Issue 1, p37 

    Administrative reform indicates a series of interventions that are promoted by political or administrative bodies and introduced to adapt public administration to economic and social change. There is no equivalent to such interventions in the private sector, where the word reform is not used....


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics